Star Tribune accepts ad criticizing Target and Best Buy, two of its biggest advertisers

Statewide political campaigns don't spend much on newspaper ads these days. However, a national gay-rights group says the Star Tribune will publish its ad Sunday protesting Target's and Best Buy's donation to MnForward, a big-business group supporting GOP gubernatorial candidate Tom Emmer.
The Human Rights Campaign ad does not name Emmer, but notes that "MN Forward ... hopes to install one of the most strident opponents of equality in the Minnesota Governor’s mansion."
Emmer, a state representative, opposes gay marriage and in 2008, his House campaign donated to a punk-rock ministry critics say affirmed gay and lesbian executions. Emmer's gubernatorial campaign issued a statement opposing such violence in late May.
HRC, which gives Target and Best Buy a consistent 100 percent rating on its Corporate Equality Index, walks the tightrope between the company's internal and external actions. Noting both corporations' diverse workforces, the ad states, "As a community, we are grateful for that commitment and we fully expect it will continue," while noting "you have severely damaged those carefully cultivated reputations and violated the spirit of the gold standards bestowed on you. In fact, the long-term effects on families that shop at Target and Best Buy throughout Minnesota and the U.S. will be devastating."
The group says "the very least" Target and Best Buy can do is "make equivalent donations togroups that support candidates who will put all Minnesota families first andfulfill the promises of our highest ideals."
In accepting the advocacy ad, the Strib is allowing HRC to criticize two of the paper's biggest advertisers. The paper recently spiked a campaign that attacked public officials in the Tom Petters case; that led to a court fight the paper easily won.
It will be interesting to see if groups supporting Emmer, MnForward, Target or Best Buy respond to the HRC ad and further swell the Strib's coffers.
More like this
Recent Stories
Most Commented
-
40 comments
-
34 comments
-
21 comments
-
16 comments
-
11 comments
Comments (11)
The Petters ad campaign was hardly comparable to the Target/Best Buy ad. On what grounds would the STrib reject the Target/Best Buy ad?
Target says it funds Emmer so that he will favour business interests, that is Target stores. Isn't this buying politicians to legislate to maximise profits what has got the U.S. economy (and everyone else's) in such a mess?
In any case, we used to drive south to shop, particularly at Target. No more.
Hal -
The Strib advocacy ad agreement says they can reject any ad for any reason. Which means they don't need grounds.
However, if they did reject it, they would reap the whirlwind. Better to accept it, cash the check, and remain open to dissenting speech should someone else write a check.
Money is the mother's milk of politics. Media benefits from campaign advertising. Call it short term economic stimulus to the media industry. With classified and auto ad revenues in the dumper (craigslist). I would think the Strib is grateful for revenue streams of most any variety.
Dave: I don't think we disagree at all with the STrib's action on the Target/Best Buy ad. I was only saying it is a different animal than the Petters kerfluffle.
Why is this story being given such a big play? Isn't that the way politics works? The homosexual community is unhappy so they purchased an ad. Wouldn't be the first time that has happened.
And the Strib needs the money. The ex-Strib employees at MinnPost surely must know that.
Do you think Target will stop advertising in the Strib because of one ad read by maybe 15% of the people who read the Sunday paper?
No Ray, Target will not quit advertising in the Star Tribune. In this market, the PP doesn't reach as far as the Strib.
What this ad could do is make other businesses think hard about the potential consequences of putting corporate dollars into PACs, third-party funds, or candidates directly.
On the whole, I have been impressed with the Star Tribune's coverage of this issue. It can't be easy to cover a story that many Star Tribune subscribers think reflects negatively on one of the paper's biggest advertisers, which is also one of this town's biggest power players.
With Target's support of diversity and the Pride events, it seems as though they would need to contribute millions more to MN Forward and other such organizations if balance is what the latest ad is really asking for.
I was in Target today.
Didn't happen to see anyone filling carts to buy and return, or leftist bloggers following to film the event.
Long lines and ringing cash registers; just another day.
But don't let that disturb your dream....pffft.
Most Minnesotans will fare no better than gays will under Tom Emmer. It's sad to see Minnesota self-destruct on extreme right-wing Tea Party politics, while Target and Best Buy cheer the destruction of Minnesota along.