Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.


As Walz’s star rises, DFLers wonder: What about a run for governor?

Tim Walz has the backing of some high-powered folks in his own party.
REUTERS/Yuri Gripas
Tim Walz has the backing of some high-powered folks in his own party.

One of Paul Thatcher’s stories of this year’s election features, of course, the president-elect. But to hear Thatcher, a Minneapolis businessman-of-all-trades and longtime DFL insider, tell the tale, it says more about Tim Walz than it does Barack Obama.

When one of the Wall Street bailouts was being bandied about in Washington, Obama, according to Thatcher, called on Walz, the Democrat who represents Minnesota’s 1st Congressional District along Minnesota’s southern border, to plead his case.

“He got a call from Barack asking him to find five of his ‘no’ colleagues and set up a conference call, saying, ‘I want to talk to you guys,'” Thatcher says. “Obama talked the other five into changing their votes, and Walz told me that if the call had gone on two more minutes, he might have changed his mind too.”

The main point of the story is not Obama’s diligence and persuasiveness in the middle of a campaign and economic crisis — although that’s certainly noted — but that Walz has some juice in Washington. A surprising amount, some would say, for a lawmaker who’s only been on Capitol Hill for two years. (In fact, Walz served as co-president of his freshman class during his first term.)

But such is the ascension of Tim Walz, a 44-year-old former school teacher and National Guard veteran who appears to be riding a Democratic wave and his own bona fides to a new position: leader of the home state party. On the other hand, the DFL has a number of rising candidates right now, and some observers believe the state might be seeing the best crop of young Democrats in recent memory. But to some, the fast-talking barrel-chested guy from Mankato stands above the crowd.

“Our junior Senator Amy [Klobuchar] aside,” Thatcher continues, “Walz is by far the leading political star of the DFL Party.”

And there are whispers — it’s never too early to prognosticate — that Walz could indeed be shaping up as a frontrunner to run for governor in 2010, when Walz’s second congressional term expires. Of course, if Tim Pawlenty decides against running for a third term, everyone and his puppy dog will be clamoring for the Capitol.

“He has the luxury of choices,” Thatcher says. “It’s because of his authenticity. He’s the real deal.”

Second win solidifies status
The Walz camp declined to comment for this story on the congressman’s future plans, but it’s clear that he has the backing of some high-powered folks in his own party.

“I know him very well, and I’m a great admirer,” says Sam Kaplan, a longtime DFL fundraiser who in the past has seemingly had the power to anoint candidates for office. “He has the energy, the passion and the knowledge to do whatever he wants. He has a sense of confidence of himself.”

Kaplan echoes Thatcher’s notion of Walz being a genuine article, and that clearly resonates with voters in his district. In 2006, Walz was unknown in the political world, but he has deep ties in his community, especially in Mankato. A whole new generation of voters in the area can say Walz was their school teacher or high school football coach or National Guard superior — sometimes all three.

Given his background locally, and his no-nonsense approach to social and economic issues — not to mention the two wars — Walz comes across to many voters in the 1st as, simply, one of them.

“I think Tim Walz is part of a new generation of Democratic candidates more suited strategically for the district,” says Larry Jacobs, the director of the Center for Politics and Governance at the Humphrey Institute at the University of Minnesota. “For a while, they were just throwing candidates out there. But Walz fits, in that he’s almost socially conservative and fiscally liberal.”

Walz certainly has made much of his commitment to agricultural and veterans issues — likely the two most important topics in the district year-in, year-out. And while the economy has been hit hard in the 1st, Walz maintained his local credibility by voting against the $700 billion Wall Street bailout. (He’s also a proud member of the NRA.)

That Walz won in 2006 could be chalked up to a fluke, part of an anti-Bush, Democratic wave that year. Still, it’s worth noting that he beat a popular 12-year incumbent, Gil Gutknecht, a Republican who routinely beat his opponents by double-digits. Walz beat him 53 to 47 percent.

This time out, Walz’s reelection was not necessarily a foregone conclusion, but he trounced GOP foe Dr. Brian Davis, a formidable candidate who would be a good conservative fit for the district, 63 to 33 percent. That Walz is only the fifth Democrat to represent the district since 1857 is notable, and there’s reason to believe that he learned a good bit by watching his DFL predecessor, the former congressman Tim Penny, who leaned so moderate in the 12 years he served the 1st, he eventually joined the Independence Party after he left Congress.

“He’s quite diligent on maintaining personal relationships back home, quite apart from policy issues,” Jacobs says of Walz. “And on social and policy issues, he’s been able to frame those in non-controversial terms.”

What are the odds of Gov. Walz?
The question is, could Walz — if he wanted to — parlay that down-home appeal into a statewide office? Even those who support Walz say that’s anything but a lock.

“I think he would be a wonderful governor,” rainmaker Kaplan says. “But he’s made such extraordinary strides in Congress. He’d have to think twice before giving that up.”

And both Kaplan and Jacobs point to an increasingly crowded field of announced and potential gube candidates from the donkey side: state Rep. Paul Thissen, Ramsey County Attorney Susan Gaertner, state Sen. Thomas Bakk, former U.S. Sen. Mark Dayton, former state Sen. Matt Entenza, current speaker of the state House Margaret Anderson Kelliher, Minneapolis Mayor R.T. Rybak, and on and on.

“Maybe 10 years ago, the DFL had a long bench, but they were older,” Jacobs observes. “There are a number of bright, young Democrats right now, and it’s not just Walz.”

