GOP’s 2014 state House strategy: Target swing suburban districts like Ron Erhardt’s

Rep. Ron Erhardt
Rep. Ron Erhardt

Minnesota House Republicans make no secret that they are going full-bore to regain seats lost to the DFL in 2012, particularly in swing suburban districts.

House District 49A, in Edina and west Bloomington, occupies a pivotal position in that battle with two candidates separated by a fine line of political differences. 

Republican Polly Peterson Bowles has announced that next year she’s prepared to take on incumbent DFL Rep. Ron Erhardt, a former Republican who once worked with Peterson Bowles on campaigns in the district. 

The political leaning of the district tips toward the center-right. The politics of Peterson Bowles and Erhardt lie to the right and left of that, respectively.

“I’ve always been with them on the social issues,” Erhardt said of his comfort level within the DFL caucus.

The fiscal issues? Not so much.

Erhardt voted against the tax bill with it new upper-income tax bracket and new business taxes.  ”I don’t remember ever talking about them,” he said of the business taxes, “and they were dumb-ass things anyway, so I didn’t vote for them.”

Erhardt’s bluntness — and the name recognition he earned serving the district for nine terms — guided him to a win in 2012 against Republican Bill Glahn, with 56 percent of the vote.

Peterson Bowles goes toe to toe with Erhardt on district pedigree. She is the daughter of the late C. Donald Peterson, who also represented the district and went on to serve for almost 20 years on the Minnesota Supreme Court. 

Peterson Bowles, a former Miss Minnesota whose sister is a former Miss USA, was appointed to the Metropolitan Council by Gov. Arne Carlson. She tried for and lost the 2012 GOP endorsement for the House seat.

“I’ve always had an interest in government and come from a family where public service was a model,” she said.

“What really motivated me is the frustration of gridlock and the tenor of the public discussion. My father always talked about the lively debate on the floor of the House and [how] people would go out to coffee afterward.  People could disagree, but it did not become personal.”

Erhardt ran his 2012 campaign on a platform of being able to work across the aisle.

Polly Peterson Bowles
Polly Peterson Bowles

Peterson Bowles said she describes herself as a “pragmatic conservative,” saying: “The word compromise from a party standpoint is not a popular word, but there is an art to the judicious use of negotiating a compromise.”

She has nuanced views on the social issues that drove Erhardt to the DFL.

 She believes, for example, that the state’s role in marriage should be limited to determining the contractual requirements of a committed union.

“Regardless of whether the union is a man and woman, or two men or two women, the state should be there to define and enforce the benefits,” she said. “Leave out the word marriage.”

Abortion, she said, is the “federal law of the land. I don’t support abortion as a birth control method or a way of ducking responsibility.”

When Peterson Bowles, now 54, sought the 2012 GOP endorsement, she promised to abide by the party’s decision. This time, she said, “I will hold the idea of a primary in reserve.”

Erhardt, 84, says he’s preparing for a tough campaign against whoever ends up the Republican candidate. He’s already raised $15,000 for a race that could run well into six figures.

While Peterson Bowles pieces together her campaign, Erhardt says he already has his aggressive political plan in place. “Just raise money and go out and kill ’em,” he said.

You can also learn about all our free newsletter options.

Comments (6)

  1. Submitted by David Frenkel on 12/17/2013 - 11:01 am.

    unseating an incumbant

    It is tough to unseat an incumbent when there are no burning issues separating candidates. Almost all new political candidates vow to end political grid lock but the reality is freshman politicians have very little power to do so.

  2. Submitted by Jackson Cage on 12/17/2013 - 11:07 am.

    Well, ummm

    I always had an interest in playing for the Wild, but it doesn’t mean I’d be any good at it.

  3. Submitted by Hiram Foster on 12/17/2013 - 12:21 pm.


    What do you do with social issues if you are a Republican running in Edina? You nuance your views. Edina voters are very sophisticated and they appreciate a good nuance.

    • Submitted by RB Holbrook on 12/17/2013 - 01:41 pm.


      If it’s a way of saying “I don’t really differ from my opponent on these issues, but I know I can’t come out and say that or the party stalwarts will have me for breakfast.”

  4. Submitted by jason myron on 12/17/2013 - 01:43 pm.

    If the Republicans are gambling

    on people forgetting how close this state came to becoming Wisconsin between 2010 and 2012, they’re sadly mistaken.

  5. Submitted by Doug Gray on 12/23/2013 - 09:40 am.

    a personal touch

    One thing Rep. Erhardt used to do, even back when he was a Republican, was to show up on every voters’ doorstep at least once every two years, usually unshaven and looking like he had slept in his clothes, to say who he was and what he was running for. That kind of personal touch can go a long way.

Leave a Reply