The Minneapolis Foundation generously supports MinnPost's Community Sketchbook coverage. Learn why.

Target Field temp workers win fight for back pay, but not higher wages

MinnPost photo by Kristoffer Tigue
Lovie Franklin: “Nobody should get treated like this. Target Field needs to fix this. The Twins need to step up, because we’re working for them right now.”

Sondra Jones has worked at Target Field as a temporary worker for the last two summers. But this summer she found herself waiting for hours in a line with hundreds of other temp workers just hoping to pick up a shift for the day.

“The longest I’ve stood in line is three hours,” Jones said. “The shortest is ninety minutes.”

Even then, there was no guarantee she’d get a job that day, nor any pay for the hours spent waiting to find out. So in September, Jones was one of 136 Target Field temp workers who signed a petition asking for better wages, a more predictable schedule and improved working conditions.

Last week, Minnesota Sportservice, the local subsidiary of Delaware North — the company that contracts the temp agencies who hire workers for Target Field — met with the agencies and temp workers, and came to an agreement that met most of the workers’ demands, though higher wages were not part of the final deal.

“We recently met with leaders of Neighborhoods Organizing for Change to discuss concerns regarding temporary workers assigned to Target Field and have reviewed those concerns with the temporary agencies,” wrote Minnesota Sportservice in a statement. “Minnesota Sportservice, though not the employer of the temporary employees, is willing to facilitate a direct meeting between NOC and the temporary agencies.”

The negotiation comes amid the Minneapolis City Council’s efforts to draft new ordinances aimed to protect workers like those that negotiated with Minnesota Sportservice, many of whom are black.

Target Field employs a number of unionized workers, but the demand is such that Minnesota Sportservice contracts temporary workers through four different temp agencies: New Heights Staffing, Labor Ready, Spartan Staffing and All Team.

Those temp agencies will now provide their workers with paper checks and direct deposit as options for payment, will require agencies to pay their workers who are asked to wait in line before their shift, and won’t mandate workers to report to shifts if there are life events that take priority, said Minnesota Sportservice. 

Target Field also said they’d tell the temp agencies to pay all back pay owed to any temp workers who waited in line before their official shift start time. In Minnesota, employers are required to pay for all hours worked, which includes waiting time, call time, training time and any other time the employee is restricted to the premises of the employer.

That should come as welcome news to Lovie Franklin, who has worked as a temp at Target Field for New Heights. She said workers were not getting paid for the many hours they stood in line. “We’re on our feet for nine hours and only getting paid for five,” Franklin said.

Michael Higgins, left, and NOC executive director Anthony Newby
MinnPost photo by Kristoffer Tigue
Temporary worker Michael Higgins, left, and NOC executive director Anthony Newby, right, addressing a crowd outside Target Field at the Sept. 23 rally.

New Heights owner Charles Jones said he pays his temporary staff for waiting in line, and if they didn’t receive any pay, it was because they didn’t report the hours. “I can assure you that they are getting paid if they’re waiting,” he said.

One major complaint from temp workers — one that was cut from the negotiations — was the issue of increased wages.

Minnesota Sportservice food staff at Target Field are unionized under UNITEHERE Local 17, and make between $11 and $14 per hour. But workers for Target Field temp agencies typically make between $8 and $9.50 an hour, for what they say is the same job.

“We’re all doing the same job,” said Michael Higgins, who worked at Target Field through the temp agency Labor Ready. “Every last one of us is doing the exact same thing. They’re not giving us benefits, so why aren’t they giving us the same wages?”

Comments (1)

  1. Submitted by Frank Phelan on 10/05/2015 - 01:58 pm.

    Meddling In The Free Market

    We hear a lot about the benefits of not letting the government “choose winners and losers” and not “meddling in the free market”. But as long as we’ve tossed that out the window and ladle cash upon the owners of professional sports franchises, we shouldn’t stop at taking care of the wealthiest in our society. Minimum standards should be baked into these sweet heart deals we offer the Pohlads, Wilfs, etc. There should be absolutely no interference with any worker organizing, and the team owners should be specifically held to account, no hiding behind subsidiaries, holding companies, or contractors.

    It’s shameful to let billionaires feed at the public trough while they nose out the least among us.

    When Jesus spoke of looking after the least among us, these are the folks he was talking about, so I fully expect those who profess Christianity to get behind these people.

Leave a Reply