Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.


Medical marijuana stare-down: the issues that divide Dayton, House and Senate

REUTERS/Nick Adams
Medical marijuana patient Robert Badillo smoking vaporized marijuana inside Frankie Sports Bar and Grill in Olympia, Washington.

Minnesota could become the first state to permit use of marijuana for medical purposes while not allowing patients to smoke it — setting it apart from the District of Columbia and 21 other states that have already legalized medical marijuana. A compromise at the Legislature this year, however, still hinges on whether some groups consider the final deal restrictive enough.

Among the sticking points: 

  • Whether patients have access to up to 2.5 ounces of marijuana leaves to vaporize
  • Whether Minnesota — the 12th-biggest state by square miles — should have three, or 24, or 55 dispensaries
  • Whether 5,000 or 35,000 Minnesotans should be covered

Gov. Mark Dayton and House and Senate lawmakers are trying to strike a deal on medical marijuana with just six days to go before the May 19 adjournment deadline. The medical marijuana bill has appeared all-but-dead at several points this session, with Dayton reluctant to sign a proposal that law enforcement officials opposed.

A last-minute observational study compromise struck between cops and legislators in the House has won the governor’s approval, but senators — who passed their version of the medical marijuana bill with a veto-proof 48-18 vote last week — prefer a more expansive law.

Minneapolis DFLer Scott Dibble, the Senate bill author, said some of the House proposal’s restrictions make it “inadequate and unworkable” for senators.

The upper chamber opted on Tuesday to head into a conference committee this week to strike a deal with the clock ticking on the legislative session.

For now, all three parties say they are willing to make compromises to get something passed before adjournment. “I hope they work out a bill that we can all support,” Gov. Mark Dayton, who raised the profile of the issue this session with his initial opposition, said Monday.

“We want to do anything we can to [alleviate] the pain and suffering of children and adults who suffer from diseases and afflictions that might be helped by medical marijuana, but we want to do it in a way that’s not going to open it up to even more people for greater harm.”

Vaporizing leaves, or just liquids?

The House and the Senate medical marijuana bills allow the state Department of Health to administer a medical marijuana program that does forbids patients from smoking the plant.

While neither bill allows smoking, the Senate proposal allows approved patients to obtain 2.5 ounces of plant-form marijuana at any one time. Patients could then ingest the marijuana in various forms under the Senate bill, including crushing and heating the leaf form to just short of combustion.

Sen. Scott Dibble
Sen. Scott Dibble

For Dibble, having access to the whole plant is only way patients can get the therapeutic effects that medical marijuana can offer. The House bill, authored by Rep. Carly Melin, DFL-Hibbing, allows approved patients to use medical marijuana in an oil or pill form. They can also vaporize a liquid form of medical marijuana under the supervision of a practitioner.

In an expansive letter to the House and the governor sent Sunday, Dibble said digestive absorption is slow and uneven with pill and other forms of medical marijuana, which “does not allow patients to receive immediate benefit” or “very precisely limit their own dosage to alleviate symptoms.”

Using the plant form also opens up the number of people who can receive treatment, Dibble said.

The House medical marijuana bill allows coverage for a list of eight illnesses, including seizure disorders, cancer, glaucoma, multiple sclerosis and other disorders that cause severe muscle spasms, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, HIV and AIDS. An estimated 5,000 Minnesotans fall under those categories for treatment, but the Senate bill would cover roughly 35,000 Minnesotans. Dibble’s bill includes illnesses like intractable pain, which he says should be included because there’s no other known treatment for the disease.

Even so, Dayton prefers the House bill — which also passed last week with a wide 86-39 margin — noting that it’s hard for him to imagine a scenario where people walk away with several ounces of plant-form marijuana and not abuse the system.

“It’s to me impossible to believe someone is going to buy 2.5 ounces of marijuana and not smoke it or not sell it to someone else who will,” Dayton said. “It just defies common sense in my judgment.” 

Big state, few dispensaries?

The House version allows for only one in-state medical marijuana manufacturer run by the Department of Health, plus three satellite distribution centers. Dayton prefers that proposal to the Senate version, which allows for 55 dispensaries around the state.

Dibble says he’s willing to drop that to 24 dispensaries, or three per congressional district, but he’s worried too few facilities would make access difficult for people in the rural, far-flung regions of the state. “Minnesota is a big state. It takes 7.5 hours to drive from International Falls to Worthington. Asking an ill person to drive several hours to get what they need … will put relief out of reach for many,” Dibble wrote. 

Each state with legal medical marijuana treats distribution centers differently, said Karmen Hanson, a program manager with the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL). Some calculate the number of dispensaries by population density or by county, while some allow for homegrown options if patients are too far from a dispensary. 

Rep. Carly Melin

Rhode Island allows for six dispensaries, despite being one-seventieth of the size of Minnesota.

“Looking at ratio of population-to-dispensary, the one with three satellite locations would seem low compared to other programs out there,” Hanson said. “That’s purely by the numbers. Each state is unique in how it handles its program based on the need.”

Dibble also says putting the state’s medical marijuana in one place could risk the entire treatment program if there’s, say, a fire or bad crop.

