Let’s stop repeating statistical exaggerations about black men

Dr. Ivory Toldson

Many of us black men who have championed our own rights in this nation for a long time are pleased to see Dr. Ivory Toldson, an associate professor at Howard University, debunking some of the longstanding myths surrounding our community.

Toldson, at a recent inaugural session of the Men of Color Think Tank at the University of Minnesota, knocked down  these often-reported inaccuracies:

• One-third of black men in the United States will serve time in prison

• There are more black men in prison than in college

• Black males are a dying breed

• Black male youth today are more violent than any previous generation

“What does the line, ‘there are more Black men in jail than in college’ have in common with the Jheri curl?” Toldson rhetorically asked the audience. “The answer is they were both invented by white men and adopted enthusiastically by black people, and they left a nasty stain on the shoulders of millions of black men.”

Toldson researched the one-third figure about Black men in the prison system and found that it was incorrect and often repeated by the media and in reports released by various organizations. That old “one in three black men going to prison” figure is based on questionable research led by Dr. Thomas Bonczar and referred only to black males born in 2001, Toldson said.  In reality, today more black men are in college than in prison, he added. 

Further,  instead of dying off, the number of black males between the ages of 15 – 24 is actually increasing.  And it was actually during the mid-1980s and early 1990s, when illegal drug trafficking was at its height, that crime among black youth was the most violent, Toldson showed. More detail on Toldson’s debunking of commonly repeated exaggerations about black males can be found on The Root website. 

Toldson noted that black people and leaders themselves have perpetrated these very misconceptions, to dramatize legitimate concerns with discrimination and disadvantage.  But the exaggerations ultimately hurt black males who internalized the negative stereotypes. “A lot of people were regurgitating them and didn’t realize how they would influence black males,” Toldson said.

Toldson, also the deputy director for the White House Initiative on Historically Black Colleges and Universities, was the keynote speaker for the first event sponsored by the Men of Color Think Tank, a project of the University of Minnesota Office for Equity and Diversity. The think tank aims to be an ongoing forum bringing together thought leaders from community organizations, faculty and staff at the university and surrounding institutions. Students and advocates are involved as well.  The initial large group meeting in late April was followed up the next day by break-out sessions with ongoing meetings planned for the future.

Louis Porter II, Ed.D. is a Growth & Justice board member and policy fellow. He teaches at the University of Minnesota and operates a communication and organization development consulting practice.

This post was written originally published on the Growth & Justice Blog. Follow Growth & Justice on Twitter: @GrowthandJust.

If you blog and would like your work considered for Minnesota Blog Cabin, please submit our registration form.

You can also learn about all our free newsletter options.

Comments (2)

  1. Submitted by Rachel Kahler on 05/08/2015 - 10:07 am.

    Exaggeration

    This is a great thing to read. It is hope and change (to borrow a campaign phrase from someone who would, based on the wrong statistics, probably be in jail rather than being in the highest office in the US). I am glad to know that the statistics that have been thrown around are probably wrong, and probably too pessimistic for the purposes of driving various narratives. Some of those narratives are vicious–justifying racism and classism. Some of those narratives are well-meaning. However, the pessimism of the situation makes it appear that much harder to improve. But things are improving–at least with regard to race–as I’ve noted in many posts, we don’t have a race gap, we have a class gap. But, because of openly racist policies in the past, a disproportionate number of people that suffer from classist policies are people of color. We need to adjust our thinking to address the wealth and class gap. Part of the solution is providing hope. Part of the solution is economic policy that provides tangible support for the hope. And part of the solution is to quit protecting the rich at the expense of the poor, and shamefully claiming that the poor deserve their lot. Finally, we need to stop pretending that the world is either entirely racist or there is no such thing–the truth is in between and to ignore that is to stand in the way of improvement.

  2. Submitted by Connie Sullivan on 05/08/2015 - 11:55 am.

    How refreshing this article is, and how hopeful! However, I just read an article in the May 11 The New Yorker by Jeffrey Toobin on a Milwaukee county attorney who’s trying to solve the problem of too many young black males going to prison by innovating with teams of personnel on ways to avoid filing criminal charges on low-level crimes committed by young black males; Toobin cites the figures that this article claims are untrue. The figures are everywhere you look. Nearly half of all jail prisoners are now black?

    We have got to stop exaggerating, as you say. But somebody has to inform the newswriters, as well as the advocates out there.

Leave a Reply