And running for governor involves a different kind of scrutiny from the public, the press and the loyal opposition. For instance, there are already rumors about Walz’s personal finances being in disarray, which could be red meat for any opponent., the website that tracks the public and personal financial records of officeholders, lists Walz as 394th in the House as far as net worth. And the website lists his “liabilities” for 2007 as totaling anywhere from $225,000 to $515,000. All this for a schoolteacher on leave from his job.

At least one person is gearing up for the possibility of a Walz governor run in 2010: State GOP chair Ron Carey. Carey notes that Walz spent all of $2.4 million to get reelected, three times that of his opponent.

“And it helps that he can’t mask that he’s a liberal, despite his claims to be a moderate Minnesotan,” Carey says. “I often say that the only thing conservative about Tim Walz is his haircut. And his military background does not guarantee election.”

Jacobs agrees, at least, on Carey’s final point.

“After 9/11, military issues became predominant, but now it’s about jobs and the economy, it’s a one-dimensional electorate,” Jacobs says. “He’s a bright star, sure, but he’s not the only one.

“But he is,” Jacobs concludes, “one of the most natural politicians I’ve seen.”

G.R. Anderson Jr. covers politics, the state Capitol and issues related to public safety.

Correction: The original version of this article incorrectly stated Walz’s military record. Walz served in the National Guard.


Comments (7)

  1. Submitted by Annalise Cudahy on 11/24/2008 - 09:18 am.

    He’s certainly got what it takes, but I wonder if he wants it. The answer to that may come from whether anyone else wants it.

    The DFL candidates for Gov have not been great lately. Hatch was the only statewide candidate to lose in a year that had big DFL gains throughout the state. Roger Moe never caught on fire, which isn’t a surprise. Could Walz?

    What I find fascinating is that the best of the DFL right now are all women. Klobuchar has to lead any list, but for potential Govs we have Kelliher, who knows how to use power like no other DFLer I’ve ever seen, Judy Dutcher, who has a broad appeal, and Rebecca Otto, a quiet but very sharp proven administrator. Walz is the only man who really stands out as a potential contender to Pawlenty in my mind.

    Should he do it? The three women I named would all be good. I’m not ready to jump on his bandwagon, and with so many strong women it’d be a shame not to select one of them. But I do like the guy, and he has a lot of support outside of 1CD. We’ll see.

  2. Submitted by Lawrence Downing on 11/24/2008 - 11:49 am.

    Certainly the answer to this question has to await the results of the recount. Clout in Washington must not be wasted. If Al Franken doesn’t oust Senator Coleman, Tim Walz certainly can!

  3. Submitted by Nancy Gertner on 11/24/2008 - 12:26 pm.

    What G.R. Anderson refers to as ‘Air Guard commander’ for Walz’s military experience is actually that he achieved the rank of Command Sergeant Major, E-9, the top rank for enlisted members.

    I don’t think Walz would ever refer to himself as ‘Air Guard superior’, as the author did. He might call himself senior in rank to some of the other Guard members.

    But true to the role of a non-commissioned officer that is dedicated to the health and welfare of their enlisted Guard members, Walz as Congressman is dedicated to his constituents, and will have to ponder if he can best serve them in DC or in Minnesota.

  4. Submitted by Paul Linnee on 11/24/2008 - 02:54 pm.

    One more clarification on Walz’ military rank. He was a Command Sergeant Major (CSM) in the ARMY National Guard of Minnesota, not the AIR GUARD. The rank structure in the Army National Guard (ARNG) is identical to that of the active army, while the rank structure of the Air National Guard is identical to that of the U.S. Air Force. Hence the top ellisted, non commissioned officer in the ARMY Guard is an E-9, the Command Sergaent Major rank attained by Walz, while in the AIR GUARD it would be Chief Master Seargent, also an E-9.

  5. Submitted by Ray Schmitz on 11/24/2008 - 05:13 pm.

    One needs to recognize that an individual does not get to the rank that he achieved in the service without being a pretty good country politician. Also Dr. Davis was clearly the “base” of the republican party candidate, this failed to recognize that the district had moved from,if it ever was, that uniform in it’s makeup. Gutknecht was blessed with a number of uninteresting opponents and the good ones were ignored by the DFL. I remember one highly electable woman who the then leader of the party totally forgot during a discussion of candidates.
    Take a few minutes to look at the secretary of States web site for some interesting maps of how the voting went in the district, both for Walz and the presidential race, and also the state house and senate. It is still a mixed district, so I don’t think the a good moderate republican would be out of the race in two years, fortunately the party is unlikely to nominate anyone who fits that description.
    Ray Schmitz

  6. Submitted by Charley Underwood on 11/24/2008 - 08:53 pm.

    I realize that she has officially declared her candidacy, but it pains me every time I see Susan Gaertner’s name associated with the 2010 governor’s race. So far, at least, she has completely served the political ambitions of Ramsey County Sheriff Bob Fletcher, the very worst of the worst during the siege of St Paul known as the RNC.

    With all those court cases with fanciful evidence like “weaponized urine” still grabbing the occasional headlines, Gaertner’s candidacy will likely remain an awkward joke, if not a painful reminder of the civil liberties we lost with her as Ramsey County prosecutor. Her only hope is to drop these fanciful charges as quickly and quietly as possible.

  7. Submitted by g.r. anderson jr. on 11/25/2008 - 04:09 pm.

    good people: thank you for pointing out my silly error regarding walz’s service. i know the difference, just flubbed it–mea culpa. the story has been corrected and a note will be appended. i appreciate you pointing that out.

    and thanks for reading, as always. -g.r.

Leave a Reply