Community Voices features opinion pieces from a wide variety of authors and perspectives. (Submission Guidelines)

The destruction of the Mamilla Cemetery: desecration of a sacred site

The Ma’man Allah (Mamilla) Cemetery was the oldest Muslim cemetery in Jerusalem, with graves dating back to the seventh century, comprising 33 acres and tens of thousands of graves. After 1948 the Israeli ministry that maintained the site reassured world leaders that this important religious site would be cared for in perpetuity.

Less than 15 years later, in the 1960s, a park was built in part of the cemetery and a parking lot covered another part. These were followed by a school, football field, underground parking garage and road. Electrical wires were laid in other sections.

The final few acres were dug up recently, just before the beginning of Ramadan, in the middle of the night (as can be seen on the CNN video) so that Israel can build the Museum of Tolerance in conjunction with the Simon Wiesenthal Center in the United States.

An enormous amount of knowledge was lost with the destruction of the Mamilla cemetery, says St. Paul-based archeologist John E. Landgraf, since the end of the Byzantine period and the beginning of the Islamic conquest (around 638 AD) is the least well-known period of history in that area. There is much to be learned by examining skeletal remains, headstones and tombs. The Israeli Department of Antiquities does not allow any remains to be examined; Jewish remains must be re-interred as quickly as possible out of respect or because the remains are sacred, and non-Jewish remains can be disposed of along with tombstones and other debris in construction dumpsters.

Landgraf participated in many archeological digs in Israel since 1965, and said that the Israeli Department of Antiquities was never interested in the preservation of remains or artifacts that were not specifically Jewish. In 1965 the discovery of Muslim graves at Tel Gezer did not interest the head archeologist at the time and bulldozers were used to push remains, artifacts and debris back into the graves.

History exposed one layer at a time
Archeological digs are a way of learning about the past in an orderly fashion. One exposes history a layer at a time and by careful examination stories can be told of the various eras and cultures. When Israel occupied all of Jerusalem in 1967 it used bulldozers to excavate the Wailing Wall area, destroying homes and shops of Palestinians living there at the time, and destroying the long history of people who had lived there since before the Byzantine period. “There is a loss of continuity in our understanding of the past,” said Landgraf.

It is ironic that in the midst of mass hysteria over an Islamic center to be built in lower Manhattan, because some people feel that this would be disrespectful to the dead, that a genuine desecration of a sacred place occurs, unreported in most mainstream media.

“The unfortunate reality is that Indigenous populations live in a world in which we are never safe from colonizer assaults — even when we are dead,” says Wazayatawin, Indigenous Peoples Research Chair and associate professor, Indigenous Governance Program, University of Victoria, someone who has worked on behalf of indigenous peoples in this hemisphere for many years and sees many parallels with the experience of Palestinians. “The ongoing desecration of indigenous burial sites, including the Mamilla Cemetery in West Jerusalem, reflects a deeply embedded colonizer mentality that views subjugated peoples as fundamentally inferior and unworthy of even the most basic dignities afforded other human beings,” she says.

“The act of erasing a people’s memory from the landscape is a necessary element in the colonization process,” Wazayatawin says. “In order for the colonizers to legitimize their occupation of another’s land, they must eradicate all memories of the colonized, including even the human remains that demonstrate a deep and powerful connection to the land itself.”

Memories eradicated
Everywhere in Israel are the eradicated memories of the dispossessed indigenous people. Old mosques are transformed into bars and nightclubs, so that patrons drink alcohol where Muslims used to pray. The history museum in Jaffa (more of a tourist site than an educational institution) is inexplicably silent about the existence of people in the city between the Roman times and Napoleon’s invasion. Street names are changed from their ancient Arabic names to new Hebrew ones.

Golda Meir’s famous comment that “There is no such thing as a Palestinian people” reflected her desire, not a reality, but it has been repeated so often that many Israelis believe it. The destruction of a cemetery shows starkly how little regard Israel holds for the humanity of the Palestinians. As Wazayatawin says, “There is something terribly wrong with a culture that digs up the dead of others. The societal justification for such a crime reveals its own sickness.”

Sylvia Schwarz is a resident of St. Paul and member of the Minnesota Break the Bonds Campaign and of the International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network (IJAN-TC).

Comments (4)

  1. Submitted by Greg Kapphahn on 09/13/2010 - 09:23 am.

    As the Israeli government increasingly ignores the advice of the ancient prophets of the Jewish faith, perhaps our Israeli friends might like to consider what happened the last time they ignored their own prophets in favor of political expediency and endemic (though unacknowledged) psychological dysfunction.

    Indeed if it continues down its current path, it’s enemies will not have to lift a finger. The nation of Israel will destroy itself from within.

  2. Submitted by rolf westgard on 09/13/2010 - 09:50 am.

    Sylvie, thanks for this, and thanks to minnpost for the courage to print it.

  3. Submitted by Douglas Johnson on 09/13/2010 - 12:01 pm.

    This travesty reminds me of the actions of the alitohlas (sp.)when the Shiites took over Iran. They demolished Ba Hai (sp.) gravesites and and artifacts of their beliefs.
    I heard about this from an Iranian descendant of a founder of Ba hai.
    Doug

  4. Submitted by myles spicer on 09/13/2010 - 03:23 pm.

    If, what Schwarz claims is true, it is indefensibble. But Schwarz has bent facts in the past in other columns, so this one needs further vetting.

    Indeed, the Jerusalem Post (a generally reliable paper) reported somewhat different facts, below:

    “Despite what city officials have called “clear and indisputable evidence” of some 300 fraudulent tombstones that were discovered – and subsequently demolished – inside an ancient Muslim cemetery in Jerusalem in recent weeks, a handful of demonstrators arrived at the burial site on Wednesday morning to protest what they labeled the city’s “desecration” of the cemetery.

    Nearly two dozen Muslim demonstrators descended on the city’s Mamilla Cemetery, a centuries-old Islamic burial site in the heart of Jerusalem, at around 10 a.m. on Wednesday and began chanting slogans about the recent developments there.

    Last week, the Jerusalem Municipality released photographs and a clear timeline of what officials described as “one of the largest deceptions in recent years,” detailing how “Islamic officials” had used permits obtained for the purpose of cleaning and renovating tombstones at the site to instead erect hundreds of “fictitious graves” on a neighboring plot of land.”

    So…what IS true? I could support Schwarz’s contentions, IF true; but if this is a fraud, it’s condemnation should also be part of the story. What is needed here are facts and credibility before judgement is made.

Leave a Reply