Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.


Former Congressman Rick Nolan, in comeback bid, revs up DFL convention crowd

Chuck Slocum
Rick Nolan

ROCHESTER — Late in the afternoon on Saturday, delegates to the state DFL convention here were growing weary.

They’d spent the day crowded together at long tables, applauding speeches by their elected officials and candidates, munching on snack foods and voting  “yea” or “nay’’ on a long list of insider resolutions.

Rick Nolan had seen his late-afternoon spot on the speakers’ lineup and winced.

“If you had to pick a spot to speak, this would not be it,” said the former congressman who is the DFL-endorsed candidate for the 8th District congressional seat held by GOP Rep. Chip Cravaack.

Nolan received polite applause from the crowd when he was introduced.

As he began his speech — without notes — the delegates were half-listening. But the longer he spoke, the more tuned in the crowd became.

“Who is this guy?” many delegates seemed to be thinking.

Nolan was talking about the need to bring U.S. troops home from Afghanistan. He was talking about a single-payer health care system. He was talking about “gay marriage,” not just opposing the so-called marriage amendment. He was talking, in compelling tones, about issues that most Democrats seem to no longer talk about.

In short order, the crowd was with him. The old guy — the former 6th District congressman is 67 years old — can still rock ’n’ roll and move even a tired crowd.

8th District race getting national attention

Nolan, and the race he is in, will bring national attention and money to Minnesota politics this year.

First up is an 8th District primary that promises to be costly and intriguing.

Both of Nolan’s primary opponents opted to not make any sort of appearance at this convention.

Tarryl Clark and Jeff Anderson have meaningful bases of support as they approach the August primary.

Clark, a former state senator,   has a large base of national support, following her unsuccessful bid to defeat U.S. Rep. Michele Bachmann two years ago. Anderson, a former Duluth city council member, has support of such Iron Range stalwarts as just-retired Rep. Tom Rukavina and former House Majority Leader Tony Sertich.

But it is Nolan, who served three terms in the U.S. House (1975-1981) before deciding not to run again, who won the support of activists at district conventions.

This race has national implications because Democrats believe the 8th District seat belongs to them and that Cravaack’s stunning victory over longtime incumbent Jim Oberstar was a one-time fluke.

That thinking, however, doesn’t necessarily reflect contemporary realities.

It’s understood by most that Republicans can fare well in the southern portion of the 8th, which includes the northern exurbs of the Twin Cities.

Political, demographic changes reshape district

But there are even potential political changes in Duluth and the Range portions of the district that create some anxiety for DFLers.

Joe Begich, who was a state representative (1974-92) from St. Louis County, has been attending DFL conventions since 1952.

“In the 1950s to the 1970s, there were 17,000 miners (in the 8th District),” he said. “Now there are 3,600 – and a lot of the younger ones are non-union,” he said.

More shocking to Begich and some of his colleagues is that many of those younger miners find Cravaack “a pretty good guy.”

“They’re not paying attention to how he votes,” Begich said.

But they are paying attention to some contemporary issues that create a philosophical divide in the contemporary DFL.  That big issue — environmentalists vs. mining — came up again at this convention.

All of this means that whoever wins the Nolan-Clark-Anderson primary can no longer count on universal support from the lunch-bucket crowd that once-upon-a-time almost unanimously supported Democrats.

That there is going to be a highly competitive primary in the 8th will make it even more difficult to make Cravaack a one-term wonder.

After his speech, Nolan talked about the problems a primary presents.

Contrary to the prevailing belief that most voters don’t pay attention to politics during the summer months, Nolan believes that time is important for candidates to define themselves and their opponents. But this summer, the three Democrats in the 8th will be busy instead trying to round up support for their August showdown.

An even bigger problem, Nolan said, is that many contributors — including the national party — will not come forward with financial support until after the primary. Often, Nolan said, money comes too late to finance the sort of campaign that will be needed to take out an incumbent.

National money helps GOP ramp up

Meantime, he said, super-PACs, such as the Congressional Leadership Fund (which is headed by GOP stalwarts Norm Coleman and Vin Weber), are raising and spending millions of dollars. Some of that money, Nolan said, is already showing up in the 8th District.

“They’ve got trackers on me already,” Nolan said.

But trackers, who record every word in every speech of opponents, don’t seem to bother Nolan.  He will say what he believes, and he will say it with passion.

