Nonprofit, independent journalism. Supported by readers.


Death penalty is too expensive for states, study finds

State and local governments facing budget crunches can realize big savings by eliminating the death penalty, according to a new report from the Death Penalty Information Center.

A group opposing capital punishment is urging government officials to reassess the costs and benefits of the death penalty in light of America’s economic troubles.

State and local governments facing dire budget crunches can realize substantial savings by replacing capital punishment with a regime that sentences the worst offenders to life in prison without parole, according to a report released Tuesday by the Death Penalty Information Center (DPIC).

The number of death sentences handed down in the United States has dropped from roughly 300 a year in the 1990s to 115 a year more recently. Executions are falling off at the same rate, the report says.

In the meantime, some 3,300 inmates remain on death row.

Article continues after advertisement

“[T]he death penalty is turning into a very expensive form of life without parole,” said Richard Dieter, DPIC executive director, in a statement. “At a time of budget shortfalls, the death penalty cannot be exempt from reevaluation alongside other wasteful government programs that no longer make sense.”

Despite the report’s findings, the death penalty has the support of most Americans. According to an October 2008 Gallup survey, 64 percent of Americans favor the death penalty for a person convicted of murder. Thirty percent oppose it.

Only once in the past 70 years (in 1966-67) did more Americans oppose capital punishment than support it, the poll results show. In that time span, 47 percent opposed it, while 42 percent supported it.

The DPIC study does not address American attitudes toward capital punishment. Instead, the report focuses on the economic costs.

A 2008 study in California found that the state was spending $137 million a year on capital cases. A comparable system that instead sentenced the same offenders to life without parole would cost $11.5 million, says the DPIC report, citing the study’s estimates.

New York spent $170 million over nine years on capital cases before repealing the death penalty. No executions were carried out there.

New Jersey spent $253 million over 25 years with no executions. That state also repealed capital punishment.

Some officials may be tempted to try to cut capital-punishment costs, notes the DPIC report, but many of those costs reflect Supreme Court-mandated protections at the trial and appeals-court levels. “The choice today is between a very expensive death penalty and one that risks falling below constitutional standards,” the report says.

Nationwide, the report estimates, at least $2 billion has been spent since 1976 for costs that wouldn’t have been incurred if the severest penalty were life in prison. The figure is based on an estimate in a 1993 North Carolina study that found the average extra cost of a death sentence in this state was $300,000. The average extra cost of capital punishment is significantly higher in several other states like California, Florida, and Maryland, the report says.

Article continues after advertisement

Bills calling for an end to capital punishment have been introduced in 11 state legislatures this year. Also this year, New Mexico abolished the death penalty, and Maryland narrowed its use. The Connecticut governor vetoed a law that would have ended capital punishment.

The DPIC report includes the results of a recent poll of 500 police chiefs nationwide. Fifty-seven percent of the chiefs polled said they agreed with the statement that the death penalty does little to prevent violent crimes because perpetrators rarely consider the consequences when engaged in violence.

Thirty-nine percent of police chiefs disagreed with this statement.

The DPIC study concludes that capital punishment is a wasteful, expensive program that no longer makes sense. “The promised benefits from the death penalty have not materialized,” the report says. “If more states choose to end the death penalty, it will hardly be missed, and the economic savings will be significant.”