Community Voices features opinion pieces from a wide variety of authors and perspectives. (Submission Guidelines)

Minnesota: Please don’t join Wisconsin and Iowa in stripping cities of their power

As local elected leaders from Duluth, Milwaukee, and Johnson County, Iowa, we have a message for Minnesota’s legislature and Gov. Mark Dayton: Don’t let Minnesota go the way of Wisconsin and Iowa.

Em Westerlund

These states failed to honor local residents’ desire to lift up workers, and took away local control. In Wisconsin, Gov. Scott Walker wiped out the will of the Milwaukee residents who voted overwhelmingly for a paid sick days law that would have guaranteed for local workers the basic right to paid time off when they or a family member was sick. He passed a state law that stripped Wisconsin cities of their right to pass laws to protect their workers. And in Iowa, when counties acted to raise the minimum wage, the state legislature stepped in and told them they could not protect workers with a higher wage.

Now Minnesota is facing the same threat. After a year of deliberation, Minneapolis and St. Paul both passed local paid sick time ordinances last year similar to Milwaukee’s. But now the Minnesota Legislature is threatening to emulate Wisconsin and Iowa, removing power from these cities, telling them they do not know what is best for the people who live there, repealing laws these cities have passed, and telling other local elected officials they cannot respond to the economic realities of their communities.

Cities addressing local workers’ needs

Marcelia Nicholson

As Minnesota is seeing today, gridlock is increasingly preventing state legislatures from addressing many important problems facing workers and residents. Fortunately, cities are stepping in to address these needs of their local workforces.

Minneapolis and St. Paul both followed the lead of the 38 other localities in the U.S. and adopted local paid sick time laws that will take effect on July 1. Duluth is considering the same. And the Minneapolis City Council is now considering a higher local minimum wage, as approximately 40 other U.S. cities have done, to reflect higher local living costs and an expensive rental market.

Rod Sullivan

But the Republican-led Legislature is trying to take power away from Minnesota townships and cities, and roll back all of these protections. Legislation is making its way to Gov. Dayton’s desk that would yank away earned sick days from workers in the Twin Cities and prevent Duluth and other cities from adopting such protections. The legislation would similarly strip cities of the power to raise the minimum wage – freezing minimum pay for workers at $9.50 an hour, which translates to less than $20,000 a year.

We’ve seen this movie before

As local elected leaders from Wisconsin and Iowa, two of us have seen this movie before. Backed by corporate groups, the Republican-led Wisconsin legislature, did what the Minnesota legislature is trying to do: they banned cities from raising the minimum wage and then told Milwaukee and other cities in Wisconsin they could not pass paid sick days laws, letting the people of Milwaukee who voted by a margin of 68% to adopt paid sick days know that their votes counted for nothing, a terrible thing to do to voters in a democracy.

In Iowa, last year, when the legislature refused to raise the minimum wage, five counties across the state responded by approving local minimum wages, boosting pay for tens of thousands of workers. But when Republicans took control of the state senate last November, one of the first things they did was listen to corporate lobbyists and enact legislation stripping counties and cities of the ability to act on the minimum wage, yanking back raises from 85,000 workers across the state. At the same time they refused to raise the state wage, which remains frozen at $7.25. As a result, like in Wisconsin, local governments in Iowa are now helpless to act – while the state continues to sit on its hands, ignoring the basic needs of workers and their families.

A race to the bottom

Even if one believes that action at the state level would be best, many state legislatures simply will not act to protect workers right now. But cities will. If Gov. Dayton allows the legislature to strip power from cities, this will send a chilling message about the state of our democracy and shut down the last realistic avenue for protecting workers in Minnesota.

We have seen what happened when Wisconsin and Iowa went this route: It resulted in complete paralysis with no level of state government willing or able to guarantee basic safeguards. It is a race to the bottom. Working families are counting on you, Gov. Dayton, to protect Minnesota from that bleak future.

Em Westerlund is a member of the Duluth City Council; Marcelia Nicholson is a member of the Milwaukee County Board of Supervisors and public school teacher; Rod Sullivan is a member of the Johnson County, Iowa Board of Supervisors.


If you’re interested in joining the discussion, add your voice to the Comment section below — or consider writing a letter or a longer-form Community Voices commentary. (For more information about Community Voices, see our Submission Guidelines.)

You can also learn about all our free newsletter options.

Comments (3)

  1. Submitted by Garth Taylor on 05/17/2017 - 09:19 pm.


    Cities are the magnets of employment and culture that will drive the local economy forward into the future. To some,it is comforting to resist the future. And even though there are cultural practices and ideas that are objectionable, it is not a good idea to hold back urban change. Guide it. Shape it. But do not attempt to choke it off. The states, and the local economies, that prosper win the mid- to long-range future will be the ones that learn to accommodate and benefit from the vitality of urban change.

  2. Submitted by Mike martin on 05/18/2017 - 01:44 am.

    We verses They

    The authors advocate a we verses they argument. We are good they are bad. Sounds like a right wing commentator on Fox News or Donald Trump The issue is different but the attitude is the same. An attitude guaranteed to turn-off people that disagree with them.

    They blame big corporate lobbyist for what happened at the State Legislature. Not all opponents are big corporation. Some are small businesses. Big Corporations have the money to hire more payroll people to handle the complexity of multiple wage & sick leave polices in the same county. This would be an expensive burden for small businesses that have 3 stores/restaurants in 3 cities will different wage & sick leave polticies.

    They choose to ignore examples like Sunday liquor sales in MN was held up because opponents included the Teamsters Union, small liquor stores and municipal liquor store The Teamsters were afraid their members might have to work on Sunday to deliver liquor & beer to liquor stores. Small and Muni liquor stores were afraid they would just spread 6 days of sales over 7 days with little or no increase in total sales

    The Milwaukee County Commissioner does not talk about how the County payroll department would handle it; if there were from 2 to 10 different minimum wages and sick leave policies in the County because different cities had different minimum wages and sick leave policies. If a County worker is relocated from one city to another, could his/her wages & sick leave change because the 2 cities have different policies? Some will say this example is silly but it could happen

  3. Submitted by Paul Udstrand on 05/18/2017 - 03:04 pm.

    Dayton already vetoed this didn’t he?

    Dayton said he was going to veto this legislation if it passed a few days ago, so I’m not sure where it’s at now.

    But you have to Remember, for Republicans elections aren’t about representing constituents, and they don’t really believe in democracy, they just want to exert power and dictate policy. This is why the same guys that pretend to be champions of local control when it comes to school boards, are enemies of local control when it comes to living wages, their hostility is consistent, but their rationales are quite pliable.

Leave a Reply