Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.

The Minneapolis Foundation generously supports MinnPost's Community Sketchbook coverage. Learn why.

Catholic Charities CEO: St. Paul’s Dorothy Day Center is overwhelmed

MinnPost file photo by Jana Freiband
The current facility was opened in 1981 as a daytime drop-in center offering coffee and sweet rolls to homeless people.

A proposal to relocate the Dorothy Day Center to St. Paul’s East Side was abruptly pulled off the table this week because of neighborhood opposition.

The plan to move services for homeless and low-income persons from Dorothy Day’s location near the Xcel Energy Center to an East Gateway site was touted in December by a mayoral task force representing members of faith, business, government and nonprofit communities.

But by early March the Payne Phalen Planning Council was pleading for a site “that does not further concentrate poverty, and which is not already saturated with services for at-risk populations. ’’  

Other East Siders argued that having Catholic Charities construct an emergency shelter, housing facility and service center near Railroad Island northeast of the junction of Interstates 35E and 94 would be a setback to their economic revitalization efforts.

Faced with the possibility that opposition would interfere with efforts to obtain bonding dollars from legislators this session and delay construction, St. Paul Mayor Chris Coleman announced that the new facility will be constructed on and around the current Old Sixth Street location.

Coleman and Catholic Charities of St. Paul and Minneapolis, which would build and operate the new Dorothy Day Center, call the need to provide services urgent.

The current facility was opened in 1981 as a daytime drop-in center offering coffee and sweet rolls to homeless people. The center now shelters 250 people a night sleeping on thin mats on the floor.

The first phase of the project is expected to cost $39 million. Planners hope to receive $18 million in state general obligation bonds from the Legislature and to apply for an additional $17 million in housing infrastructure bonds.

In light of the about-face on where to build, MinnPost talked to Tim Marx, CEO of Catholic Charities of St. Paul and Minneapolis. Here are edited excerpts of the interview:

MinnPost: Can you say more about the sudden decision to change locations?

Tim Marx:  It is not unusual when you propose a project of some significance that it takes time to work through the community process so the community feels comfortable with what is going on. It is because of the urgency of the Dorothy Day Center and horrific conditions there that we are moving this process along….We were confident with some time we could resolve those concerns….It turned out in order to get the support at the Legislature that we need and to move forward immediately we needed to pivot…to advance this critical need for the community.

MP: Where does that leave things?

TM: That leaves us with the community united around the need to advance the Dorothy Day revision. We have a location the mayor and community are now rallying behind in and around our current site.

MP: What is the overall plan?

Catholic Charities CEO Tim Marx
Catholic Charities CEO Tim Marx

TM: Phase one is a combined dignified-emergency shelter with permanent housing right above it — the proposed St. Paul Higher Ground based on the successful Higher Ground in Minneapolis. That is 150 units of new housing and shelter capacity for 320. That is the first and most critical component of phase one. The second component [of phase one], which also was going to be located on the northeast quadrant of downtown and that will  stay in or near the present location, is called the Connections Center, and would be a resource center.

MP:  How much space do you have now?

TM: I’m not an acre guy. We’re working with our neighbors and partners to gain access to sufficient space. We were going to do land acquisition as part of this. We know we have sufficient space within that area. We’re working to figure it out.

MP: What will this cost?

TM: The total project cost of phases one and two is estimated to be $63 million. What we’re focusing on right now includes Higher Ground St. Paul — combined housing and dignified shelter — and the Connections Center, which offers health care, housing and other important resources. The total cost of that is $39 million.

MP: Do you already have plans to build on your current site?

TM: When we began we looked at a number of options. One option was to stay at our current site. We did some preliminary work on that.

MP: When do you think you might be able to start construction?

TM: If we can get the state funding we need by the end of this year…and assemble the rest of the process, our hope is we can break ground by 2015.  My real-estate professionals tell me that is very ambitious, but I think it is very important to be ambitious when you look at the dire situation at Dorothy Day. We have no time to waste.

MP: How would you describe that situation?

TM: Dorothy Day was never intended for people to sleep there. We’re increasingly concerned about our ability to meet the needs of a place that is  [sheltering] people overnight. It is a building being worn out where 250 people are sleeping inches apart on thin mats with inadequate facilities, including increasingly infirm people. People are coming with more challenging conditions, including more elderly people. It is a facility that is overwhelmed.

MP: Can you provide some numbers?

TM: We have about 6,000 visitors to Dorothy Day each year and increasingly we find it difficult to accommodate them all. Not everybody who visits there sleeps there. About one-third sleep there. The other two-thirds get meals and services there. Beginning in 2011 we actually started turning people away. We see people increasingly elderly. They have difficult medical conditions and we’re unable to provide decent, safe and sanitary conditions.

MP: How will the homeless be sheltered during construction?   

TM: What we’re hoping to do, and it is a challenge, is to stage the construction so there is no disruption of services.

Comments (3)

  1. Submitted by Dennis Tester on 03/14/2014 - 01:20 pm.

    Minimum wage

    Would increasing the minimum wage HELP these unemployed, unskilled people out with their difficulties or HURT these people as they try to get back on their feet?

    • Submitted by Karen Sandness on 03/14/2014 - 02:20 pm.

      It depends on the person, but businesses make

      hiring decisions based on many factors other than wages. One of my free-lance clients made promises to one of THEIR clients that they can’t actually meet, and now they’re begging for subcontractors at far above the price they originally offered.

      You know how stores hire people during the Christmas rush? They did that when the minimum wage was $1.25, and they’re still doing it. Only now their customers have less money, so they’re trying to make up for it by extending “Christmas” into September.

      Also, some of the people who frequent the Dorothy Day Center may be unemployable, if the people who frequent other charitable programs are any indication. Few businesses will hire the mentally ill or frail elderly or obvious substance abusers at any price.

  2. Submitted by James Nogler on 03/19/2014 - 01:37 pm.


    I’ve been homeless in Minneapolis for the last three months, and have been staying in the Higher Ground shelter in Minneapolis, while I appreciate the resources I receive, I feel calling these resources dignified is immoral. Make arguments for more resources or that you do what you can with what you have, there are many ways to approach the problem, but claiming that you are making a dent in the problem or meeting the needs of individuals with the resources currently provided is disingenuous at best.

    There seems to exist a difference between the language presented to the public about these services and the provision of these services to individuals in need. From Catholic Charities website on higher ground (, many of these claims are inaccurate at best. Lockers ARE NOT available to anyone in the emergency shelter. A light breakfast corresponds to bologna sandwiches, not a breakfast item the last time I checked. Light dinner is usually canned vegetables with the most unhealthy hot dish you could imagine. Showers are barely that, with limited water pressure and if I remember 5 per 171 people.

    If you wish to discuss the way individuals are treated at Higher Ground by staff, it is usually similarly poorly. Frequently the staff are not to be seen as they eat their ordered in food, slow to be of assistance in almost anything, and frequently act bothered if asked for anything. Several times the line to be screened to enter the shelter has been left outside in below freezing temperatures for unknown reasons well after the time it is specified to open.

    Complaints are often met with ‘restrictions’. A euphemism for get out of here or we will have a cop break your nose and take you out of here.

    Misrepresenting what you do for those in need not only disrespect those in need, but creates a misrepresentation that the services provided to those in need are somehow adequate.

    Shame on you.

Leave a Reply