Nolan shakes at the carefully worded scripts of so many contemporary pols.

“They’re for access to affordable health care,” said Nolan, laughing. “There seems to be a conventional wisdom, ‘Don’t take a stand.’ Glittering generalities and a lot of money are what you need to get elected.”

Laughing, he added, “Scary thing is, there’s some evidence that’s true.”

But Nolan — who left politics and got into an array of activities, including a business (a sawmill and pallet plant in Emily) — never has been one for caution.

Drawn into politics because of his opposition to the war in Vietnam, he took the difficult step of supporting former U.S. Sen. Eugene McCarthy over former Sen. Hubert Humphrey in the great divide in Minnesota politics decades ago. (Ultimately, Nolan said, he and Humphrey became allies again.)

Will age and absence hurt Nolan?

His age and long separation from seeking elective office may have been negatives early in his campaign, but when audiences have heard him, heard the passion and seen the energy, age has seemed to become a nonfactor.

This ability to give an old-fashioned stem-winder speech is not new, according to such longtime politicians as Sen. Dick Cohen, a St. Paul DFLer.

“Always a great speaker, one of the best,” said Cohen.

In fact,  Nolan was so impressive on the stump that Cohen believed that the congressman would one day become “the next Minnesotan to become a national figure.”

Nolan, though, opted for a different route. He says the experiences away from Washington have prepared him well to be a more effective congressman.

“There are some advantages to age,” Nolan said.

(Um, all of us who have grown older have come to believe there are some advantages to age.)

Certainly, the years haven’t taken away from Nolan’s ability to rouse even a weary crowd.

On the other hand, one of the underlying beliefs of this convention is the need for the DFL to work harder to attract a new generation of supporters.

Rick Stafford, a party activist for 40 years and a former party chairman, spoke of the need “for generational change” in the party.

Stafford recalled that when he became involved in party activities, one of the most under-represented groups in the party were seniors.

“Seniors are now the most over-represented,” he said.

Stafford said the party structure needs to get younger and needs to become more diverse.

Others speak of how the party needs to hone its message to where the swing voters are: the suburbs.

All of these things – changing demographics, changing messages, environmental concerns vs. lunch-bucket issues – are issues in the 8th District, where the state’s major political story of the summer will play out.

There are real concerns on many levels for DFLers. Still, the speaker who woke up the crowd Saturday, had a booming, optimistic finale to his speech.

“The wind is at our back,’’ he told the cheering party activists.

Comments (4)

  1. Submitted by Jane McWilliams on 06/04/2012 - 03:47 pm.

    Rick Nolan

    I was at the convention. Nolan’s speech – both in content and delivery – was in the Wellstone tradition! Maybe his time as come and gone, but younger candidates could do well to aspire to his integrity and candor – not to mention his oratorical skill!

    • Submitted by Rachel Kahler on 06/05/2012 - 09:39 am.

      He did give a great speech

      I’m not sure his time has come and gone. He clearly has retained the ability to get people to listen, and has the right ideas. He’s not feeble in mind or body. And most importantly, he didn’t blow off the convention. The people that attended that convention will be the ones that will move the vote. Sure, you can get on the ballot without being at the convention, and even win (I was amused by Dayton’s comment “thanks for letting me in”). But, getting the support of the people most involved in the election process, the delegates, will definitely put the wind at your back.

  2. Submitted by Eric Ferguson on 06/04/2012 - 04:51 pm.

    We’re all going to get older

    and we’ll want to be taken on our merits. At 67, Nolan is only two years older than Mitt Romney, who isn’t being challenge on his age for a more strenuous job. He seems to be up to the job. Isn’t that supposed to be the issue? He’ll still be younger than a lot of his colleagues, and no one is telling them to quit. If he had health issues that looked to be permanently debilitating, that’s on the thing, but absent that, age shouldn’t be an issue.

    To prebut the lurking conservatives, no, I never criticized or mocked John McCain for his age.

  3. Submitted by Virginia Martin on 06/04/2012 - 06:04 pm.

    Age is not a disqualifier for office of the President. Ability is. This is strenuous but Nolan is sharp and active and there is no reason to disqualifier–asp. as Ferguson noted, he’s only slightly older than Romney.
    Look at his abilities and character and views.

Leave a Reply