Educating: someone’s gotta do it. On being a Jew in the armed forces
“I’ve never seen a Jew before.” He went up on his toes and craned his neck, his eyes searching my head. His sweet Kansas City accent suddenly sour.
“Looking for something?” My voice thick, I resisted the urge to clear my throat. I could hear blood pounding in my ears, my anger beginning to boil. I knew damn well he was looking for horns.
He rocked back on his heels, embarrassment rising in his cheeks. “I uh, um . . .” His voice trailed off as he looked away. I informed him he was an idiot for thinking that and didn’t speak to him for the rest of our training.
I was the only Jew in my guard unit back in NH and a few of the soldiers were fascinated with that. On drill weekends I would be peppered with questions about holidays, foods and traditions. Usually I was happy, or at least willing, to educate. One of the other Staff Sergeants occasionally would check in with me and make sure it was alright, that none of the questions were offending me. The right to religious observance/freedom is taken seriously in the military. This doesn’t mean I get every holiday off, but rather that I am not discriminated against. The needs of the military will always come first.
Having someone look for horns on my head tho? That’s a bit much.
The second day at Fort Sill’s reception battalion we were told to speak up if we needed any specific or unique religious accommodations. Kosher meals were mentioned so I spoke up. I was hoping to get a few kosher MRE’s. At the next meal the Student First Sergeant (1SG) took my request (and me) up to the person in charge of the dining facility (D-Fac). I had a hunch it wasn’t going to go well.
“What’s Kosher?” I didn’t want to get into it, I had no expectations of getting a hot kosher meal at the D-Fac. The Student 1SG asked me to explain. I did. “Well, you don’t have to take the bacon, we have sausage.” She was confused by my explanations but still trying to help. I shook my head, thanked her and went back to my iceberg salad meal plan.
At Charlie Company where we would start our Warrior Transition Training, we sat on the painted concrete floor around our First Sergeant as he gave us the low down for the next 9 weeks and took questions. He went over the religious services schedule and I raised my hand, asking about Jewish services. He didn’t know, but thought they were on Friday night. He told me he would do his best to accommodate me and promised I would be allowed holiday observance for Purim.
I was fortunate and able to make nearly all Friday services during the 9 week course. It wasn’t uncommon for there to only be 2 other soldiers in attendance, 1 Jewish and 1 battle buddy. When I was there in ’09 services were run by a very nice Chaplain. He introduced himself to me as a “Torah Observant Christian” from Alabama. The closest translation of which I can come up with is Messianic Jew. He and his family lit candles Friday night, his son wore a kippah, they had mezuzahs up on their door posts and were all completely and devoutly in love with Jesus. Those Friday night services were bizarre.
A week into training I admitted to one of my curious drill instructors (DI) why I was only eating salads and cereal. He kindly suggested I have someone mail me sustenance and issued me a “kosher food profile.” (which equates to a permission slip for non D-Fac food). Boyfriend (now Husband) took to mailing me weekly packages stocked with Powerbars, Clif Kids Fruit Ropes, Sunflower seeds, anything nonperishable bearing a hechsher.
For my birthday Uncle Sam issued me an M-16 and Boyfriend sent me a Tiffany’s necklace. This gift was met with the quasi-question, “So it’s true. All Jews are rich?”
One of my bunkmates assumed Boyfriend was a Rabbi when she heard me saying the Modeh on the phone with him every morning.
Another female was even brazen enough to ask about the hole in the sheet. I was disappointed that of all things to know about Jews that was her factoid. She was disappointed to learn that it is in fact a myth.
I was able to help educate my not so kind DI’s about the word “kike”. I believed him when he said he didn’t know what it meant. I also believe you shouldn’t say things you don’t know the meaning of. The 1SG was happy to help me file an EO complaint and I’m sure that my DI was shipped off to get some sensitivity training. A hiccup in his career.
With close to 3 million soldiers in US Army and less than 5,000 of them Jewish I’m not surprised to find ignorance and questions. It gets old and tiresome but it’s also a little bit fun. I like explaining that “no, a Rabbi didn’t bless my food.”
Of course there are days I would prefer to blend in and not have the fancy kosher MRE meal that stands out like a sore thumb, or to not be the one heading out to chow early on Friday so I can make services, but as long as the Army is willing to work with me, I will be continue to answer questions, dispel stereotypes and proudly represent The Tribe in my Army Combat Uniform.
This post was written by Emily Ozer and originally published on TC Jewfolk. Follow TC Jewfolk on Twitter: @tcjewfolk.
If you blog and would like your work considered for Minnesota Blog Cabin, please submit our registration form.
Recent Stories
Most Commented
-
27 comments
-
24 comments
-
22 comments
-
19 comments
-
18 comments
Comments (4)
In my eight years on active duty
I never met anyone from Wyoming and I never met anyone who was Jewish.
Given Wyoming's sparse population (500,000) I suppose the chances are pretty slim that a person in the military would ever encounter a Wyomingite. But there are over 5 million Jews in this country, 10 times the number of Wyomingites. So the odds should be much greater that I should have met SOMEONE from the Jewish faith while serving in the military. But I did not.
During boot camp, religious services were not only encouraged, they were mandatory. But they were only on Sunday and they were either Catholic or Protestant. So it appears that was the norm and that the military establishment was not expecting Jews to sign up in great numbers any time soon.
I often wondered why the people of the Jewish faith had such little representation in the American military. I wonder if the author has any theories.
My theory
Mr. Tester,
Many Jews in Ms. Ozer's situation, or ones who served with you in the military, may have chosen to not self-identify, specifically to avoid the types of interactions Ms. Ozer describes. You may very well have served with a number of Jews; but as we really don't have horns, you may not have known them. It's just as well for you that you did not make the acquaintence of my father, Col. Donald Greenberg. He served for 30 years in the US Army (active duty, including Vietnam; and reserves) and did not suffer fools or sideways bigotry.
Stats
I have no theories really. We can do some math though! I like math. Numbers make things more clear - at least for me. So, after a bit of research I found that only 10% of the US population serves in the military, and only 2.2% of the US population identify as Jews - either culturally or religiously. Never mind that a lot of them (like a lot of the population in it's entirety) are ineligible for service due to old age, disability, weight, flat feet etc. (Did you know that over 50% of the population is ineligible? Crazy!) Turns out with the close to 5,000 Jews in uniform we're statistically over represented when you take that stat into account.
Anyway - back to the basic math -
Recap: 10% of the entire population serves, 2.2% of the entire population is Jewish. So -if Jews were to be proportionally represented that's only .2% of the military that would be Jewish. Currently there are about 4 million active and reserve members of the US Military (my numbers above about the Army include the National Guard) - which means that only 8,000 service men and women would have "Jewish" on their dog tags. You have a better chance of meeting a Jew than a Wyomingite but the odds still aren't in your favor.
I've met 2 other Tribe members so far so the way I see it - I'm way ahead of the curve. Bonus that one of them is a Major General. :)
Also - to address the whole services thing... If services are mandatory and your only options are Catholic or Protestant... where's a Jew to go?
I'm going to go before this reply ends up longer than the initial post! Thank you very much for reading and thanks for commenting! :)
Aspersions
Mr. Tester;
Perhaps you would like to pose your question to someone at the Jewish War Veterans of America. http://www.jwv.org/.
Such organizations were founded in part to counter tiresome aspersions such as yours.
Ms. Ozer,
Thanks for the interesting article.