Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.

Donate
Topics

NYT compares Obama, Clinton health-reform efforts

Just in time for President Obama’s address to Congress on Wednesday, New York Times reporter Jackie Calmes looks back and forward at Clinton and Obama efforts in a video on “Health Care Reform: Then and Now.”
Her written story, “Clinton’s Health De

Just in time for President Obama’s address to Congress on Wednesday, New York Times reporter Jackie Calmes looks back and forward at Clinton and Obama efforts in a video on “Health Care Reform: Then and Now.”

Her written story, “Clinton’s Health Defeat Sways Obama’s Tactics,” is the second-most popular NYT health story last I checked.

Both reports are worthwhile primers and reminders. The video raises the possibility that more attention will be paid to the compromise legislation proposed by former Sens. Bob Dole of Kansas and Tom Daschle of South Dakota. Dole’s a Republican; Daschle a Democrat.

The written version also spells out the six lessons Obama’s administration is taking from the Clinton administration:

Article continues after advertisement

Lesson 1: Failure Is Not an Option.

Lesson 2: Know your audience — insured taxpayers.

Lesson 3: Move before the honeymoon ends.

Lesson 4: Leave the details to Congress.

Lesson 5: Co-opt the opposition.

Lesson 6: Take what you can get.

Calmes offers more detail under each lesson. But with Obama’s address to Congress coming up, Lesson 6 is on my mind:

“What optimism remains among Democrats stems from their belief that Mr. Obama, unlike the Clintons, will take half a loaf and declare victory, and that most Democrats, mindful of 1994’s election debacle, will go along.

“In his 1994 State of the Union address, Mr. Clinton famously waved a pen and threatened to veto any bill that did not ‘guarantee every American’ private health insurance. Even an aide who recommended that uncompromising signal, Paul Begala, now says it was a mistake. Others have said the White House forfeited a chance to compromise with Mr. [Bob] Dole and other Senate Republicans.

“The question for Mr. Obama is whether he will have any Republicans with whom to compromise. More likely, he will have to mediate between the liberals and conservatives in his own party.”