Skip to Content

Support MinnPost

Norquist, Klobuchar find common ground on immigration reform

norquist photo
Anti-tax activist Grover Norquist has also has been a big supporter of immigration reform proposals.

Get MinnPost's top stories in your inbox

Related Tags:

About the Author:

Comments (2)

I'm not impressed

The fact that both Norquist and Klobuchar are in favor of the Gang of Eight's immigration plan does not make it a good deal. It will ruin employment opportunities for low-skill workers, and our welfare costs will skyrocket if the plan becomes law. And forget legislation that is advertised as "comprehensive." That means the details will be hidden in a lot of words.
The first thing that should be done is end chain immigration, where family members get to immigrate here no matter how uneducated they are. The second, build an Israeli-style fence at 100 percent of the southern border. After that, we can deal with the illegal immigrants already here.

EVEN MORE TAXES TO SUPPORT ANOTHER AMNESTY?

Every American should scrutinize the uncomfortable details of S.744, as hidden in the terminology given Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano “Carte Blanche” on provisions, so she has complete discretion of handling the security at the border. Upsetting as it maybe, the real fencing was never built according to the legislation of upgrading on former Presidents Bush’s watch. The two parallel east to west fences was compromised by Texas Senator Kay Bailey Hutchinson; taking away the funding? This inevitably been one of the prime reason, this country is inundated with illegal immigrants from across the border. The Gang of 8, better revitalize this double layer fence, so enforcement from illegal aliens and criminals is their paramount goals? It should be essential that the U.S. Border Patrol has full access and a right to take out spotters persons on mountains, who are being used to inform drug cartels of the agents whereabouts, and no place along the border should be out of bounds to this enforcement, including tribal and national park sectors.

Although the use of the electronic E-Verify detection program has had much success and that if this impending Amnesty is enacted, mandatory E-verify would cut back on unauthorized workers stealing jobs. However, Congress should review a national biometric ID card and its major attributes that although expensive to issue to all Americans, overtime would far outweigh the cost of this official identity card. It would significantly halt foreign nationals from being hired, stop voter fraud so no non citizen would be equipped with this card and only people who had been verified with the ID card, would be able to attain credit. Other possibilities would surface such as insurance, weapons purchase and even car registration. Such a document would identify the user to clerks and officials for welfare and other entitlements. Of course there are critics that have much to say about privacy and civil rights, but in truth our freedoms are already under this administration to take away our right to bear arms, and take away our basic rights. AFTER READING THE HERITAGE FOUNDATION ANALYSIS OF THE COST FOR SUPPORTING ILLEGAL ALIENS, FROM “CRADLE TO GRAVE” IT DETERMINES THAT THE BREATHLESS COST OF THIS AMNESTY MUST NOT HAPPEN? AS AN INDEPENDENT MODERATE OR ANY POLITICAL PARTY OR GROUP WE DESERVE THE TRUTH? THAT WILL NOT COME FROM THE LEFT AND THEIR OPEN BORDER MANIA, AND THEIR AGENDA IS OUT TO BRING TO ITS KNEES OUR GREAT NATION.

ALREADY ILLEGAL ALIENS THROUGH THEIR IMMEDIATE CITIZEN CHILDREN ARE COLLECTING FOOD STAMPS, WELFARE, HEALTH CARE, SCHOOLING AND CASH PAYMENTS, THAT THE PARENTS NEVER PAID A CENT TOO? THIS IS JUST ANOTHER PAYOUT CRAFTILY ADMINISTERED TO BY PRESIDENT OBAMA AGENCIES AND PREVIOUS ADMINISTRATIONS. DEMAND FROM YOUR WASHINGTON POLITICIANS THAT ONLY CHILDREN OF AT LEAST ONE CITIZEN PARENT, GUARANTEES U.S. CITIZENSHIP. We have been shackled to this part of the misinterpreted law for decades, when it was only to award the successors of the Civil War slaves.

NOW WE MUST ACT or we will sponsor our own financial demise/? Hundreds of billions of dollars are collected through taxes to support illegal aliens, when these huge amounts should go towards a leaking Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid (for citizens, not illegal foreigners) mental health and a whole range of other things.

NOW is the time to begin an incessant offensive on all politicians at the state and federal level of government? Specifically to every U.S. senator, not just the so-called “Gang of Eight” and urge them, no demand no comprehensive immigration Reform and NO path to citizenship. Many senators are doing everything achievable to pretend there would be no mind boggling tax hikes for making some 80 federal welfare programs plus all entitlements available to millions of mostly uneducated, low-skilled illegal aliens. These U.S. Senators have themselves unfortunately collected an earful from plenty of billionaires and special-interest lobbyists, unions, who stand to make huge profits or gain some advantage from a concession labor facet of this amnesty. You only have to listen to prominent, seriously minded Senators as Jeff Sessions of Arkansas that this bill called Border Security, Economic Opportunity, and Immigration Modernization Act or S.744, has major problems. REMEMBER THIS IS NOT JUST ABOUT ENFORCEMENT AT THE BORDERS, BUT THE ESTIMATED 46 PERCENT THAT LIE TO AGENTS, WHEN THEY OVERSTAY VISAS AND INTENTIONALLY IGNORE U.S. ARRIVAL AND DEPARTURE LAWS WHEN USING THE AIRLINES AND FERRIES?

There are approximately 400 waivers, exemptions and hidden advantages for illegal immigrants, but a financial death knell for taxpayers. The Heritage Foundation has just released its latest analysis of the amnesty provisions of the Gang of Eight's immigration bill. Top analyst Robert Rector has determined that if the 11 million illegal aliens living in the United States receive amnesty, it will have a net cost to taxpayers of $6.3 Trillion! Call your Members of Congress toll-free -- 1-888-978-3065 -- and tell them about the costs and urge them to oppose amnesty. Now, right now each Senator needs to hear from millions of taxpayers who say NO to promote that "cheap" labor with $6.3 trillion price tag. We hope citizens are making sure that their Senators' phones are ringing off the hook, or free faxes at numbersusacom jamming the core switchboard in Washington, with messages of pressure from THE PEOPLE and not the corporate welfare special favors division of this administration.