Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.


TCF unhappy with Fed Reserve plan for big cuts to its fees


Early this week, Best Buy’s stock price took a hit after a third quarter diminished by online retailers and Apple-loving consumers. Now TCF Bank is off 8 percent after the Federal Reserve suggested new rules to cut down on debit card fees charged to stores by … well, by TCF Bank for one. MPR’s Bill Caitlin applies a local spin to the original Bloomberg story: “Wayzata-based TCF Financial, parent company of TCF Bank, has sued the Fed to block the new rules. TCF says it is the 12th largest issuer of Visa debit cards, and received debit card fee revenue from retailers ‘of just over $100 million from a swipe fee that amounts to a little less than $0.50 per average transaction of about $35.’ Terms outlined by the Fed in documents posted on its website today include a plan with caps no higher than 12 cents per transaction. The fees currently average about 1 percent.”

The Wall Street Journal story says: “Stocks of debit-card processors and banks that issue cards got hit. MasterCard Inc. plunged $25.73, or 10%, to $223.49. Visa Inc. tumbled $9.75, or 13%, to $67.19. The card companies don’t actually collect swipe fees themselves, but the new proposed rules would loosen their control over the process and allow merchants to choose rival payment networks. Some analysts say banks will try to pass on some of their lost revenue by reducing what they pay the credit-card networks. MasterCard general counsel Noah Hanft said, ‘This type of price control is misguided and anti-competitive, and in the end is harmful to consumers.’ ” Allowing merchants a choice is “anti-competitive”?

Oh good god. On the heels of the Salvation Army bell ringer pulling bills out of his kettle with tweezers, we have the Habitat for Humanity manager allegedly ripping that group off for … $60,000. Anthony Lonetree’s Strib story says: “The former manager of a Twin Cities Habitat for Humanity retail store has been charged with swindling the operation out of tens of thousands of dollars through a scheme involving cash for fraudulent returns, authorities say. According to charges filed this week in Ramsey County District Court, Zachary L. Spader, 30, of St. Paul, made the fraudulent returns and pocketed the cash until a co-worker raised concerns to Habitat officials in May.” I know we should save our anger for Wall Street crooks, but this stuff is pathetic.

Minnesota Attorney General Lori Swanson’s latest target is TaxMasters, the crowd claiming to have special magic in reducing tax debts. Because, I guess, they know a guy who knows a guy … An AP story says: “The lawsuit filed today alleges that the Houston-based company collected up-front fees of as much as $8,000 while falsely claiming it could reduce tax debt by as much as 90 percent and stop the IRS from garnishing wages or making other collection efforts. Swanson says most people don’t qualify for IRS programs to reduce tax debt but the IRS will work directly with consumers on payment plans.”

Crying is in vogue, I guess. Speaker-to-be John Boehner couldn’t stop blubbering on “60 Minutes” last week. Now one of our local Ponzi schemers showed his sensitive side … as he was being sentenced to eight years in the slammer. Rochelle Olson reports for the Strib: “Gerard Cellette Jr., 46, pleaded guilty earlier this year to 36 counts of securities fraud in a scheme linked to phony contracts for his printing business. But in an unusual arrangement, he willingly went into custody a year ago to begin his sentence.” And: “In a teary, halting statement, Cellette told Larson, ‘I just want to say how sorry I am. … I just want to ask for a chance to redeem myself.’ “

“Not guilty.” That’s the plea of Michael Swanson, the St. Louis Park 17-year-old charged with killing two women in Iowa last month. The AP story reports: “The Des Moines Register says Swanson’s attorney, Charles Kenville, declined to comment on why Swanson pleaded not guilty on Thursday. His arraignment had been set for Monday.”

Jeff Larson, known in some circles for renting out his D.C. basement to then Sen. Norm Coleman, is going after Al Franken,
again, says Rachel Stassen-Berger in the Strib’s “Hot Dish Politics” blog. The issue? Actor Eddie Izzard. He gave Franken money. But is a … foreign national?  “Larson, the chair of Senate Accountability Watch, said the group has only filed one other complaint — that, too, involved Franken. Larson has long been an ally to Republican Norm Coleman, whom Franken defeated in 2008. Although foreign nationals are prohibited from contributing to U.S. campaign committees, immigrants who have green cards are allowed to contribute, according to the FEC web site, and Izzard has said he has that permanent residence status. Izzard said in a 2007 newspaper piece that he has a green card and two months ago even tweeted, ‘I’m a Green Card guy paying taxes. Can’t vote. Can donate. Can talk sense” and “Yes — Green card and pay taxes’ last month in answer to a Twitter question about whether he had ‘U.S. citizenship/residency, etc.’ ” Just a question here, what’s worse? Being an “illegal” or being a “green-card-carrying liberal donor”?

