Community Voices features opinion pieces from a wide variety of authors and perspectives. (Submission Guidelines)

Planned Parenthood attackers seek to take women and medicine backward

© Dominick Reuter / Reuters

As a medical doctor and a mother of three, I’m deeply disturbed by recent, shameful attacks on Planned Parenthood. I find the resulting rush to take federal funds away from this health care provider to be typical of many debates in Washington – hyperpartisan, deceptive, and almost completely devoid of fact. After spending a lifetime devoted to science, I feel compelled to set the record straight.

Dr. Mary Lawrence

An extreme anti-women’s group that calls itself the Center for Medical Progress, a name George Orwell would find amusing, deceptively cornered medical staff from Planned Parenthood, secretly videotaping them without their consent and heavily editing the footage in order to shock and disgust people, attempting to leave the false impression that laws were violated in the process of donating tissue for medical research. That claim has been widely debunked, rightly so.

Planned Parenthood provides more care than any other organization in the country to keep women healthy and prevent unintended pregnancies, providing birth control, cancer screenings, and sexually-transmitted-infections testing to 2.7 million people annually. The notion that politicians in Washington would use a fabricated issue like this to step between women and their health care professionals at Planned Parenthood and defund their mission is abhorrent to me. It is as out of place as a member of Congress barging into my operating room while I was performing surgery on a patient.

Donating tissue for research

Often, serious medical issues do not manifest themselves until the middle or latter stages of a pregnancy, leaving many couples with the heartbreaking decision to end a pregnancy after months of carrying their child. For some couples, donating tissue for critical medical research to help another family avoid debilitating diseases is the one small positive that can come from their own medical ordeal. While this practice does not take place in Minnesota, a handful of Planned Parenthood affiliates around the country do offer women the option to donate tissue for medical research, utilizing a highly technical medical process to preserve organs and tissue and safely transporting them to reputable research organizations — all in compliance with strict federal law.

As is the case with opposing stem cell research, right-wing groups are trying to impose their extreme political views to not only stop women from making their own medical decisions, but also to prevent valuable medical research when it involves any fetal tissue. As a doctor, I know fetal tissue research has made it possible for life-saving prenatal surgical procedures. Doctors can now perform surgery in the womb and correct fatal and nonfatal abnormalities in the heart, spine and other areas thanks to fetal tissue research. Groups like the one that is attacking Planned Parenthood not only want to eliminate birth control and outlaw all abortions, including in cases of incest and rape, they would almost entirely shut down avenues of research in prenatal surgery as well as limit advances in fighting diseases like Alzheimer’s, epilepsy and cancer.

Truth is the first victim

Sometimes, in the overly partisan world that is today’s Washington, the truth is the first victim. In this case, the wholly dishonest attacks on Planned Parenthood not only have little basis in fact, but actually seek to victimize women, taking away not only their right to make their own medical decisions, but also taking away cancer screenings and other vital care. In the process, millions more families could be cut off from groundbreaking research that can save lives. Rather than progress, as their phony name implies, this group wants to take women and medicine backward.

It’s time for medical professionals to stand up and speak the truth. I stand with Planned Parenthood.

Dr. Mary Lawrence is a candidate for U.S. Congress in Minnesota’s 2nd Congressional District and a former professor at University of Minnesota Medical School.

Want to add your voice?

If you’re interested in joining the discussion, add your voice to the Comment section below — or consider writing a letter or a longer-form Community Voices commentary. (For more information about Community Voices, email Susan Albright at

You can also learn about all our free newsletter options.

Comments (3)

  1. Submitted by Pat Berg on 08/06/2015 - 10:01 am.

    The media could do a better job

    As an example, I was listening to story on NPR about the most recent sting video which contained the following:

    “Planned Parenthood of the Rocky Mountains actually tried to enter into a deal with this fake company, but the Planned Parenthood lawyer there struck out parts of the contract that was provided to them, saying no, we can’t profit from this; no, this part here is unethical.”


    In my mind, that should be the HEADLINE. That bottom line here is when PP is actually faced with something illegal, they say “No, sorry, we can’t do that”.

    Instead, it’s been all too often included as a sort of postscript, after all the sensationalistic parts have already been reported. So of course, with the public’s notoriously short attention span by the time they get to reporting this, the negative impressions have already been well-set.

    The media should report the deception FIRST. THEN they can fill in with the sensationalistic details if they absolutely must. But make the dishonesty the headline, because that’s the way it SHOULD be getting reported.

    • Submitted by jason myron on 08/06/2015 - 01:00 pm.

      Couldn’t agree more, Pat.

      But that’s not the headline that keeps readers or viewers. Why do you think the NY Times printed all of their retractions of the Clinton email story off of the front page? News has turned into little more than clickbait.

  2. Submitted by Tom Anderson on 08/06/2015 - 09:49 pm.

    Shouldn’t the ACA

    Put Planned Parenthood out of business? All women must have health insurance. All health insurance (with very limited exceptions) must provide free contraception. All women are thus provided healthcare, cancer screenings, and all vital care necessary for themselves and even their unborn children

    Planned Parenthood was exposed for processes and procedures that they won’t deny but hoped would go unnoticed. There is nothing illegal. But the truth is not always pretty.

Leave a Reply