Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.

Community Voices features opinion pieces from a wide variety of authors and perspectives. (Submission Guidelines)

The WHO is needed now more than ever

On May 29, President Donald Trump declared his decision to withdraw the U.S. from the World Health Organization (WHO) and leveled accusations that it had failed to alert the world of the gravity of the COVID-19 virus in a timely manner and is too closely aligned with China. It is imperative that we set aside our focus on assigning blame right now and focus on saving lives. There will be plenty of time for analyzing our successes and failures later. The health care workers of the world need us to work on getting them the tools to do their job and keep people alive until better treatments, and vaccines, can be developed.

Charles Adams Cogan
Charles Adams Cogan
We think of pandemics as things of ancient history, like the Black Plague in Medieval Europe. In fact, they are not so distant. In 1946, the Minnesota State Fair was closed down in the midst of a polio epidemic. My wife (a registered nurse) is the oldest child in her family because her three older siblings all died on the same day in the early 1960s when measles struck her home. Polio and measles are now vaccine-preventable and the challenge is simply to get the vaccine to everyone in need. Just a few years ago, a vaccine was developed rapidly to protect people from Ebola after a terrible outbreak in West and Central Africa threatened to spread to the rest of the world. The science of immunology and epidemiology has made huge strides in recent years. However, vaccines cannot be developed overnight and people are dying right now.

Years of experience, strong partners

How do you coordinate a global effort on this scale? WHO has people in almost every country and years of experience dealing with infectious diseases. It also has strong partners. In the Global Polio Eradication Initiative (GPEI), WHO partners with Rotary International, UNICEF, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and now Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance. They have a working relationship with national governments across the globe. In 1988, when the GPEI was launched, there were 350,000 cases of wild poliovirus in 125 countries. Thirty-two years later, there were fewer than 200 cases of wild poliovirus in the world last year in just two countries: Pakistan and Afghanistan.

In 2004, I led a team of Rotary members to West Africa for an integrated vaccination campaign, where the oral polio vaccine and Vitamin A drops were administered, along with measles vaccine, bed nets for malaria prevention, and medicine to kill intestinal parasites. Each intervention had its sponsor. It was an incredible example of leveraging the work of multiple organizations to provide more comprehensive coverage to children than any one organization could have managed. At the same time, each organization was used to working alone, getting all of the publicity and having their way when it came to planning for a national campaign. There were some disagreements as we prepared to launch that threatened the effectiveness of the campaign.

In this context, the WHO national director arranged for me to join the chair of the Togo National PolioPlus Committee to address the public on national radio. We provided the names of all of the partners and the important contributions made by each, explained the importance of attending the vaccination events and addressed rumors that had circulated about the safety of the vaccines. Then, the WHO director summarized the schedule for the coming days and called on all parents to bring their children to the vaccination sites. Internally, he also worked to remind all of the organizations that our goal was the same, to protect children from illnesses that were preventable. The campaign was a huge success and the entire region has been free of the wild poliovirus for more than 10 years.

In northern Nigeria, where conflict with Boko Haram and related militant groups has made vaccinations dangerous and difficult, WHO coordinated the work of national health service agencies in several bordering countries, security forces in each country and international partners with such success that Nigeria has not had a case of wild polio in more than three years and the entire African region may soon be declared free of the wild poliovirus. There are many powerful nonprofit organizations with a focus on health care. Without WHO, they lack the organizational power and global presence to coordinate their efforts.

Pandemics cannot be treated piecemeal

The world was already full of conflict and discord before COVID-19. The coming months will be terrible ones, even in countries with relatively robust health care systems. For those with fewer resources, the outcome is still in the balance. Pandemics cannot be treated piecemeal. Viruses do not respect international borders. If any country fails to contain COVID-19, we are all vulnerable. WHO is needed now more than ever.

The current situation reminds me of a DC graphic novel that was made into a blockbuster movie, “The Watchmen.” In the movie, the nations of the world are locked in conflict and nuclear war seems inevitable. At the end of the movie, the villain turns out to be a former member of the Watchmen who has decided that only a tangible, external threat will be enough to unite the governments of the world to defend themselves. He engineers a horrible attack on New York City in which millions are killed and the governments of the world unite to face the “alien” invasion. It is not a happy ending, but at least the threat of nuclear war recedes as the world’s leaders realize that they cannot fight each other and face an external enemy at the same time. Truth is sometimes stranger than fiction, and it is hard to fathom why we are not uniting with WHO and the governments of the world to fight the COVID-19 pandemic. We have the resources if we work together.

As a major supporter of WHO, the U.S. has influence. If we pause our funding now, we weaken our most valuable partner. If we have complaints, we have every right to voice them. In order to have this voice, we need to be more engaged than ever. If a glimmer of hope can be seen in times like these, a recent article in the New York Times informed us that, in spite of publicly rejecting calls to ease sanctions on Iran to allow them to face the COVID-19 pandemic, we have worked behind the scenes to allow them access to the resources they need. I am hoping and praying that our announcement that we will withdraw from WHO is another “negotiating” tactic and behind the scenes we are working to repair the relationship and unite to strengthen WHO’s capacities in this time of need.

This is an opportunity for us to see the big picture and do the right thing for a world in need of our leadership. If we seize this opportunity, it will be a source of light in dark times.

