Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.


Community Voices is generously supported by The Minneapolis Foundation; learn why.

Lessons from the pandemic: Start with advancing Medicare for All

Changes should include enacting a wage replacement system for times of economic or natural crises and in the event of another pandemic.

REUTERS/Lucas Jackson

Imagine a seamless, coordinated health care system that would be possible with national health insurance like that proposed by advocates of Medicare for All. Then think about what has transpired in our country since the pandemic began. Might we have fared better? Been more prepared? More cohesive as a people?

Clearly, we have witnessed the failure of the Trump administration to lead a coordinated, national, science-based, public health response to the pandemic. A state-by-state approach proved a disaster as wave after wave of virus spread to every corner of nation. The virus, if you will, trumped states’ rights. Pun intended.

This commentary, however, asks the question: What if a Medicare for All insurance system had been in place long before the pandemic and before the Trump administration? For example, no one would have lost their health insurance, no hospital would have lacked personal protective equipment (PPE), there would be no shortage of nurses or doctors, no bills piling up on kitchen tables, no medical bankruptcies and no co-insurance payments.

Instead of efficiency, an expensive bureaucracy

Instead of the efficiency inherent in a national health insurance program we have expensive marketing, administrative and billing bureaucracies of the private insurers that in turn impose administrative burdens on hospitals and medical providers. A bureaucracy that delivers no health care, but eats up an estimated 32 percent of every health care premium dollar. Medicare’s administrative costs average about 2 percent.

Article continues after advertisement

Such an administrative savings means the nation could cover everyone and expand Medicare to include dental and eye coverage without additional overall funding. The tens of thousands now working in private insurance and billing departments could be trained as health care providers or for other productive work.

An egregious example of the failure of our for-profit, privatized health care and insurance system is the recent need to require nursing home staff that test positive for COVID, but who are asymptomatic, to perform their work. The choice forced on an already understaffed system is between exposing patients and having enough staff to care for them. How could we let this happen in our nation?

President-elect Joe Biden repeatedly mentions his determination to help our nation heal. I suggest that the most concrete measure he could take is to alter his opposition to national health insurance and lend his years of political experience to advancing Medicare for All. This is a time like no other since that of President Franklin Roosevelt’s for transformative leadership. As such, Biden has a chance to guide the nation, as did FDR, along a path that leads to a more just and fair economic future.

Inadequate economic support

Adding to the health insurance crisis is our government’s inadequate economic support in response to the pandemic. What if the U.S. had a system like that in Europe, where as much as 80 percent of payroll has been covered for anyone laid off due to actions taken to stem the pandemic? Rent and mortgages could be paid, businesses, large and small, affected by the pandemic could have retained their employees on payroll. Independent contractors and freelance workers could be included. Instead of a pink slip, employees would have continued to receive a payroll check. This too is a more efficient means to distribute economic support.

Two friends of mine in Norway have had no work since March because of the pandemic as they provide services for the entertainment and convention industry. Both are independent contractors. They have no worries about making mortgage payments as they receive 80 percent of their incomes. They have no worries about health care, as everyone, including non-citizens, receive health care. If someone becomes ill they need not choose between working and quarantine.

Wayne Nealis
Wayne Nealis
If a wage replacement program were in place there would have been no food lines and less need for food shelves. For those who are still in need they could be issued renewable EBT cards (the electronic form of food stamps). This is far more efficient as the holder would simply buy what they need at a grocery store. This would also benefit agriculture producers, especially growers of perishable goods.

What can Americans do? Protest this state of affairs. Demand our politicians act to ensure this never happens again. If they are not responsive, replace them. Demand they advance a Medicare for All bill and enact a wage replacement system for times of economic or natural crises and in the event of another pandemic. This should be followed by enacting social benefits such as affordable child care, low-cost or free post-secondary education and paid parental and vacation leave on par with our peer nations. Now, imagine this pandemic year had we had these social benefits and programs in place.

With these measures a more productive, cohesive and less stressful future is possible. Business will object, but they too would benefit by a more well trained, healthy and educated workforce. This is the unfinished work necessary to raise our society to a level commensurate with our productive, technical and democratic potential.

Wayne Nealis is a writer and longtime peace and labor activist living in Minneapolis.


If you’re interested in joining the discussion, add your voice to the Comment section below — or consider writing a letter or a longer-form Community Voices commentary. (For more information about Community Voices, see our Submission Guidelines.)