SERVING MINNEAPOLIS / ST. PAUL / MINNESOTA
Donate Now Sustaining Member


Our major sponsors




Sponsor of
Second Opinion



Our major advertisers


Our in-kind partners


MinnPost thanks these generous donors:

INDIVIDUALS AND FOUNDATI0NS
Blandin Foundation
Otto Bremer Foundation
Bush Foundation
Sage & John Cowles
David & Vicki Cox
Toby & Mae Dayton
Jack & Claire Dempsey
Ethics and Excellence in Journalism Foundation
Sam & Stacey Heins
John S. and James L. Knight Foundation
Joel & Laurie Kramer
Lee Lynch & Terry Saario
Martin & Brown Foundation
The McKnight Foundation
The Minneapolis Foundation
The Saint Paul Foundation
Rebecca & Mark Shavlik

(See all donors here.)

BrauBlog

  • Switch to Small Text Size
  • Switch to Medium Text Size
  • Switch to Large Text Size
Email Print Submit a Comment

    John Kline: For the 'Slaughter Solution' before he was against it

    By David Brauer | Published Wed, Mar 17 2010 9:55 am

    I’ve written my share of single-source blog posts, so I don’t want to pretend every one must contain a ton of research.  But a Strib Hot Dish Politics post touching on the day’s biggest issue — health care reform — let a Minnesota Congressman’s attack go uncontextualized.

    The source was John Kline, and the post focused mostly on his defense of federal subsidies to student-loan middlemen such as banks. I would’ve had a bit more fun tweaking the conservative Kline about the his ardor for private-sector giveaways, but reporter Eric Roper did a good job framing both sides of the issue, including Kline’s legitimate complaint about embedding student lending in the health care bill.

    The stumble occurred at the end:

    Kline also expressed frustration with the latest legislative tactic being proposed to pass the health care bill, the so-called Slaughter Solution. It would involve the House voting on the fixes to the Senate bill without voting on the bill itself, deeming it to have already passed.

    Describing the Slaughter Solution to reporters, Kline stopped mid-sentence and remarked, seemingly to himself, "It's incredible to even think about it."

    Well, maybe not so incredible. As political analysts had noted throughout the day, Republicans had used the “Slaughter Solution” — also called "deem-and-pass" — repeatedly when they controlled Congress. The American Enterprise Institute’s Norm Ornstein mocked the GOP attacks, pointing to one vote in particular, “a $40 billion deficit reduction package so that … GOPers could avoid an embarrassing vote on immigration.”

    Ornstein told me the bill was House Resolution 653, which passed in 2006 with as bare a majority as health care reform might — 216 to 214.  In other words, every vote was critical. Not every Minnesota Republican voted with the 100 percent GOP majority — Jim Ramstad dissented — but among the “aye” voters: John Kline.

    As Ornstein wrote of deem-and-pass objectors, “I can’t recall a level of feigned indignation nearly as great as what we are seeing now from congressional Republicans and their acolytes at the Wall Street Journal, and on blogs, talk radio, and cable news.”

    Fairness compels me to note that Ornstein expressed his own disdain for deem-and-pass. Also, as the national media pressed the hypocrisy point, Republican complaints morphed from the tactic itself to using it on something as huge and long-lasting as health care reform.

    Still, given how often hypocrisy is a default political position, the Strib should have held Kline more accountable for his own voting record.

    Like what you just read? Support high-quality journalism in Minnesota by becoming a member of MinnPost.

    Advertisement:

    14 Comments: Hide/Show Comments

    E-mail address

    Password

     

    Forgot Password? | Register to Comment

    MinnPost does not permit the use of foul language, personal attacks or the use of language that may be libelous or interpreted as inciting hate or sexual harassment. User comments are reviewed by moderators to ensure that comments meet these standards and adhere to MinnPost's terms of use and privacy policy.

    We intend for this area to be used by our readers as a place for civil, thought-provoking and high-quality public discussion. In order to achieve this, MinnPost requires that all commenters register and post comments with their actual names and place of residence. Register here to comment.



    minnpost.com/braublog

    David Brauer authors Braublog and is MinnPost's local media reporter. He's covered media and politics as a writer and editor since 1983 for City Pages, the Southwest/Downtown Journal, KFAN and KSTP-AM, Mpls.St.Paul, Minnesota Monthly, Law & Politics, the Business Journal, KARE11 and national outlets. Follow him on Twitter. Email: dbrauer [at] minnpost [dot] com. 


    MinnPost on Facebook

    Recent BrauBlog posts