The Minneapolis Foundation generously supports MinnPost's Community Sketchbook coverage. Learn why.

Pollution Control Agency enlists north Minneapolis residents in effort to pull recycling facility’s permit

Creative Commons/MPCA Photos
The MPCA wants to stop Northern Metal Recycling’s operations, at least until it can re-evaluate the facility and ensure it’s not a significant contributor to the recent spike in lead contamination.

When Channy Leaneagh moved to north Minneapolis three years ago, she didn’t anticipate that the neighborhood’s air quality would be a problem. But last year, her 7-year-old daughter missed over a week of school. “Every single one of those [days] she was home sick with asthma,” she said.

Leaneagh was just one of dozens of concerned residents who attended a meeting last week hosted by Neighborhoods Organizing for Change (NOC) surrounding Northern Metal Recycling, a north Minneapolis metal recycling plant the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency believes may be contributing to dangerous levels of atmospheric lead and other hazardous metals.

NOC organizer Janiece Watts said over the last year NOC has held several meetings to find out what concerns north Minneapolis residents have regarding their neighborhoods, and air quality has come up time and time again. And in a recent survey NOC conducted in north Minneapolis, 83 percent of the 408 people who took the survey said they had or knew someone who had asthma.

All that followed a report from last March, when the MPCA released new data revealing unhealthy levels of lead in the air in north Minneapolis. According to the Department of Health report, the north Minneapolis area, which includes Leaneagh’s Hawthorne neighborhood, has a higher rate of elevated lead levels in children. At last week’s meeting City of Minneapolis officials also stated that this area has the highest rate of asthma hospitalizations in the state.

“This has been an issue for a long time,” Watts said. “There’s a lot of emotion, there’s a lot of anger.”

Now the MPCA wants to stop the recycler’s operations, at least until it can re-evaluate the facility and ensure it’s not a significant contributor to the recent spike in lead contamination in an area that city officials say already suffers from poor air quality. Last month, the agency filed to revoke the operating permit of Northern Metal Recycling’s north Minneapolis facility on the basis that the plant was conducting operations that weren’t disclosed under its current permit.

At the time, MPCA officials said they believe those operations may be contributing to higher levels of lead and other hazardous metals found in the air surrounding the area. “The facility, which operates a metal shredder at the site, is believed to be a primary source of particulate emissions that have repeatedly violated state air quality standards near the site since 2014, when the MPCA began operating air monitors near the facility,” the MPCA stated at the time of filing.

On June 9, a Ramsey County judge held a hearing on a request for an injunction, along with a motion to temporarily shut down the plant. The judge declined to shut down the facility, and now has 90 days to rule on an injunction to force the facility to close, according to MPCA officials.

MPCA Land and Air Compliance Section Manager Sarah Kilgriff said the MPCA will continue pursuing permit revocation. The community may participate by submitting public comments to the MPCA, and staying aware of the case as it progresses.

Through June 20, the MPCA is holding a public comment period, asking residents to submit their thoughts on what they believe should be done with the Northern Metal plant in light of the new findings. The agency is collecting the comments as part of the permit revocation process and it will take all comments into consideration, Kilgriff said.

Kilgriff said the MPCA isn’t alleging that Northern Metal is violating the emission limits set by its permit. But if it is, it wouldn’t be the first time. The facility was fined $15,000 in 2010 by the MPCA after it measured levels of mercury coming from the building that exceeded state emission standards, Kilgriff said, and in 2014 and 2015, it found elevated levels of lead, chromium, cobalt and nickel in the atmosphere surrounding the building that exceeded health risk guidelines. Northern Metal Recycling did not respond to attempts to get comment for this story. 

MPCA representatives Sarah Kilgriff and Ned Brooks
Courtesy of NOC
MPCA representatives Sarah Kilgriff and Ned Brooks speaking during a presentation to residents at the Neighborhoods Organizing for Change offices.

Roya Damsaz, who works across the street from the recycling plant, says she often hears her coworkers coughing and was concerned it had to do with dust she believes is coming from Northern Metal.

“You can see when it hasn’t rained in a few days there’s a lot of particles and dust all over the cars that are in the parking lot right across the street,” Damsaz said. “A lot of them are just covered with dust. This is what people breathe.”

Damsaz said she doesn’t want going to work to be a health hazard so she hopes the MPCA succeeds in revoking Northern Metal’s permit. “One of my close coworkers, she coughs a lot. Almost all year round,” she said. “When she works from home she said it’s not as bad.”

Daniel Huff, the Environmental Health Director for the Minneapolis Department of Health, said the city is also very concerned with the MPCA’s findings regarding air quality in north Minneapolis. “We are concerned about our residents, we are concerned about the health disparities, and we want the PCA to vigorously enforce air quality standards,” he said.

While the city can’t act as a regulatory figure in this case, Huff said, it does plan to submit an official statement as part of the public comment period, and it’s asking their staff members to do the same.

The move would have the city officially back the MPCA’s goal to revoke Northern Metal’s permit to operate, he said, and hopefully be influential as the case will likely become a legal battle. The full City Council will vote on the measure this Friday, he said.

As for Leaneagh, she said she won’t be leaving the neighborhood even though it’d be the safest thing for her daughter. If people leave north Minneapolis, she said, the problems won’t get fixed.

“As a parent I’ve made a horrible choice in living in this area, but at the same time you don’t want homeowners to start moving or people to abandon the Northside,” she said. “The historical problems always happen to black neighborhoods. We have to do better than that.”

Correction: This story contains corrections, including: An earlier version of this story incorrectly named the host of the event last week and incorrectly stated what would be done with comments sought from the public.

Comments (5)

  1. Submitted by joe smith on 06/14/2016 - 10:04 am.

    Shouldn’t the MPCA have definite proof that N Metals is

    Causing the problems before they shut it down and put folks out of work? If they shut it down and find out that N Metals is not the problem, will the MPCA pay for the cost of the shut down? Which means the tax payers will pay!

    Shutting down a business and putting folks out of work is a huge decision, it needs to be made with facts not feelings!

    • Submitted by Mark Snyder on 06/14/2016 - 12:32 pm.

      Northern Metals has refused to cooperate with MPCA to confirm whether they are the definitive source of these air emissions. Perhaps if they were more forthcoming, they would be able to remain in operation while the agency re-evaluates the facility. If their permit does end up being revoked, Northern Metals will have nobody to blame for that but themselves.

  2. Submitted by Connie Sullivan on 06/14/2016 - 11:36 am.

    A friend who is a long-time local environmental activist told me that this move by the MPCA is unusual, given its past shyness with taking on not only the polluting done by this business, but business in general. The agency obviously has people who are stepping up to the plate with their expertise and much less political stuff than before. I hope not only the North Minneapolis NOC and residents, but all of Minneapolis gives the MPCA a boost here, as they try to protect people’s health in our cities.

  3. Submitted by William Lindeke on 06/14/2016 - 12:25 pm.

    Lead contamination is not OK and we should be taking great care in finding out what’s causing it.

  4. Submitted by Rod Loper on 06/15/2016 - 07:17 am.

    Downwind

    Northeast as well as north Minneapolis need to be tested as well. This outfit has sued and stonewalled MPCA from the getgo about monitoring and compliance. I live downwind from this thing
    and patronize restaurants just across the river.. They are an eyesore as well as a health hazard.

Leave a Reply