Community Voices features opinion pieces from a wide variety of authors and perspectives. (Submission Guidelines)

Other news from Lake Wobegon: reclaiming the rural narrative

Today will be Garrison Keillor’s last official time hosting “A Prairie Home Companion,” a public radio broadcast with a history a decade longer than that of Southern Minnesota Initiative Foundation‘s (SMIF), which is celebrating its 30th anniversary this year. There’s no denying Keillor’s radio show, particularly his “News from Lake Wobegon” monologue, has crafted one of the most pervasive narratives for rural Minnesota and our small, Midwest towns.

Tim Penny
Tim Penny

For those of us living in and working for the future of that mythical — yet somehow incredibly real — “Lake Wobegon,” we understand that Keillor’s sign-off from a place where “all the women are strong, the men good-looking, and the children are above average” is a somewhat misleading simplification. Through SMIF’s early childhood programming, we understand that all of our children are not above average, but instead struggle as the result of income and racial achievement disparities. In our rural region, we are home to many new immigrant families who can feel isolated by our business-as-usual approach, no matter how much “Minnesota nice” envelops it. 

A nostalgic connection point. Now what?

Yet, one of the things the more than 1,500 Lake Wobegon tales have done is create a rural voice pumped weekly into the radios of rural and urban dwellers alike. Keillor’s stories are highly edited, nostalgia-inducing yarns filled with a somewhat realistic yet limited cast of characters. The question may now become: With the departure of Keillor and his monologue, how else can we carry the rural narrative forward?

Keillor’s show has created a nostalgic connection point for those of us who reside in rural areas and for those with rural roots, but those roots are weakening with generational change. The stage is set for a new voice — even better, new voices — to step up to the mike, or blog, or podcast, or camera lens, or whatever medium they may find to help tell our rural stories.

Perception becomes reality, William James observed. If that’s indeed the case, the stories we tell ourselves and others are important. In Minnesota, while 40 percent of the population still lives in Greater Minnesota, our representation in mainstream media does not seem to reflect that proportion. Additionally, we face researchers who have been predicting the doom-and-gloom of rural Minnesota for decades, locals who pessimistically eye empty main streets and yearn for the better days of yore, and outsiders who pass through and often pass judgment of these “dying” places.

Telling of a new vitality

However, I argue that there’s a new vitality in many of our rural communities and that we need to be the ones telling that story. Certainly, researchers like Ben Winchester and others at the University of Minnesota’s Extension are providing evidence that things are not as dark for Greater Minnesota as people may tend to believe. But beyond statistics of new blood coming back into rural areas, especially in our 20-county region, there is a lot to celebrate: enviable quality of life, beautiful landscapes, a world-class medical facility, many new businesses, quality schools, and generous, dedicated residents.

In addition, there is a spirit of entrepreneurialism that lives on in our small towns. At SMIF, we see it as our job to help spark that spirit and give seed investments to help them grow. As with everything we do, this needs to be a collaborative, regional effort. A growing tourism industry in Fillmore County must be seen as a success for surrounding counties; a theater project in Le Sueur must be celebrated by any town within an easy drive.

Most important, we should all be vigorous advocates of our region and more hopeful in our thinking of what can be. With Keillor stepping aside, we must be the ones to reclaim our own narrative. We must become the storytellers offering a more complete, more hopeful telling of what is and where we’re headed. 

Tim Penny is president of the Southern Minnesota Initiative Foundation and a former member of Congress. 

WANT TO ADD YOUR VOICE?

If you’re interested in joining the discussion, add your voice to the Comment section below — or consider writing a letter or a longer-form Community Voices commentary. (For more information about Community Voices, email Susan Albright at salbright@minnpost.com.)

Comments (2)

  1. Submitted by Greg Kapphahn on 07/01/2016 - 10:17 am.

    Southern/Southwestern Minnesota

    where Tim Penny was raised,…

    is NOT “Lake Wobegon.”

    At least in my experience,…

    Minnesota’s regions are very different from each other.

    in the South and Southwest, having the “rugged individualist” attitude, the constant question is “What do I get out of this?” (because I’m not going to lift a finger unless there’s something substantial in it for me). This is coupled with an intense suspicion of people who are different,…

    and/or who are not “from here,” (which, of course, includes the entire State Government in St. Paul).

    In the Central Lakes (and the far North and Northwest, as well), having the “we’re all in this together” attitude, the question is, how can we work together to make things better, to improve what’s been here before; to make next year even better?

    I’m not sure if it’s the dominance of certain religious denominations,…

    the legacy of the ethnic groups who settled there,…

    the aftermath of the very understandable revolt of the Dakota Indians,…

    or the difference in geography and climate,…

    but having lived in communities of both regions,

    it’s abundantly clear to me that Central Minnesota’s lakes district is a VERY different place,…

    from it’s South and Southwest.

    If Garrison Keillor had been raised in the South and Southwest,…

    he likely would have been a Country Western singer and story teller,…

    and his stories would have been filled with the dysfunction, depression, and despair so endemic in the earlier music of that region,…

    and the only people who would ever have heard of him would have been those who frequent Country Western bars.

    In my experience, it is indeed likely that an arts venue in one community in the Central Lakes Region might be appreciated and enjoyed in neighboring communities,…

    as Mr. Penny commented,…

    but in the South and Southwest, it’s far more likely to be ignored and even resented out of a sense of competition,…

    and “who do they think THEY are.”

    In the South and Southwest, folk in neighboring communities might even smile at the demise of such an effort,…

    and comment that the folk in the neighboring town “should have known better,”…

    and “we don’t need that kind of effeminate artsy stuff around here, anyway.”

    Meanwhile, many of the people in Central Minnesota spend their summers visiting back and forth to festivals, Wateramas, and parades in surrounding communities,…

    and congratulate those hosting them on how they’ve outdone themselves, this year.

    The Central Lakes and far North and Northwest Regions in Minnesota tend to be a places of hope, optimism and tolerance.

    The South and Southwest are more often places of intolerance, confusion, and an abiding inability to comprehend why “nothing every works out for us,” “everyone’s against us,” and “we never get our fair share,”…

    without ever comprehending that their attitudes and approaches to life ensure that this will continue to be the case,…

    as often as not because of their perception of reality,…

    which is only loosely related to actual facts (if there’s even a connection).

  2. Submitted by Robert Franklin on 07/02/2016 - 05:09 pm.

    Attitudes

    It would be a mistake to endorse broad characterizations of attitudes in various regions of the state. For my last 20 years at the Star Tribune, I reported from 86 of Minnesota’s 87 counties, and I can tell you that every town is different, depending on leadership, economics, heritage, economics, religion, demographics, schools and other factors. Even one or two committed citizens can make a difference in a town’s character and attitudes. And, yes, the arts are valued in southern Minnesota, too, from Lanesboro to Windom to Milan. I look for continued research on trends by those who know the state well, including Ben Winchester, Gregg Aamodt, Jay Walljasper, Joe Amato and others.

Leave a Reply