Neorenaissance: Herman Cain Joins Mad Tea Party

I can’t explain myself, I’m afraid, sir, because I’m not myself, you see. -Alice in Wonderland

Making a move in GOP presidential primary politics has come to include taking obligatory antiscience positions.  Candidates are making increasingly outlandish statements — statements that once would have disqualified serious candidates for president but now are oddly celebrated.  You stop in Iowa, and New Hampshire, and then you swear on the bible that global warming is poppycock.

We’re all mad here. -The Cheshire Cat

Sliding in the polls, antiscience Red Queen Michele Bachmann tried it herself, claiming that HPV vaccine causes “mental retardation.” Newt Gingrich now says of stem cells that we are “killing children in order to have research materials.” Santorum has always been a little off, thinking we should teach creationism in science classes.  Ron Paul says that HPV vaccine is “not good medicine” even though it’s recommended by medical experts because it prevents the leading cause of cervical cancer.  The secret is social conservatives think it somehow promotes promiscuity by removing a horrible consequence of sex.  Rick Perry claims that “the science is not settled” on climate change even though the US National Academies says climate changes should now be regarded as “settled facts.” He favors biblically-based abstinence-only education in public schools despite the fact that Texas’s teen birth rate is fifty percent above the national average. And of course there’s the audiences, cheering executions and shouting for death for the uninsured – they might as well be shouting “off with their heads!”

Adventures first… explanations take such a dreadful time. -Gryphon

So obviously, to stay viable, Herman Cain had to let his antiscience freak flag fly and sample the tea at the mad party. “Manmade global warming is poppycock,” Cain firmly told radio talk show host Mark Levin, sidling up to the doilied table. “In other words, I don’t believe in it.” Another cup, Herman?

Cain told listeners that “Look, if people look at the real data, the climate has varied ever since we have known that the planet was here.”  That is true, it has.  But the climate has been relatively stable during the time humans have evolved; our evolution “fits” well with the current climate.  Scientists are concerned that the rapid changes occurring under global warming may make the planet inhospitable for our biology, the economy, the environment, and civilization.

Curiouser and curiouser! -Alice

Cain went on to tell listeners an alternate version of reality that bears little relation to actual history.  “And we know that those scientists who tried to concoct the science to say we had a hockey stick global warning [sic] and they were busted because they manipulated the data.” 

Speak English! I don’t know the meaning of half those long words, and I don’t believe you do either! -Eaglet

Just one problem.  Cain’s statement is completely false.  Climate scientists have not been found to have concocted science or manipulated data.  Cain is apparently referring to the illegal hacking of computers at the UK’s Climate Research Unit by climate deniers, not climate scientists.  The climate deniers then illegally posted the emails they stole on the internet and drew attention to ones they claimed cast doubt on climate scientists’ motives. Despite the fact that he was traveling, climate denial blogger Anthony Watts somehow managed to identify and post the key most spinnable emails out of thousands within hours of the illegal posting.  The scientists involved as well as the science have been investigated numerous times and the allegations of climate deniers were found to be false.

You’re nothing but a pack of cards! -Alice

This is a central enough fact of both history and science that Cain should be aware of it as a serious candidate for president, suggesting that he is either dangerously ignorant, easily manipulated by propaganda, or purposely deceitful.  None of these qualities is attractive in a presidential candidate.  Whether we like them or not, facts are facts and history is what actually happened, not what we say happened or wish happened.  

Ah but in this new topsy-turvy world, Alice, up is down, and antiscience ignorance is a virtue.

Here’s a theme song for this new batch of anti-reason politicians. See if you can suggest a better one:

Shawn Lawrence Otto’s new book: Fool Me Twice: Fighting the Assault on Science in America. Like him on Facebook.  Listen to him of Science Friday.  Join ScienceDebate.org to get the presidential candidates to debate science.

Comments (6)

  1. Submitted by Dennis Tester on 10/28/2011 - 08:45 pm.

    “suggesting that he is either dangerously ignorant, easily manipulated by propaganda, or purposely deceitful.”

    If a journalist had said those things about Barack Obama in 2008 when he had the audacity to run for president with zero qualifications, she would have been called a racist. Even if they happened to be true.

  2. Submitted by Richard Schulze on 10/29/2011 - 07:03 am.

    I’m amazed that someone with a degree in mathematics can think that the 9-9-9 plan is at all sensible.

    It requires only superficial examination to see that Mr Cain’s 9-9-9/Fair Tax scheme is more an ill-considered, hand-waving improvisation than a serious plan from a serious policymaker. He’s winging it, which I supposed makes it all the more impressive that he’s been able to wing it all the way to the top in a few polls. But now he’s made himself a target, and an easy one at that, so I doubt Mr Cain will wing it all the way to the nomination.

  3. Submitted by Ginny Martin on 10/29/2011 - 02:04 pm.

    Dennis Tester just gave us evidence of the thinking of the Cain/Bachman/Perry/Gingrich etc. followers.

  4. Submitted by Ginny Martin on 10/29/2011 - 03:32 pm.

    I don’t think science is not only denied in other countries, but has turned into a political football. This is a dangerous place for America to be. The Catholic Church (1992 to the deceased Galileo (he died in 1600something). But I don’t think scientific inquiry stopped with him.
    Science and truth have a way of making themselves visible. I suspect we will look back at Cain, Perry, Bachmann, and others as ignorant and dogma bound as we know Galileo was. But we already know the truth about evolution, stem cells, climate change, and all these other things. Holding onto these ancient and wrong concepts just delays us from making progress. What other country has gotten bogged down over the evolution controversy? That’s nuts. Let’s get on with it.

  5. Submitted by Marcia Brekke on 10/30/2011 - 09:51 am.

    Oil, coal, and gas companies have lots of money and lots of incentives to make sure enough of us believe what the climate-change deniers are selling, persuading enough folks to keep voting against the environment–and for the Republican party.

  6. Submitted by Thomas Swift on 10/31/2011 - 09:50 am.

    Oh that teh crazee Michele! Next thing you know, she’ll be questioning the rock solid, *scientific* consensus on the effectiveness of flu vaccines!

    Wait; what??

    http://chemistry.about.com/cs/howthingswork/a/aa011604a.htm

Leave a Reply