Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.


For Minnesota immigrants with dreams of playing pro soccer, club fees are a major hurdle

MinnPost photo by Ibrahim Hirsi
Yimer Woldeyes, center: “To play for a big team, you have to go through a lot of training. You have to have a good coach. You have to be in a good club. But these things are too expensive. It’s like $2,000 a year. We can’t afford that.”

On a recent Friday evening, over a dozen young immigrant players from Ethiopia, Mexico and Somalia showed up in various European soccer jerseys at the East Phillips Park in Minneapolis.

All of them wanted to play, but the soccer field could only hold 12 people at once. So they divided themselves into three teams — with two groups playing against each other, and the third one waiting outside to replace whichever team lost first.

They had no coach to supervise them and no referee to enforce the rules of the game. Instead, the players assigned their own positions and called their own fouls. The system seemed to work well until a goalie, who asked to play forward, was left with two options: leave the field or remain a goalkeeper. (He chose the latter.)

Though each player wore a random jersey, which made it difficult to differentiate between the teams, it was easy to spot Yimer Woldeyes, an Ethiopian-born teenager who dominated the midfield with his speed, near-perfect ball control and masterful passes.

Even with such skills, though, Woldeyes — like many of his immigrant and refugee friends — has never really imagined playing in professional leagues in Minnesota. That isn’t because he doesn’t want to play competitively; it’s because he knows that getting there requires a lot more money than he has available.  

“To play for a big team, you have to go through a lot of training,” said Woldeyes, a junior at Minneapolis South High School. “You have to have a good coach. You have to be in a good club. But these things are too expensive. It’s like $2,000 a year. We can’t afford that.”

Expensive training costs

Woldeyes is among thousands of young immigrant and refugee players who came to the U.S. with some soccer skills that could put them on a path to a professional soccer career.

Sometimes, these youngsters develop an interest in making a living as soccer players after their arrival in the U.S. For example, when Aweis Hassan, a Somali immigrant who was also at the East Phillips soccer field on Friday, came here in 2013, he learned for the first time that some people make a career as soccer players in America.

“I heard that you get money for playing soccer,” said Hassan, a senior at South High. “I didn’t even know you could do that.”

During most of his time here, Hassan has been involved in soccer activities. Like Woldeyes, he plays for the school’s soccer team and he shows up to the East Phillips field every day for practice.

But none of these activities provides him and his friends with the formal training they need to be physically and mentally prepared for competitive youth leagues — which is the reason Hassan and Woldeyes think they will never make it in professional soccer.

Indeed, former head coach of the Minnesota Thunder, Buzz Lagos, knows too well the experience Hassan and Woldeyes describe. Between 2005 and 2015, Lagos served as the soccer coach of St. Paul’s Higher Ground Academy, where he trained hundreds of East African immigrant and refugee students. “They had good soccer experience in Africa,” he said. “So it was a nice way to work with them and get them better and better through some coaching. We developed some very good teams.”

But Lagos also encountered a number of challenges while training the students. First, the students were from low-income families who couldn’t afford the fees to maintain a strong soccer club. Second, he had to provide the transportation to get students to and from games because their parents weren’t able to do so.

Buzz Lagos
MinnPost photo by Ibrahim Hirsi
Between 2005 and 2015, Buzz Lagos served as the soccer coach of St. Paul’s Higher Ground Academy, where he trained hundreds of East African immigrant and refugee students.

For affluent American families whose children participate in formal soccer clubs, he said, the experience is much different. The parents usually pay an annual fee of $4,000-$6,000 a year for each child and provide transportation and other needed services to the teams.

In return, their children receive advanced training and a chance to play in major tournaments across the nation. This advantage could help them gain the attention of professional soccer club managers who are recruiting players for their teams — a chance that Woldeyes can never find at the East Phillips soccer field.

Alternative clubs

In response to that practice, former U.S. women’s national team goalie Hope Solo criticized in June the U.S. Soccer Federation for imposing high fees to play in soccer clubs and thus excluding people of color and poor people from playing soccer competitively.

