Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.


Community Voices features opinion pieces from a wide variety of authors and perspectives. (Submission Guidelines)

Rallying for public schools as sanctuaries for their students

After the presidential election, students in one school in St. Paul asked their teacher if anyone who is not white would be forced to leave the country if Donald Trump won the presidency. At another, teachers had to escort a student to the nurse’s office because she was having a panic attack thinking about her own future. It isn’t just our students, though. Members of the St. Paul Federation of Teachers are fearful for their families, colleagues, and their students. In these turbulent days, public schools are one of the few safe places for youth and their families. They are places of learning, where students can get a hot meal and spend time with their friends. Public schools are sanctuaries, and the Trump administration wants to take that away.

Denise Rodriguez

Today our public schools, teachers, and our students are under attack like never before. The incoming Trump administration has threatened to deport millions of our friends and neighbors. The president-elect’s vitriol has created an environment that marginalizes and threatens the livelihoods of Muslim, African-American, Latino, and differently abled students and their families. Millions of Americans are concerned about the future of our country’s promise of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.

President-elect Trump began his campaign to undermine public education when he nominated Betsy DeVos to be the secretary of education. DeVos has spent her life and her fortune actively seeking to destroy public education. In her home state of Michigan, she championed a voucher and charter school system that reinforced pre-existing racial segregation. While the public schools fell into disrepair, corporate executives raked in profits through tax breaks. In the name of school choice, she advocated for charter schools, which routinely push students with behavior issues and learning disabilities out of the classroom.

This doesn’t have to be our future. Our kids deserve better.

At the heart of democracy

Public education is at the heart of our democracy, and we must act to protect it. Increased funding for our schools is critical. Standardized testing and zero-tolerance policies have created environments of distrust and isolation, contributing to the racial education gap. Smaller class sizes, restorative practices for addressing conflict, and deeper family engagement will help us to better prepare all students to take on the challenges of an uncertain future. We must demand that our elected officials prioritize public dollars to support public education – our kids are counting on us.

That is why we are rallying today at LEAP High School the day before the presidential inauguration. We believe in our community. We believe in public education. And we whole-heartedly believe that all of our students and their families are important and valuable. The issue is not whether our state or our school district has enough money; it is about whether we have the will to make the best choices for our kids. Now is the time to take our beliefs and turn them into actions.

Today, as a first step in strengthening our schools and standing up for our students, we are partnering with St. Paul Public Schools to unapologetically declare our schools to be sanctuaries. Sanctuary school districts are safe havens for students. They protect students from immigration raids in schools, which traumatize children and disrupt learning, and they refuse to share student information with immigration officials. Most important of all, sanctuary schools proudly declare themselves as defenders of their students.

Working with all students

Teaching is an inherently political act. What and how we teach our children will impact our society for years to come. We encourage and support each and every student who comes into our schools to reach their full potential. We work with students no matter their race, gender identity, sexual orientation, ability, or immigration status. By doing this, we fight back against messages of division and hate.

It is only going to become more important in the weeks and months ahead for us to unite for a public education system that all kids need and deserve. We must redouble our efforts to strengthen our schools and our profession. The St. Paul Federation of Teachers will fight for our schools and our communities to be safe, racially equitable spaces for learning and growth.

Together, we will take a stand against hatred. Together, we will take a stand against vitriol and division. Together, we will fight for the world our children deserve. Will you join us?

Denise Rodriguez is a Spanish teacher and St. Paul resident serving as the president of the St. Paul Federation of Teachers.


If you’re interested in joining the discussion, add your voice to the Comment section below — or consider writing a letter or a longer-form Community Voices commentary. (For more information about Community Voices, email Susan Albright at

Comments (4)

  1. Submitted by Ray J Wallin on 01/19/2017 - 10:13 am.


    I rarely read articles so full of trepidation, of hopelessness.

    The author creates fear by making comments like: our students are under attack, defending students, sanctuaries, panic attacks, environments of distrust and isolation, campaign to undermine public education, Trump wants to take that away, Trump has threatened to deport our friends and neighbors.

    Who is the fear monger? If I didn’t know better, I would be the one having the panic attack. And I can’t help but think these fears have and will filter through to our students.

    Then I look on the SPFT link, and, again, negativity. Teachers in front of a school are holding signs stating “St Paul Students Can’t Wait.” Can’t? Tell us what they can do, not what they can’t do.

    I’m not saying her fears are baseless, but we need leaders, not reactors.

  2. Submitted by joe smith on 01/19/2017 - 12:30 pm.

    I will try again….

    I am all for a “safe space” for students but I am equally concerned about a quality education for ALL children including inner cities and poor small towns. Are you saying that a charter school will not be safe for their students? Are you saying that charter school teachers are not able to comfort students? Are you saying that parents who choose to send their kids to charter schools (easier to do with school choice and vouchers) are not concerned about their own children’s feelings?

    Breaking up the monopoly of public schools with parental choice, vouchers and competition will help everyone.

  3. Submitted by Ron Gotzman on 01/19/2017 - 03:45 pm.

    Minds full of mush….

    I think we now know why many public schools are failing.

  4. Submitted by Ilya Gutman on 01/19/2017 - 08:37 pm.

    No, it is not

    “Teaching is an inherently political act.” That is what they firmly believed in the Soviet Union… Is this what we want in America?

Leave a Reply