The Groveland Tap is showing some bona fide holiday spirit by coming to the aid of The Nook, the St. Paul neighborhood burger joint thrown out of business by a fire earlier this week. KARE’s Dave Berggren reports: “The Groveland Tap will host “Save the Nook Saturday” this weekend with proceeds from drinks and wings going to help employees now without a place to work. The two establishments would be considered competitors, but not under circumstances like this. ‘We want to generate some hope,, says [Tap owner Stephanie] Shimp. ‘We want to help someone out during the holidays and it’s just the right thing to do.’ The news of other restaurants rallying around the Nook humbles co-owner Mike Runyon. ‘You’re so grateful,’ says Runyon. ‘Words can’t speak for how everyone has been helping us out.’ “

The Twins signed Japanese batting champion Tsuyoshi Nishioka.
Terms were three years for $10 million. ESPN reports: “Nishioka had 206 hits last season, becoming the Pacific League’s first player to reach 200 since Ichiro Suzuki, now a star with the Seattle Mariners. Also Thursday, the Twins traded backup catcher Jose Morales to Colorado for minor-league left-hander Paul Bargas. The 22-year-old Bargas was 5-4 with a 3.59 ERA and five saves in 67 2-3 innings for Class A Asheville last season. He was drafted by the Rockies in the 13th round in 2009.” Uh-oh. “Nishioka” and “Ichiro” in the same sentence. Good luck, kid.

You can also learn about all our free newsletter options.

Comments (7)

  1. Submitted by Hiram Foster on 12/17/2010 - 06:24 am.

    TCF is a poor people’s bank. They lure their customers in with the easy entry terms, and hit them hard with transaction fees whenever they can. Theirs has always been a profitable but politically risky business model.

  2. Anonymous Submitted by Anonymous on 12/17/2010 - 07:36 am.

    Re: Taxmasters. Their ads are non-stop on Faux News and MSNBC. I guess we should forever forward just assume that whoever blankets cable “news” with ads is some kind of crook, unless proved otherwise.

  3. Submitted by Greg Kapphahn on 12/17/2010 - 09:39 am.

    These Republican attackers who turn out to be incorrect in their knowledge of the issues involved or in their knowledge of the law of the land (for example Emmer, Pawlenty, and now Mr. Larson) are starting to remind me of “Emily Litella” from the good old days of Saturday Night Live, who always started her complaint section of the “news” by misunderstanding the issues she was addressing then, after the host(s) of the news segment corrected her mistaken impressions, ended with “never mind.”

    Sadly, now days, Emily Litella has weasel news on which she and her fellow, highly-opinionated, poorly informed compatriots can bloviate at will and be taken as accurate, informative, and educational by their equally-opinionated, poorly informed (moreso for watching the weasel) audience.

    And no one EVER says “never mind.”

    When caught in a mistake or even when caught lying outright, they just double down and lie about the lies (about the lies, about the lies).

    If Mr. Larson’s mistaken, misinformed statements about Senator Franken have appeared on the weasel, they are now “fact” for it’s audience and will never be retracted nor corrected. We can look forward to these assertions being used in “pants on fire” attacks against him four years down the road.

  4. Submitted by Greg Price on 12/17/2010 - 01:40 pm.

    Explain to me why TCF is a bad guy for making a profit or for drawing a line in the sand and suing the Federal reserve. If you are going to regulate…then make the playing field even and regulate everybody..

    I just wish more people had the guts Bill Cooper has for calling it the way he sees it…

  5. Submitted by Greg Kapphahn on 12/17/2010 - 03:08 pm.

    I have no problem with TCF making as much money as they want to make if they do it the old fashioned way – by actually (and carefully and wisely) lending the “savings” they hold to others at sufficient interest to turn a REASONABLE profit.

    But TCF gave up that model long ago.

    Now their specialty is finding the most underhanded ways possible to extract money from their customers and from fellow business people – ways which take the most money from people who are the most desperate or people who have no other options (such as people who can’t (and likely never will) manage to keep track of their checking accounts and merchants who have no choice but to take debit cards and to pay whatever outrageous fees TCF and similar institutions collude to charge them).

    These “bankers” are seeking the day when, in ways that are largely invisible to the general public, they will be able to extract a percentage of EVERY financial transaction which takes place in this country.

    If you buy a car (even paid in full), they get a cut.

    If you buy groceries, they get a cut.

    If you buy a tank of gas, they get a cut.

    If you go do a movie, they get a cut.

    Rich or poor, no matter the rate of inflation, they get a cut of every dollar you spend for essentially doing nothing.

    So, Mr. Price, that’s what’s wrong with TCF making a profit: They’re extracting that profit from desperate people who have little or no choice; the more desperate those people, the more they extract, and they do next to nothing to earn the profit they extract.

    It’s the same with many banks today, especially the largest, multi-state and Wall Street investment banks. They’re all about extracting massive benefits for themselves, especially their management, while providing little or no benefit for those they are, theoretically, supposed to be serving. Often the affect they have on society in general is that of any of a wide variety of “wasting” diseases (cancer, MS, ALS, etc.).

  6. Submitted by r batnes on 12/17/2010 - 03:31 pm.

    Greg Price says:
    “Explain to me why TCF is a bad guy for making a profit or for drawing a line in the sand and suing the Federal reserve. If you are going to regulate…then make the playing field even and regulate everybody..

    I just wish more people had the guts Bill Cooper has for calling it the way he sees it… ”

    Making a profit is one thing, gouging the consumer is quite another.

Leave a Reply