Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.


Red Wing’s Howe-Schmit Senate race may be ‘nastiest’ campaign in state

Sometimes it’s hard not to take politics personally, especially when you’re a candidate.

Sen. John Howe
Sen. John Howe

Take, for example, the case of John Howe, the Republican senator from Red Wing. Unlike so many of his first-term Republican peers who came to St. Paul in 2010 with a hard-right, slash-government agenda, Howe showed up  saying he was looking to find  some middle ground.

Although Howe almost always voted with his caucus, he did have meetings with Gov. Mark Dayton on things like tax policy. For his trouble, he frequently was chastised by his GOP “allies.”

Because of those meetings, Howe was disappointed when Dayton showed up in Senate District 21 to help Howe’s opponent, Matt Schmit, raise money. Howe said he was so surprised by the governor’s appearance on behalf of Schmit that he called him.

Howe said the governor told him not to take it personally; that if Howe wins, “we’ll be friends again.

Throughout the state, there are races that show that moderation is no haven from ugly campaigns.

For instance, in Senate District 44, incumbent DFLer Terri Bonoff  is so moderate she’s won the endorsement of a number of pro-business organizations, which typically endorse GOP candidates.

Bonoff even has a little TV spot showing her linking a donkey and elephant to show how she can get along.

No matter.  Literature from the “Freedom Club’’ on behalf of Bonoff’s opponent, Republican David Gaither, paints her as just another “liberal Democrat” who is “a bad apple” on education and has a record that makes her “an economic model based in more jobs lost and more despair.”

Of course, twisting voting records and the over-use of words such as “liberal Democrat” and “extremist Republican” are ho-hummers in American politics.

What seems different about the Howe-Schmit race in District 21 is how it’s become personal. It may be the nastiest race in the state.

Though there are serious issues in the district — for example, what should the state’s role be in the mining of sand used in oil fracking? — the literature from the GOP and DFL dwells on the sensational.

Howe fears that a GOP mailing — which brings up a four-year-old DUI charge against Schmit, complete with grainy mug shot — actually is hurting him more than it’s hurting Schmit. (Charges ultimately were reduced to careless driving.)

Howe insists he had nothing to do with the lit piece.

“The piece is really bad,” Howe said. “Everybody says I had something to do with it. I tell them, ‘I’ve never gone negative in my life.’ ”

Schmit’s supporters don’t believe that Howe is all that innocent.

Howe says that when he’s door-knocking now, he carries several pieces of negative literature that the DFL has used against him just to show that nasty is a two-way street.

“I really believe I’ve lost votes because of the negative ad,” Howe said.

(The DFL is in no position to show outrage over its candidate being hit with an old drinking-and-driving charge. Recall, the DFL-friendly Alliance for a Better Minnesota used  1981 and 1991 drinking-and-driving charges against GOP gubernatorial candidate Tom Emmer in the 2010 governor’s race.)

What seems to most trouble Howe about the GOP attack on Schmit is not just the blowback he’s receiving from the lit. He also thinks the GOP missed a chance to raise a residency issue that Howe has been pushing.

The arrest record on Schmit shows that he gave his address as St. Paul.  In his ads, Schmit has been claiming to be “a lifelong resident of Red Wing.”

Matt Schmit
Matt Schmit

Howe insists that to this day, Schmit is not actually a resident of the district but, rather, has moved from St. Paul to a previously vacant home next door to his parents’ Red Wing home to fulfill requirements that state legislators live in the districts they represent. He indicated that if he loses the race to Schmit, he might take legal action to question Schmit’s residency.

Schmit scoffs at that threat. Red Wing, he says, “is home.” As for the driving charge, he says simply, “I’m not proud of it, but I have learned from it.’’

The campaign, he said, turned nasty when it became clear that he was making major gains in the race.  It’s those gains that brought DFL Senate Caucus money into the race, which many believe now is going to be very close.

While Howe says he’s fretting about the impact of negative literature his own party is using, DFLers — and DFL-friendly organizations — are doing their best to bruise Howe.

One piece of literature claims that during the government shutdown two years ago, Howe continued to receive his pay while state workers went without. Howe says he forwarded his pay and per diem money to food shelves in the district.

Another piece of literature tries to link Howe — and all GOP legislators — to the infamous Senate sex scandal. There’s a photo of a “Do not disturb’’ sign hanging from a hotel-room door. The text reminds Minnesotans that legal fees and settlements in this case are going to cost all taxpayers hundreds of thousands of dollars.

“The DFL has spent $124,000 in my race after I was assured they weren’t going to do anything,” Howe said. “I gotta tell you, I still have a lot to learn.’’

You can also learn about all our free newsletter options.

Comments (5)

  1. Submitted by Robert Gauthier on 11/02/2012 - 09:36 am.

    Travel with skunks

    And you smell like one.

  2. Submitted by Connie Sullivan on 11/02/2012 - 04:33 pm.

    This guy’s naivete is showing. It’s one thing to try to work with the other party’s governor in legislative session, and another thing for the governor later to try to help elect a majority of his own party in the legislature’s two houses. That’s why Gov. Dayton said: “Nothing personal.” It’s not personal; it’s politics and policy.

  3. Submitted by Tom Anderson on 11/02/2012 - 11:15 pm.

    That’s nothing!

    We have received a giant postcard from the DFL party or their candidate for Senate every day for the last week and a half complete with the grainy stretched photos and sensational headlines (most signed by Governor Dayton). The best one was from the candidate calling out her opponent for negative ads (we have yet to receive even one mailing) and saying how she is a grandmother and would never do anything negative to win an election. No way that the grandmother loses, but at 71 I’m guessing that we won’t need term limits to eventually replace her.

    • Submitted by Tom Anderson on 11/03/2012 - 07:13 pm.


      Two more giant postcards today. This onslaught of cash may kill a whole forest but will be worth it when the DFL retakes the Senate with more people claiming to work across the aisle. Still haven’t received a mailing from the Anti-Christ with only Monday left.

  4. Submitted by David Mensing on 11/05/2012 - 04:46 am.


    Is he a moderate, or does he just talk like one to win voters’ favor? I live in his district and was polled by the GOP. I said that I thought I would vote for Schmit, but that Howe showed some “reasonableness”.

Leave a Reply