Religion taboo topic? Not in blogosphere

MinnPost photo illustration by Corey Anderson

As the gap widened between him and his fundamental Baptist church, Bob Hayton found himself with more and more questions about his faith.

The St. Paul father of four began writing out his questions on a blog to help make sense of his thoughts, particularly the more controversial points.

Hayton eventually left his church, and those thoughts evolved into the creation of his popular blog Fundamentally Reformed.

“I’ve seen people change as a result of interacting with my blog, and I’ve been able to challenge non-Christians with the truth as well,” he explained.

Hayton is one of hundreds of Minnesotans who have taken to writing about their faith in blog form. The high number of Minnesotans expressing their spirituality online shouldn’t come as a surprise: 84 percent of us find religion “at least somewhat important,” according to a 2008 Pew Research poll of the state.

Yet each day, we say nary a word  about our beliefs. We — myself included — avoid the topic of faith with co-workers and acquaintances.

It’s different online.

“To the extent that religion is sometimes a taboo topic in certain social spaces, religious blogging may help individuals express and share their faith in a supportive and encouraging environment,” said Pauline Cheong, associate professor of communication at Arizona State University and the author of “E-vangelism: Thou Shall Not Covet Thy Neighbors Blog Ranking.” “The partial anonymity provided by the Internet and deliberate connections of religious sites encourage religious expression.”

Transmission of values
In Cheong’s studies of human communication and religion, she’s found that there are several reasons people blog about religion, including entertainment and interaction. But, more than anything, she said, people take their faith online to transfer their own personal values onto others. 

In other words, many religious bloggers believe they’ve been called to pass on a message.

“I hope that people read my blog and appreciate that they have learned something that has made them a better person and a better Catholic,” said Ray Marshall, author of the widely read Stella Borealis blog, when asked about the most rewarding part of blogging.

Susan Stabile, a law professor at the University of St. Thomas, writes posts and creates podcasts for her Creo En Dios blog to complement her work as a spiritual-retreat director. She said the best part about religious blogging is the ability to connect with people who she normally wouldn’t interact.

“An attorney in the U.K. A young Catholic woman in Asia. A law student in New York. A couple in California … I get e-mails from people in far-off locales telling me that something I wrote touched them, made a difference in their lives,” she said.

Faithful voices underrepresented
As I interviewed more than a half-dozen people about this subject, one theme emerged from Christians to Muslims, left to right. People of faith say they are underrepresented in the public eye, especially the mainstream media.

The Engage Minnesota blog aims to include Muslims in the broader public discussion by giving them a larger voice in local media. The founders of the site say that since 9/11, the portrayal of Muslims in the media has been overwhelmingly negative.

Fedwa Wazwaz is one of the site’s most thoughtful contributors and sees her writing as necessary, given Americans’ current view of Islam.

“I am an introvert, so speaking or writing drains me,” she said. “It is not something I like to do, as much as is it is something I feel needs to be done. If faith remains solely in the private sphere, then it cannot be challenged and the one-eyed kings will hijack the blind.”

Edina blogger and theologian Tony Jones said that blogs have allowed those with a religious message to “even the playing field” after years of being shut out by traditional media.

“I think we desperately need more media outlets — StarTribune, MinnPost, CityPages, whatever — to employ thoughtful, progressive religious columnists,” Jones said. “Please, God, can Katherine Kersten not be the only religion voice in the Minnesota media?”

More on local religious blogs
After poring over Minnesota’s religious blogs, I’ve realized that the makeup of the faithful blogosphere roughly mirrors what the Pew poll found to be our religious demographic. There are few Jewish or Muslim blogs, a couple of atheist bloggers, a good chunk of mainline and evangelical Protestants blogs and lots of Catholic bloggers.

In addition to the blogs linked above, here’s a list of the more thoughtful, regularly updated blogs from Minnesota about faith:

Minnesota Atheist News, Israel HotDish, The Minnesota Lutheran, Desiring God, Minnesota Mom, Abbey-Roads, North Prairie Pastor, Adoro Te Devote, The Responsible Puppet, Bible Geek Gone Wild, and The Recliner Commentaries.