“We have alienated the Hispanic communities,” she said on a podcast. “We have alienated our Black communities. We have alienated the underrepresented communities, even rural communities.”

While expensive coaching costs cut short many immigrants’ dreams of playing in professional soccer leagues, it hasn’t taken away their passion for the sport. In fact, each day during the summer, hundreds of immigrants and refugees pack soccer fields throughout the Twin Cities metro area.

In the last two decades — when Minnesota started to see an increase in the number of African, Asian and Latino immigrants and refugees — private companies, public agencies and nonprofit organizations have set up dozens of new soccer fields in Minneapolis and St. Paul.

The Minneapolis Park and Recreation Board, for example, owns eight synthetic turf fields, seven of which were constructed in the last 10 years. They include half-sized fields for young players and full-sized ones for adults.

These soccer fields, as well as those at Augsburg University and the University of St. Thomas, have become hubs for Ethiopian, Somali, Hmong and Latino immigrants, who hold tournaments for their communities.

On Sunday, female players from Mexico, Ecuador and Somalia competed in the tournament of the Fútbol Mundial league, which is among dozens of similar leagues organized for ethnic communities across the state.

“A lot of people really need this,” said Moises Hernandez, owner of the league. “They can’t participate in major clubs because they’re expensive. But this gives them the space to do what they like to do.”

Fútbol Mundial league
MinnPost photo by Ibrahim Hirsi
On Sunday, female players from Mexico, Ecuador and Somalia competed in the tournament of the Fútbol Mundial league.

This same reason also brought Woldeyes and others to the East Phillips Park field that Friday evening. Since a competitive game in the Fútbol Mundial tournament was approaching, they wanted to be prepared.  

On the field, Woldeyes is well respected, mainly because of his soccer skills, which have been the culmination of years-long persistence practice and endless passion for the sport. At age 7, he started learning to play soccer from his older brother in Ethiopia.

Since he arrived in the U.S. three years ago, Woldeyes has been trying to make a career as a professional soccer player in Minnesota. Though Woldeyes doubts he will ever see his dreams become a reality, he continues to show up to the field on a daily basis and sharpen his skills.

“We have the talent,” he said speaking of his fate in the soccer profession, “but we just don’t have the chance to make it big because we don’t have money.”

You can also learn about all our free newsletter options.

Comments (7)

  1. Submitted by Ray J Wallin on 07/10/2018 - 04:06 pm.

    Nice article.

    I would encourage those who have children interested in soccer to check out Joy-of-the-People. They have an all-day M-F soccer camp during the summer as well as free play times. It is open to all skill levels, from those who are kicking the ball for the first time to those who play in national tournaments.

    I am familiar with their South Saint Anthony Rec Center location off of 280 and University. There is another facility in SLP, too.

    They have a strong philosophy on letting kids be kids while they learn the sport.

  2. Submitted by Kevin Powers on 07/11/2018 - 06:42 am.

    Kudos to Buzz for his efforts with immigrant community. For folks who aren’t aware he is a legendary pioneer in Minnesota soccer having coached at all levels (including pros) and raised sons who play professionally.

    I don’t think playing professional soccer is a realistic goal, but aiming for scholarships and college opportunities is. This is especially true for women thanks to Title IX. Unfortunately Title IX also reduced the number of scholarship opportunities for boys to play “second tier” sports such as soccer as schools have tried to balance opportunities for men and women while maintaining huge football rosters.

  3. Submitted by Erik Petersen on 07/11/2018 - 08:40 am.

    Wildly innaccurate cost figures claimed

    If the contrast here is supposed to be the immigrant youth soccer experience vs the affluent, suburban youth soccer experience, in reality the contrast isn’t nearly so much as the author is suggesting.