Still, Dayton said he’s still concerned it would be too difficult to police problems under the Senate bill with so many facilities, not to mention the security and credentials of dispensary workers. The House proposal — a study — gives the Department of Health and its commissioner more direct control in determining patient dosages.

“There’s no doctors involved,” Dayton said. “There’s nobody … assessing what is the proper dosage, what is too much to get behind the wheel of a car.” 

Compromise possibilities

But there are things Dayton says he likes about the Senate bill.

For instance, The Senate version makes it a felony for any patient caught diverting his or her own supply of medical marijuana. The House proposal doesn’t include specific penalties.

The Senate proposal also lays out specific security measures at laboratories and other facilities, but the House proposal does not, Dibble said.

“I am convinced a middle ground exists,” Dibble concluded his letter. “We can sensibly provide relief to thousands of Minnesotans while ensuring cannabis only reaches those who need it for medical purposes.”

Comments (11)

  1. Submitted by Jon Lord on 05/13/2014 - 09:57 am.

    sounds like

    we’ll probably pass a medical marijuana bill that, among other things, will still outlaw the possession and use of marijuana in any form.

  2. Submitted by Leslie Davis on 05/13/2014 - 11:36 am.

    Cannabis – marijuana

    Cannabis (marijuana) is a wonderful plant that, when legalized, will be great for Minnesota’s economic development and agricultural diversity.
    Cannabis means jobs in hundreds of industries for thousands of people in many localities.
    The fact that some people use Cannabis for health or pleasure purposes should not only not deter us from supporting legalization, but should encourage everyone to get on-board the legalization train.
    We shouldn’t let a handful of exaggerated horror stories about Cannabis use force us to wear blinders to the truth.
    The Drug War is bad for America and should end.
    Leslie Davis
    Candidate for Governor 2014

    • Submitted by Richard O'Neil on 05/13/2014 - 04:53 pm.

      “The Drug War is bad for America and should end.”

      I disagree. The sale and use of illegal drugs including marijuana is “bad” for America, especially for teens and young adults.

  3. Submitted by Beth-Ann Bloom on 05/13/2014 - 12:19 pm.

    Talented legislators

    Minnesota is fortunate to have talented, hard-working legislators like Senator Dibble and Representative Melin. They have been able to craft bills where earlier in the year nobody saw any hope for passage. Wishing them the best as they work to meld the strongly vetted provisions of the Senate bill with the governor’s embrace of the House bill. They and their colleagues should be applauded for trying to meet the medical needs of a specific population of children and adults in an environment where everyone in the state has an opinion but the bill will only become law if the governor signs it.

  4. Submitted by Eric Jaffa on 05/13/2014 - 12:52 pm.

    car safety

    RE: “what is too much to get behind the wheel of a car.”

    Swallowing pot causes some people to hallucinate. Smoking-and-vaping pot doesn’t cause people to hallucinate.

    If Governor Dayton cares about car safety, then he should prefer that patients smoke-and-vape pot rather than swallowing pot pills.

  5. Submitted by Dennis Tester on 05/13/2014 - 01:22 pm.

    In Minnesota

    apparently you can never have too many intoxicants. It’s a cultural thing. Hey, we’re not the rehab capital of the world for nuthin’.

    • Submitted by Kurt Nelson on 05/13/2014 - 01:37 pm.

      Read the headline again

      in the 22 states where medical marijuana is legal, many of those patients are best served by very low THC content weed (that’s what gets you high). Nothing intoxicating about that.

      The arms race for higher and higher THC levels is in COlorado, and soon Washington, is for recreational use, but for those seeking palliative care, low THC is best. They don’t want to get baked, they want relief from the nausea of chemo, or to reduce the tremors of Parkinsons – don’t confuse the two, it weakens your argument..

    • Submitted by Eric Jaffa on 05/13/2014 - 03:42 pm.

      pot safer than opiate-pills

      Many people who need rehab became drug-dependent after a doctor prescribed them opiate-pills for pain relief.

      If they could have gotten pain relief from pot and had smoked pot instead, they’d have been better off, since pot isn’t physically addictive.

  6. Submitted by jason myron on 05/13/2014 - 04:37 pm.

    After sitting through

    the list of possible side effects from FDA approved drugs, that are marketed direct to consumer during any televised sporting event on a Sunday afternoon, it makes the fear mongers bellowing about the dangers of marijuana look even more foolish. We’re supposed to be a progressive state, not some throwback that looks at marijuana in the same lens as an old episode of Dragnet.

  7. Submitted by Michael Johnson on 05/14/2014 - 03:41 am.

    It’s like Minnesota has to pretend…

    it is better at everything and thus knows better about what can and should not be done about pot. But everyone says it is so and so, and therefore that is what every Minnesotan is going to think, or so say the politicians. They are just the middleman in this crime of indifference. Because everyone knows pot is harmless compared to alcohol, and even, dare I say, cigarettes. In a world where possession of marijuana can land you in prison, why isn’t it the same for these so-called legal substances, and with that I also include all “legal” pharmaceutical drugs that are abused and highly addictive as well as dangerous. If pot is illegal then so should be cigarettes. Tobacco is fine. It’s all the additives that make it bad. But marijuana by itself is a godsend. When are people going to give up the hysteria?

Leave a Reply