Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.

Community Voices features opinion pieces from a wide variety of authors and perspectives. (Submission Guidelines)

Why are House Republicans refusing to do anything about distracted driving?

Courtesy of MnDOT

An incident happened recently that really drives home why I’ve spent the last few years dedicated to toughening the penalties for distracted driving. Last week, 9-year-old Maddie Vance from St. Paul spent the night in the hospital after getting hit by car driven by a woman too distracted by her cellphone to notice Maddie, her brother, and their teacher in the crosswalk.

Jim Carlson

Maddie’s story illustrates a growing problem both here in Minnesota and across the country. Nationally, more than 3,000 people are dying each year due to distraction-related crashes, and 431,000 people are getting injured. It’s not OK – and as Distracted Driving Awareness Month draws to a close, I wanted to remind readers about a quiet battle over distracted driving happening right now at the state Capitol.

I have authored legislation to help reduce the number of distracted driving crashes. It enjoys bipartisan support. This legislation would require using a cellphone in hands-free mode while driving. While my bill received a hearing in the Senate, and the promise of further review and hearings next year, the House Public Safety and Security Committee refuses to hear it – effectively blocking further progress.

Why is Cornish holding the bill hostage?

This kind of behavior prompts the question: Why would House Republicans try to block this bill? It has both Republican and DFL authors, and is largely noncontroversial. Everyone is in agreement that fewer Minnesotans should die because of  distracted driving. If the legislation passed, Minnesota would join 14 other states and the District of Columbia in banning hand-held cellphone use while driving. So why is Rep. Tony Cornish —R-Vernon Center, chair of the House Public Safety and Security Committee — holding the bill hostage? I encourage supporters of the bill to call him and find out.

A recent Star Tribune editorial highlighted this very issue – and called for a “stop to the madness.” It highlighted previous work of the Minnesota Legislature designed to encourage safer driving habits – including bills I’m proud to have authored in the Senate.

Under current state law, texting while in traffic is prohibited – and that includes while you’re waiting at a stoplight. It’s also illegal for school bus drivers and teens using permits and provisional licenses to use cellphones at all while driving. Officers can issue tickets for inattentive driving, with $50 fines for a first offense and $275 for subsequent violations.

Current measures aren’t enough

In 2015, I brought forward a bill that eventually was signed into law that approved tougher penalties when a driver kills or injures another person while “aware of and consciously disregarding a substantial and unjustifiable risk” behind the wheel. All of these measures have been steps in the right direction. But they aren’t enough.

With less than four weeks left until the end of this legislative session, banning the use of handheld cellphones while driving will likely continue for another year. But rest assured, I can’t forget about what happened to Maddie and so many others like her. I especially will not forget the families who contacted my office or gave heartbreaking testimony in committee about loved ones taken from them by drivers who couldn’t put the phone down for a few moments.

I won’t give up on this issue, and I’ll continue pressing House Republicans to give the bill the fair hearing it deserves.

Sen. Jim Carlson, DFL-Eagan, represents District 51 in the Minnesota Senate.


If you’re interested in joining the discussion, add your voice to the Comment section below — or consider writing a letter or a longer-form Community Voices commentary. (For more information about Community Voices, see our Submission Guidelines.)

Comments (7)

  1. Submitted by Steve Titterud on 04/28/2017 - 03:29 pm.

    DO NOT give up !!

    Not too long ago, I witnessed an accident where BOTH drivers were on their phones. You’d think that an interruption like an accident would end both conversations, but NO !!

    Both drivers continued on their phones as they swapped licenses and waited for the police. First things first, I guess.

    People like this should have their licenses suspended, not merely pay a modest fine.

  2. Submitted by Jerry Lee on 04/29/2017 - 06:22 am.

    Hands Free Driving

    I do not understand why anyone would hold up a bill that would make it illegal to hold a cell phone while driving. In the first place, most new cars come with systems to allow hands free use of a cell phone so why the holdup? Pass the law, and pass it NOW!!!!

  3. Submitted by B Carlson on 04/29/2017 - 06:53 am.

    My best guess…..

    … that those blocking this are probably the worst offenders!

    And the same goes for our incredibly lax DUI laws.

  4. Submitted by Joseph Totten on 04/29/2017 - 03:20 pm.

    For your consideration…

    That this bill is being held up at this level is troubling. The bill doesn’t go far enough to actually protect the public from distracted driving. See a literature review on the subject here :

    The short answer is, even hands-free devices make us less safe drivers. A better bill would ban all device use, even that of hands-free devices.

    • Submitted by Steve Titterud on 04/29/2017 - 07:42 pm.

      Like you, the distraction that worries me most

      …is not of the HANDS, it’s the distraction of the MIND.

      Hands-free distraction is still distraction – interfering with a focus on driving – a form of impairment.

  5. Submitted by Matt Eckholm on 05/01/2017 - 09:38 am.

    Why don’t they pass laws? Because then they’d be breaking them.

    The head of the House Public Safety and Security Committee posts photos while driving. Kurt Daudt has been pulled over and cited for texting and driving. I’m sure you can search every name on the committee and find some buried story about how they’ve been caught texting and driving.

    So of course they’ll never pass legislation to restrict it – they’re some of the biggest culprits. Maybe if they’re so busy that they need to constantly be on their phones, they should take public transit…

  6. Submitted by Curt Johnson on 05/02/2017 - 08:09 pm.

    Distracted driving bill

    As a friend of mine once put it, the Democrats don’t have very good answers but the Republicans don’t even understand the questions. Nuf said.

Leave a Reply