Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.


Street scenes: A march through St. Paul’s concrete wilderness

Protesters assemble to begin the march.
MinnPost photo by John Camp
Protesters assemble to begin the march.

When several hundred people gathered Tuesday in St. Paul’s Mears Park to march to the Republican National Convention under the banner of the Poor People’s Economic Human Rights Campaign, few of them had any idea that they were about to set out on an odyssey through St. Paul’s concrete wilderness, but, led by the police, that’s what they did, in an exercise that varied from the absurd to the painful.

Protesters began gathering in the Lowertown park around 4 p.m., but there was no electrical power for microphones. Speakers tried to use bullhorns, but were generally inaudible in the carnival atmosphere that included Indian drummers and dancers, a brass band, chanting protesters and several street-theater groups. After an hour or so, a parks service worker, called by police, arrived to turn on the power.

As the speakers finally became audible to the crowd, one segment of the crowd broke away and started running toward the southeast corner of the park. The speaker began shouting to “keep the focus up here,” but the breakaway group surged into the street, where they were corralled by police in riot gear, and by mounted police.

The confrontation lasted a half hour, with scrimmages between news photographers and protesters — Minnesota Public Radio photographer Bill Alkofer got shoved around a bit, and a TV cameraman was repeatedly banged against a van — while the crowd chanted at police: “This is the face of democracy” and “This is what a police state looks like.” There were a few arrests, including one woman who was chased down by the mounted police, and one man apparently had a seizure and was taken away in an ambulance.

Marchers pass under the I-35E bridge.
MinnPost photo by John Camp
Marchers pass under the I-35E bridge.

Around 6 o’clock, the march to the Xcel Energy Center began, and the street confrontation ended.

‘This is crazy’
The convention center is 10 or 11 blocks, depending on the route, southwest of Mears Park. The police, however, led the marchers north out of Mears Park, to Seventh Street, and then east, in the opposite direction from the convention center.

“Where in the hell are we going?” one of the marchers yelled at a police officer, who shrugged.

A barefoot woman said, “This is crazy,” turned around and left the march. Other stragglers began falling out and the march crossed the I-94/35E overpass to Lafayette Boulevard. From there, police led the parade even farther north, through the barren streets of an industrial and governmental backwater with no spectators anywhere — without even a possibility of a spectator — and past the Ramsey Law Enforcement Center.

By then, dozens of people began dropping out and walking away as it became apparent that the march was going to be extraordinarily long; organizers stopped the march twice to rest, as the police led the way up a series of hills, to University Avenue, behind Regions Hospital, then more hills and finally around a corner on Martin Luther King Boulevard to the grounds of the state Capitol building.

A television photographer, lugging a large video camera, said, “They’re [the police] trying to walk them to death so they’ll be too tired to cause trouble.” 

Tired and foot-sore
At the Capitol, the march was joined by a crowd that was breaking up after a concert on the Capitol’s lawn.

Many of the Poor Peoples marchers collapsed on the lawn, tired and foot-sore, but the rest, joined by the concert-goers, surged down Cedar Street into downtown St. Paul, where phalanxes of riot-armored police funneled them into the large cage separating the demonstration area from Xcel center.

Protesters marching down Cedar Street.
MinnPost photo by John Camp
Protesters marching down Cedar Street.

To cover the straight line distance of 11 blocks, from Mears to the Xcel, the police had led the parade some 2 1/2 miles, over two hours; the original crowd of Poor Peoples marchers had diminished by a third before it merged with the concert audience.

At the Xcel, the marchers peered through the bars of the metal cages at the Xcel, where a large video screen was running a history of the Republican Party; and after a few minutes, began to disperse.

John Camp is a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist and best-selling novelist who writes under the pen name John Sandford. He can be reached at jcamp [at] minnpost [dot] com.

Comments (2)

  1. Submitted by Bernice Vetsch on 09/03/2008 - 02:53 pm.

    Where is the outrage from our elected officials (with the exception of Dave Thune)? Senators and representatives – federal and state? Mayors and city council members? Elected leaders of the police officers’ union? I would think even His Republicanness Governor P. would be upset.

    I was downtown Monday and barely recognized St. Paul. If there had been 100 police officers instead of what looked like a thousand, the few who were actually needed to respond to incidents of property damage could easily have done so.

    Instead, there are many reports of police brutality in a week that should instead be one of honor for our Constitution and its guarantees of free speech — whether inside or outside the convention.

  2. Submitted by tom johnson on 05/16/2009 - 06:02 pm.

    If your rights are being directly and publicly trashed I would expect some of the crowd to fight back and then police would arrest these people for acting reasonably – luckily the crowd was wise and knew fighting would not lead to good things. I respect the leaders of the crowd for this, I have no idea who they are and I am not political but this route as a St. Paul local just makes me angry cause it is so blatantly an outrage.

    Walking old people and people in wheelchairs to the point they get ill or lose hope is just an evil thing. They have made 10,000 people and their 100,000 family members feel government is willing to hurt them and restrict their right to speech.

    The officers or secret service who pushed it this far should feel some consequences, rather than I am guessing private congratulations and raises. No firings are needed but some accountability.

    I have not seen other news report this story. Thanks for the reporter who did cover it and at least get it into print.

    Protests are good. After a bad 4 years of war or disasters dammit one should expect and like that a crowd of protesters turns out, and to walk them to death and make them feel manipulated is fascist and sad.

    The Republicans as those saying what is OK to police deserve to lose votes for this until they address this rather than never admit what happened. Ignoring something should not be an option or successful tactic. That is the major point which I would hope the news and public come to, otherwise this will happen again and again whether from Republicans or next time Democrats. But so far this story is being ignored. We need a name for this walk, the “Minnesota Fascist Death March” which sounds bad but opressing free speech while claiming to be American is not ok and could lead to more oppression.

    I know this was just a minor non-violent trampling of some rights, , ,, ,but there should be more consequences and agreement to not do this again.

Leave a Reply