    Travel club soccer in the affluent suburbs does not cost $4k – $6k. It does not in fact cost $2k. Most of the time, it doesn’t cost $1k. It’s somewhat less than any of those figures for a summer schedule of suburb on suburb divisional play plus a couple local tourney entries.

    I would posit also that affluent suburbs with pay-for club play matriculates kids into the pro ranks at a nearly identical statistical rate as the newer arrival immigrant communities. Which is to say, the prospect of professional soccer player employment is about zero for everyone. To the extent there is a credible path to pro soccer, be an elite athlete and the best player on your HS team, and then be an elite athlete and the best player on your college team…. to the extent one can control that. Simple, eh….

    • Submitted by brian hanf on 07/11/2018 - 01:51 pm.

      not right

      >Travel club soccer in the affluent suburbs does not cost $4k – $6k. It does not in fact cost $2k. Most of the time, it doesn’t cost $1k.

      US club and High level teams do cost $4-6K per year.

      $2k is not unusual.

      Under $1k is very rare.

      Sweet spot is about $1200.

      I have coached for a couple of different youth clubs and am currently on the board of one.

      In Minnesota the cost of Winter training is the issue. Dome time for teams run in the many thousands of dollars. Paid coaching and fees for tournament, travel for tournaments out of state.

      Team U13+ (18 players max on roster)
      $5,000 – head coach
      $2,000 – 16 session with technical trainers
      $5,500 – dome cost (2 hours a week 22 weeks at $125 per hour)
      $1,200 – summer league fee/ referee cost (10 games)
      $1,500 – 3 ‘local’ tournaments (400-600 per tournament entry fee – 3-4 games per tournament)
      $1,500 – ‘winter’ league (anywhere from 6 to 12 games, small sided (half team) usually)
      $1,000 – misc team items – manager paperwork, supplies

      Total $17,700
      – if you have 18 that’s $983 per kid per year and this is a very trimmed down budget, mine comes to $1420 per kid (with 17 kids).

      Uniform $90-500 *
      *(my club cost is $270 for uniform – lasts 2 years, some get new one every year at about $90 per kid)

      Travel $????

      U11-12 have 14 on Roster and prices aren’t much if any less than above just less kids
      U9-10 have 12 on roster

      • Submitted by Erik Petersen on 07/12/2018 - 10:21 am.

        I’ll defer to your experience

        I do think $4-6k is clumsily asserted as normative, when its rather obviously a commitment made by families of very advanced players. Its an extreme.

        On the whole, its a ridiculous premise to argue that pro soccer playing careers are barred from people (in this case immigrants) who cant afford youth travel club soccer. Thing is, there’s barely, barely a career path to pro soccer player employment in this country for anyone. Such that this career path might exist, its contingent on being born an elite athlete, and travel club soccer will have no bearing on that.

        Its a ridiculous piece. A wiser discussion would be how to get these first generation American youths through software engineering school.

    • Submitted by Pat Terry on 07/11/2018 - 10:16 pm.

      I have paid those fees

      And the numbers are right.

  4. Submitted by Frank Phelan on 07/11/2018 - 05:39 pm.

    Youth Sports Industrial Complex

    I don’t have first hand information, but I suspect that this is the case with basketball, volley ball, softball, and I know it’s the case for hockey. For a while I have wondered if youth sports will, in the future, have two tracks. One would be the club track and the other would be the neighborhood rec league route. If you want your kid to just have fun and still have time for friends and be able to play 2 or 3 sports, you’d go the rec route. If you want to burn cash in a likely futile effort to go pro while running the risk of your kid burning out on soccer (or volleyball), knock yourself out and go the club route.

    As far as Div I scholarships or pro dreams, give it up baby. That’s no different than counting on winning the Power Ball to fund your retirement. If I were a betting man, and coincidentally I am, I’d bet that an immigrant kid with great grades is more likely to get a full ride than a great soccer player. Given how much time scholarship athletes are expected to spend in training (all year long), odds of completing a degree are much better too.

Leave a Reply