Nonprofit, independent journalism. Supported by readers.


Lawyers group aims to educate Somali community about criminal justice system

The North American Somali Bar Association wants to help Somali legal professionals, students — and the community at large. 

Nearly 100 people attended the launch of The North American Somali Bar Association last Thursday at Safari Restaurant and Event Center in Minneapolis.
MinnPost photo by Ibrahim Hirsi

On a recent cold winter night, Maya Sheikh-Salah, assistant Hennepin County attorney, stood tall before nearly 100 Somali-Americans at Safari Restaurant and Event Center in Minneapolis, passionately addressing the community about a little known topic: The U.S. criminal justice system.

“Criminal law is a very rich area of law,” she told the crowd. “And it’s one of the areas that has grasped the imagination of the public because there are so many [TV] shows that happen.”

Sheikh-Salah — who underlined that she was not speaking on behalf of the Hennepin County Attorney’s office — added that stories in the popular crime shows such as “Law & Order” and “CSI” don’t necessarily translate into the realities of real-world happenings. “That’s not how it works in real life,” she said of the shows. 

The assembly last Thursday marked the launch of The North American Somali Bar Association (NASBA), birthed by Minnesota Somali legal professionals as a way to address their community’s legal needs, to inspire young African immigrants, and to provide mentoring services to current law students.

Basic legal lessons

Even though the gathering was the association’s first meet-and-greet event, it presented some important lessons for many in attendance: Sheikh-Salah, a founding member of NASBA, explained what it means to have a justice system, a constitution and the many parallel branches of the justice system, among other things.   

“Criminal justice system is a system that’s key to the law, it’s key to the peaceful society and it’s key to a government to function well,” she said. “The criminal justice system has many agents: Law enforcement … prosecutors … defense attorneys … judges and finally corrections.”

Article continues after advertisement

For the majority of the people in attendance, learning about how justice is carried out in the U.S. was important because the civil war that unfolded in Somalia more than two decades ago has left the country without a formal justice system.

Victims in Somalia don’t often seek legal redress through law enforcement or legal courts, according to Cate Buchanan, author of “Gun Violence, Disability and Recovery,” a 2014 book project released by the Surviving Gun Violence Project.

Instead, victims turn to clan elders and religious leaders for crime or conflict resolutions, Buchanan explained.  “Clan elders play a prominent role in justice and security because they are the cornerstones of the traditional Somali justice and conflict resolution mechanism, known as Xeer,” Buchanan stated. 

She explained: “This system rests on the clan structure of Somali society, in which a community is composed of a hierarchy of units. The smallest of these units is the diya group, an extended family group collectively liable for the payment of compensation monies in case of death or injury, whether intentional or accidental.”

This traditional system of justice has long existed in Somalia, even before the civil war, which erupted in 1991, uprooting hundreds of thousands of people, many of whom ended up in Minnesota.

Somali legal professionals hint that elders sometimes get involved in minor criminal cases before or after they’re reported to law enforcement.

Sheikh-Salah shared with the crowd a case about a local Somali woman robbed by a Somali man in 2004. The woman gave the police a report statement with the name of the suspect.

When the police submitted the report and prosecutors charged the case, the woman recognized that the man was related to her. Eventually, Somali elders got involved as mediators.

Before the man had his day in court, the woman called the prosecutor, saying that she was mistaken and that the man wasn’t the suspect.

“They give her a warning: ‘Are you sure? Because you gave a report statement to the police,’” Sheikh-Salah said. 

“And she says, ‘Yes it’s true.’”

Sheikh-Salah said the woman was charged with falsifying a police report although she didn’t do it intentionally. 

Mentor program seeks to help law students 

Abdinasir Abdulahi, a founding member of NASBA and Minneapolis-based attorney, said the association was established to contribute to the community and to become a network base for Somali legal professionals throughout North America. Mentor program seeks to help law students

“We’re getting questions about what it’s like to go to law school,” Abdulahi said in an interview. “We felt that we had to [create] an association that can cater to the community, educate, inspire and mentor the youth.”

Through the NASBA mentorship program, Abdulahi took Abdifatah Mohamed, a law student at William Mitchell College of Law, under his wing.

Mohamed worked with Abdulahi about two days a week. “I gained lots of experience and lots of a valuable insight about practicing law and about running a small business,” said Mohamed, who moved to Minnesota two and a half years ago from Seattle, Washington for law school.

Abdifatah Mohamed
MinnPost photo by Ibrahim Hirsi
Abdifatah Mohamed: “NASBA has a goal of reaching out to the community and doing public service.”

He added: “Abdinasir has been a valuable mentor to me. I can’t think him enough.” NASBA has a goal of reaching out to the community and doing public service, Mohamed said.

Last week, that service included about a dozen legal professionals assembled in a panel to help the audience understand the seemingly complex U.S. justice system.

The audience even received a brief introduction to the U.S. Constitution: “This document is the oldest and shortest constitution in the world,” Sheikh-Salah said as she held the constitution high.

She continued: “And as a matter of fact, I’m going to add, the most contemporary document. It has 7 articles, 27 amendments, 4,400 words. The United States constitution gives rights to individuals. And the presumption of innocence preserves the dignity of the individual. You’re not guilty, until proven guilty.”

Ibrahim Hirsi can be reached at Follow him on Twitter at @IHirsi.