Community Voices features opinion pieces from a wide variety of authors and perspectives. (Submission Guidelines)

Quick action is needed to fix systemic problems at Minnesota Security Hospital

The following is an editorial from the Mankato Free Press.

Problems at the Minnesota Security Hospital in St. Peter seem unrelenting.

In 2011 the Human Services Commissioner gave the hospital two years to reduce the unnecessary use of patient restraints.

In 2013 investigators found two new cases of patient maltreatment, including one in which staff failed to intervene when a patient banged his head against a concrete wall for more than three hours. The hospital was fined and had its license placed on “conditional status” — a status that remains in place.

Last week, investigators determined that a security guard bears some responsibility for the January killing of a patient, allegedly by another patient.

Quality of care

Those incidents don’t cover scandals involving the quality of care given by psychiatrists, whether patients are kept in high security programs too long and myriad other managerial and staff problems in recent years.

To be fair, operating Minnesota’s largest psychiatric facility, with 400 of the state’s most dangerous patients, is a daunting task.

Human Services Commissioner Lucinda Jesson and lawmakers have repeatedly voiced serious concerns about the hospital.

Some of the safety problems, for both patients and staff, are the result of an outdated building with poor sight lines. Those problems will have a remedy now that the Legislature and governor approved more than $56 million in funding for security hospital renovation and construction.

While the work is very much needed, no one should believe the bulk of the problems at the hospital are the result of building design.

Redoubling of efforts is required

State officials, lawmakers, hospital management and union leadership must redouble efforts to improve the philosophical and clinical approaches used at the hospital, improve training for staff and identify and correct other problems with the aim of protecting and serving staff and patients.

The patients at the hospital are often dangerous and unpredictable. But we all have to remember that they are mentally ill patients who deserve the best care and protections the state can provide them.

That is not what they have received in recent years.

Reprinted with permission.


If you’re interested in joining the discussion, add your voice to the Comment section below — or consider writing a letter or a longer-form Community Voices commentary. (For more information about Community Voices, email Susan Albright at

You can also learn about all our free newsletter options.

Comments (1)

  1. Submitted by Paul Brandon on 05/31/2014 - 09:57 am.

    The real problem

    is the inherent contradiction in the whole concept of a ‘security hospital’.
    The facility houses individuals who, while not technically convicted of a crime, have been given effective life sentences (one dismissal in the history of the facility) in a prison like environment.
    Since there is no evidence this side of ‘Clockwork Orange’ of any ability (speaking as a mental health professional) to ‘cure’ violence, the whole pretense of hospitalization should be abandoned and the facility converted into a prison.
    The inmates should be tried in court for whatever crimes they are alleged to have committed, and if convicted, sentenced accordingly.

Leave a Reply