Skip to Content

Paul Brandon

Paul Brandon's picture
Mankato, MN
Commenter for
5 years 18 weeks

Recent Comments

Posted on 04/18/13 at 02:03 pm in response to Trouble ahead: Justices’ rulings on gun rights raise thorny questions

The Founders had more important things to worry about than junior high school grammar. And 18th century grammatical practices were more variable than they are now -- there was no national core curriculum.
Read some of the writings from the time.

Posted on 04/18/13 at 07:30 pm in response to Trouble ahead: Justices’ rulings on gun rights raise thorny questions

Kennedy and Humphrey were paraphrasing the language of the Second Amendment; their statements have the same basic ambiguity as the Amendment itself.
As with the Founders, he was quite literate. If he had meant 'individual' he would have said so. As it is, the most that can be said is that he endorses the right of citizens to bear arms when they are enrolled in the National Guard ('a well regulated militia').
Also note that there is nothing there about -owning- firearms; just...

Posted on 04/18/13 at 07:48 pm in response to Trouble ahead: Justices’ rulings on gun rights raise thorny questions

the 'tenther' argument could be used to dismiss the rest of the Federal and State Constitutions beyond their literal and original meaning, which become irrelevant as circumstances change with time. It limits the national government to only those powers stated in the Constitution.
The amendment:
"The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."
It does nothing...

Posted on 04/19/13 at 11:36 am in response to Trouble ahead: Justices’ rulings on gun rights raise thorny questions

that you'd say that?

Posted on 04/19/13 at 01:39 pm in response to Trouble ahead: Justices’ rulings on gun rights raise thorny questions

The only people who believe in Communism are latter day McCarthyites.
Even the Russians and Chinese don't believe in Communism any more.
If you know any in Minnesota, they must be over 80 by now.
Of course, you may be referring to anyone to the Left of Ghengis Khan, rather than people who actually identify themselves as Communists.

Posted on 04/19/13 at 01:52 pm in response to Trouble ahead: Justices’ rulings on gun rights raise thorny questions

see Snopes:
http://www.snopes.com/politics/guns/dickact.asp
What the Act did was set up the National Guard as the Constitutional equivalent of the Militia.

Posted on 04/20/13 at 10:07 am in response to Trouble ahead: Justices’ rulings on gun rights raise thorny questions

And it's obviously not illegal if good Amurican patriots do it.

Posted on 04/17/13 at 12:21 pm in response to Gun rights in the 1780s and today

It boils down to 'the rule of law, not men (or guns)'.

Posted on 04/17/13 at 12:25 pm in response to Gun rights in the 1780s and today

the ballot box is exactly what some of these people fear; a perversion of 'the tyranny of the majority'.

Posted on 04/17/13 at 01:17 pm in response to Gun rights in the 1780s and today

the militia ARE the people.