Charles Adams Cogan, a member of the board of directors of the United Nations Association of Minnesota, Harold E. Stassen Chapter (UNA-MN), is a former Peace Corps volunteer and Fulbright scholar. He leads the Rotary District 5960 PolioPlus Committee since 2008 and has taken teams of Rotary members to West Africa for polio vaccination work. He received the International Service Award for a Polio-Free World from the Trustees of The Rotary Foundation in 2010 and draws on his experiences for this piece, but this essay is written as a private citizen and not as the representative of the UNA-MN, Rotary International, or any of the other non-profit organizations he serves.


If you’re interested in joining the discussion, add your voice to the Comment section below — or consider writing a letter or a longer-form Community Voices commentary. (For more information about Community Voices, see our Submission Guidelines.)

Comments (9)

  1. Submitted by Joe Smith on 06/11/2020 - 03:09 pm.

    The WHO is a joke. They couldn’t get one thing right in this latest coronavirus case. Show me something they got right on COVID 19 and is it worth the hundreds of Millions we pay to them annually? I think not!

    • Submitted by Pat Terry on 06/11/2020 - 05:07 pm.

      The hundreds of millions are a pittance compared to the billions, if not trillions of dollars Trump’s incompetence has caused. If we had a president who prepared for a pandemic instead of eliminating the preparations made by his predecessor, we’d be in much better shape. But we elected a man who was a complete failure at everything he has ever done. Now he has run the economy into the ground just like he ran all his businesses into the ground.

    • Submitted by Jimmy Kolker on 06/11/2020 - 06:16 pm.

      I take up the challenge identified by Joe Smith. Very early on, WHO got right that a reliable test was needed to diagnose Covid19. They have a huge network of collaborating labs. Usually the US CDC comes up with the first test, but this time, it was a German lab. WHO provided hundreds of thousands of reliable tests to the majority of countries around the world, before the US was able to process more than a few dozen. The US does not “pay them” millions. We pay dues like every other country and make investments in specific activities that we decide are in our interest. The WHO budget is one-third of the Minnesota state Department of Health’s and we partner with them on programs important to the U.S., such as the polio program described in the article. Neither WHO nor anyone else got everything right in detecting and responding to coronavirus. But none of this is a joke. Hundreds of thousands are dying around the world and that is worthy of everyone’s efforts to find solutions.

    • Submitted by Nina Mattson on 06/12/2020 - 12:19 am.

      Wtfu Joe! This is not a political issue it is a health issue. If your children or other family contracted a disease caused by an unknown contagion wouldn’t you want them to get help by the world’s leading scientists with the ability to create a vaccine? This is not a political issue! You seriously trust that orange clown to make decisions for you and your family’s health? I don’t even know you but pray only for the health and safety of your family and mine every day! Wtfu! (Wtfu= wake the fuck up!)

      • Submitted by Dennis Litfin on 06/12/2020 - 12:03 pm.

        Journalism well put, Nina. Thank you..

      • Submitted by Joe Smith on 06/12/2020 - 02:24 pm.

        If it is not a political issue why did the WHO side with China and claim this virus was contained and travel was safe? The WHO was not allowed into China to conduct tests, they just parroted what China told them. With a little reading you would see China played the World Health Organization and is responsible for the virus getting out of China. Sometimes you don’t get the real news from MSM. As I stated, not worth the money by a long shot

  2. Submitted by Eric Snyder on 06/11/2020 - 07:52 pm.

    Thank you to Mr. Cogan for contributing this piece and also his public health efforts.

    The world would be a much worse place were it not for the WHO. Let’s hope that come this fall there will be a turnaround in the US’s approach to working with and adequately contributing to this leader in improving the health of all humans.

  3. Submitted by Nina Mattson on 06/12/2020 - 12:10 am.

    “Without WHO, they lack the organizational power and global presence to coordinate their efforts”. This is the statement that affected me the most in this article. The comment by Joe Smith seems to be fueled by political alliance and that is not a strong enough argument for me–it is such a sad and ignorant perspective! If there is an organization who provides the evidence based level of support during a health crisis, then we as a country need to support them! Mr. Cogan presents not only factual evidence but also personal experience with WHO that supports this country’s need for an alliance with this organization. I just pray that Trump’s politicizing in order to place blame for his obvious ignorance (i.e. saying he doesn’t fear the disease at first then later taking medication to prevent getting it that is not approved by the FDA for fighting it) does not lead to a fissure in our alliance with WHO. I pray this for my family and especially all of our children in this country who are subject to infectious diseases!! Thank you Mr. Cogan for your courage to share your very cogent and “woke” perspective! Nina Mattson

  4. Submitted by Richard Owens on 06/12/2020 - 10:04 am.

    The WHO developed the tests that helped South Korea (who learned of the epidemic about the same day the US did). HOWEVER, since the CDC decided to make its own tests, and because they didn’t know their tests were contaminated, we didn’t even use the services we contributed to.

    In the first weeks after the Wuhan outbreak, China submitted to pre-servers the genome of the virus.

    I can only imagine what a diseased, frightened and helpless population we may become because Republicans got involved in fighting the World Health Organization when they could have begun learning about the real enemy and help us work together. Our healthcare system isn’t even designed to serve all of us.

    The Arts section story this week mentioned Mike Osterholm and quoted him, but should have linked us to the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy website.

    Mr. Smith you can gain much information here (and see the WHO is not a joke). The World Wide Web allows you to go as deep as your sturdy allows about the real enemy that is COVID-19.
    Check it out.

Leave a Reply