Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.


Star Tribune files for bankruptcy and lists unsecured creditors

The Star Tribune, long the largest newspaper in the Upper Midwest, filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy (PDF) Thursday night after months of struggling under a debt load created when the current owners bought it in 2007.

Its filing, in the Southern District of New York of U.S. Bankruptcy Court, discloses publisher Christopher Harte’s specific interest in the company for the first time. The petition said the Christopher M. Harte 1992 Family Trust held a 4.1 percent equity security interest in the Star Tribune Holding Company. The other equity security holders were Avista Capital Partners L.P. (nearly 76 percent of primary shares) and Avista Capital Partners (Offshore) L.P. (20 percent).

The bankruptcy filing occurs after the newspaper missed payments to its lenders and less than two years after Avista Capital Partners bought it for $530 million.

Because the filing is for a Chapter 11 reorganization rather than liquidation of the company, readers may not notice any immediate difference, said Edward Adams, a University of Minnesota law professor who specializes in bankruptcy.

“They can carry on as usual with business,” Adams said. “The public may not see any change for a few weeks or longer.”

In a statement last night, Harte said the filing would have no impact on home delivery, advertising, newsgathering or any other aspects of the paper’s operations.

“We intend to use the Chapter 11 process to make this great Twin Cities institution stronger, leaner and more efficient so that it is well positioned to benefit when economic conditions begin to improve,” Harte said.

The Star Tribune’s petition estimates there are 50 to 99 creditors. It estimates the newspaper’s assets at $100,000,001 to $500 million. It estimates liabilities at $500,000,001 to $1 billion.

(According to a report in the Star Triibune, the newspaper has assets of $493.2 million and liabilities of $661.1 million.)

In the petition, the Star Tribune checked a box that said “debtor estimates that, after any exempt property is excluded and administrative expenses paid, there will be no funds available for distribution to unsecured creditors.”

The largest unsecured creditor listed in the petition is newsprint company Abitibi/Bowater of Greenville, S.C., claiming $1,004,543 is owed to it (described as a trade debt).  The second largest is APAC Customer Service Inc. of Chicago, a telephone-based marketing services company, claiming $133,218, also a trade debt.

Other unsecured creditors include McClatchy Interactive of Raleigh, N.C., with claims of $91,160, and the Minnesota Timberwolves with a claim of nearly $58,000.

Additional local unsecured creditors include Jobview LLC of Burnsville with claims of $45,000, Metro Distribution Service Inc. of Minneapolis with claims of $40,495, John Roberts Co. of Minneapolis with claims of $38,083, Ceres Environmental Services of Brooklyn Park with claims of $36,325, Infinity Direct Inc. of Plymouth with claims of $31,948, and Brooklyn Printing Inc of Brooklyn Park with claims of $26,827.

“This list reflects the information existing and available as of January 13, 2009,” the petition said. “The company reserves the right to amend this list based on information existing as of the filing date.”

The Minneapolis newspaper is the nation’s 15th largest daily paper and 10th largest Sunday paper based on circulation. Other major papers around the country have been struggling too as advertising moved online.

Detroit’s two newspapers recently slashed home deliveries to three days a week. Owners of the Seattle Post-Intelligencer announced last week that the newspaper is for sale and, if a buyer cannot be found, the paper may go all-digital or shut down, the Associated Press reported. The Tribune Company, owner of the Chicago Tribune, Los Angeles Times and other newspapers, filed a Chapter 11 bankruptcy in December.  

The Star Tribune’s financial problems may have been deeper because of debt the owners took on when they bought the newspaper in March 2007. The company that bought the newspaper from the McClatchy newspaper chain, Avista Capital Partners, is a private equity firm which currently has investments in 22 companies, 17 of them involved in energy and health and five in media. 

The owners indicated last summer that they had borrowed for more than 80 percent of the $530-million purchase price. In May, the Star Tribune reported that the owners had written down their $100-million investment by 75 percent. At the time, the owners denied a New York Post report that the newspaper may file for bankruptcy. The newspaper had hired Blackstone Group, a financial advisory and restructuring firm, to analyze its options.  

In a release shortly after the bankruptcy petition was filed, the newspaper said that it earned about $26 million in 2008 before making interest, taxes and debt payments, about half of what it earned in 2007.  

Without debt-related payments, the newspaper would have been profitable through 2008, but less and less so.

The owners pushed last year for concessions from the newspaper’s unions. The Newspaper Guild, representing newsroom workers signed a contract last summer agreeing to wage freezes, health care rollbacks and other concessions.

“Since Avista bought us, they’ve run us into the ground, gotten us into too much debt. It’s not any of the union contracts that forced the Star Tribune to file for bankruptcy,” Guild co-Chair David Chanen told MinnPost’s David Brauer

One fourth of the newsroom employees (including this writer) have taken buyouts or resigned since Avista bought the Star Tribune from the McClatchy newspaper chain.

Sharon Schmickle reports on foreign affairs, science and other topics. She can be reached at sschmickle [at] minnpost [dot] com.

Comments (3)

  1. Submitted by myles spicer on 01/16/2009 - 11:52 am.

    Such a sad set of affairs. As much as I loke (and regularily read) Minnpost, Daily Planet, and Star Trib online, I have looked forward to my hard copy of the Strib for about 50 years now. Times have changed (for the better?)

    I guess it is a generational thing…but I would miss it.

  2. Submitted by Welna Welna on 01/16/2009 - 12:10 pm.

    No mention is made of the enormous debt that was taken on with the purchase of the paper as a major contributor to the bankruptcy in the full page letter to readers this morning. So many fine folks have lost their jobs at the Star Tribune during recent years even as recently as this week.

    We have seen this over and over. Look what happened to NWA which owned it’s own planes, had property and cash reserves when it was purchased not with outside assets but by using the existing companies assests. Sorry to see the local companies large and small that provided services or goods to the Star Tribune that, according to the filing, aren’t expected to receive any payment during the bankruptcy process.

  3. Submitted by Mark Linden on 01/16/2009 - 08:58 pm.

    Just yesterday I read an article in the StarTribune about a small business owner named
    Paul Ridgeway……and it wasn’t the typical “newspuff” Dfler’s normally get. No sympathies here for the StarTribune.

Leave a Reply