Do you know some others? Leave them in the comments field below.

Comments (8)

  1. Submitted by Bob Hayton on 06/09/2009 - 08:39 am.

    Thanks for the interview. I agree that its easier to talk religion online. For many caught in an oppressive religious environment, or even for those too embarrassed to ask questions publicly, the web provides a safe place to explore a robust Christianity. It also keeps one on their toes, arguments for other faiths are easily accessible. The web gives you the tools and the need to dig deeper and ensure you know what you believe and why.

    God bless,

    Bob Hayton
    Fundamentally Reformed

  2. Submitted by Rick Notch on 06/09/2009 - 10:11 am.

    Another blog site to add to your list is Progressive Catholic Voice, which is found at: http://theprogressivecatholicvoice.blogspot.com/

    The PCV features original commentary and essays by Twin Cities area lay people, religious and theologians calling the Catholic Church to reform on many issues. The site also has a daily “News Links” feature linking to a wide variety of reporting on the Catholic Church.

  3. Submitted by Jeff Klein on 06/09/2009 - 10:39 am.

    It seems like it would be hard to write an article about religion and Minnesota blogs without including UMN Morris biology professor PZ Myers’ Pharyngula. Perhaps he was left out for being a vocal – and frankly, disrespectful – atheist, in an article that emphasizes Minnesota-style moderation. But his positions are always well argued and his harshness is justified by the tendency of almost everyone else – to play too nice, academically speaking, with the claims made by theists.

  4. Submitted by Ginny Martin on 06/09/2009 - 12:00 pm.

    And then there are those of us who are neither Christian nor atheist. Some of us are deeply religious, do our best to live a life of integrity and love, and stay aware of the spiritual dimensions that surround us and affect our lives.
    I am a Unitarian, where a great deal of diversity of beliefs is not only allowed but encouraged. Many of us do love to talk about our spiritual lives, but not too many people seem willing to engage in it. A blog might be the answer.

  5. Submitted by Justin Piehowski on 06/09/2009 - 12:40 pm.

    Jeff and Virginia,
    Good points. I did think quite a bit about including blogs by Atheists and Agnostics.

    There are many well-written Minnesota blogs on these topics, particularly Myers’, which is one of the most read sites in the country, let alone Minnesota.

    While they are certainly legitimate sources for discussions of faith or lack thereof, I decided that this article would be specifically about religious blogs. Not to discount the importance or legitimacy of other sources, but the keep the article focused.

    Thanks for reading.

  6. Submitted by Susan Garcia on 06/09/2009 - 01:44 pm.

    One thing about blogging is that you can get your entire perspective out before the discussion begins. This is ideal not only for discussions about religion, but about any subject that has opinion attached to it. By eliminating the opportunity for those who tend to interrupt and not accept other viewpoints, a real discussion can occur. I’m glad for people such as Bob who is able to discuss his religion with those who agree AND disagree in a civil manner.

  7. Submitted by Jodi Hill on 06/09/2009 - 02:41 pm.

    Delighted to see an article on Minnesota blogging, especially of the religious sort.

    Being a born and bred Minnesotan, I’ve found blogging about God in my daily life to be a surprisingly spiritual activity that lifts me out of the rather reserved Scandinavian/Germanic waters we Minnesotans swim in (uff da!).

    Find God Blog is found at: http://jodiq.wordpress.com

  8. Submitted by William Malo on 06/09/2009 - 06:15 pm.

    Perhaps you could devote some cyber ink to those Minnesotans who don’t choose to live by religious tenet.
    While your statistics correctly indicate there aren’t many non-believers living in the State, there do exist and they are Minnesotans.
    If it’s difficult for the religious to find support other than online, it’s a far greater challenge for the non-religious.
    If anyone would benefit from such a positive article as this, it would be this small, unrepresented and much maligned community.
    Why not ‘focus’ your editorial savvy on this beautiful group of Minnesotans?

Leave a Reply