Forum gives St. Paul mayors, past and present, chance to reflect on city’s identity

Photo by Jeff Achen courtesy of Minnesota Philanthropy Partners
Panelists from left to right: Larry Cohen, George Latimer, Jim Scheibel, Norm Coleman, current mayor Chris Coleman and moderator Gary Eichten.

Toward the end of Thursday’s Saint Paul Foundation breakfast, former St. Paul Mayor Larry Cohen had a question for the four other men present who have also been elected to the office: How many of them were from New York?

George Latimer and Norm Coleman raised their hands to the laughter of those in attendance. When the others — Jim Scheibel and current Mayor Chris Coleman — responded to Cohen’s question that they, like Cohen himself, were from St. Paul, Cohen responded:  “Nary a Minneapolitan in the group,” to loud applause.

Better, it seems, to be from New York than Minneapolis if you want a political career in St. Paul. But while the breakfast featuring five of the six living mayors proved that St. Paul is not Minneapolis, it confirmed that it is very much Minnesota. When asked to name their biggest accomplishment while in office, the men mostly rebuffed the opportunity to brag; all of them, in fact, said that whatever they’d accomplished was based on the legacy crafted by those who came before them — and because of the residents of the city.

Latimer, who is credited with the push to restore Lowertown St. Paul, said it was really the dream of Norman Mears, who advocated for the revitalization and for whom the park is now named. “We stand on the shoulders of those who came before us,” he said. “I don’t think of it in terms of ‘this is what we did’ but rather ‘this is what we did together over a long period.’” 

Several spoke to what makes St. Paul unique. Latimer praised what he termed the city’s “wonderful parochialism” created by residents’ “love of place.” Norm Coleman called it a “big, small town.”

The five represent more than 40 years in office. Cohen was mayor from 1972 to 1976; Latimer from 1976 to 1990; Scheibel from 1990 to 1994; Norm Coleman from 1994 to 2002 and Chris Coleman from 2006 to the present. Randy Kelly, who declined an invitation to attend, was mayor between the two Colemans.

The breakfast was part of the Saint Paul Foundation’s 75th anniversary, and most of the questions posed by former MPR journalist Gary Eichten focused on the relationship between the mayors and the city’s philanthropic community. Chris Coleman said what makes St. Paul unique isn’t just the number and size of its foundations, but the fact that they frequently collaborate with each other without a care for who gets credit.

“There are a lot of communities that have wealthy foundations, there are a lot of communities that have people who are pushing them, but I’ve never seen one like this community that has that across-the-table collaboration between all of the partners in this community,” Chris Coleman said.

Latimer said foundations are willing to take risks that others might not. The city’s central square Rice Park is what it is today because wealthy people decided the city needed a grand orchestra hall and some others thought the St. Paul Hotel, where the breakfast was held, needed to be saved. “Rich people, at least in Minnesota, like to be anonymous — at least until they get a building named after them,” Latimer said.

But Scheibel said “you need to give more. I am concerned. When you look at the many needs we have in a changing community — and we’re part of that — we do need to be a little more bullish.”

Five St. Paul mayors
Photo by Jeff Achen courtesy of Minnesota Philanthropy Partners
Clockwise from lower left: Larry Cohen, Norm Coleman, Jim Scheibel, Mayor Chris Coleman and George Latimer.

Norm Coleman, the two-term mayor who changed parties from DFL to Republican during his two terms, said the reason the city is blessed with a large philanthropic community is because people were able to make fortunes in St. Paul.

“If we have a robust private sector, if we’re generating wealth in this community, then you’re gonna have philanthropy,” the former U.S. senator said. “It’s the responsibility of government, actually, to do those things that create an environment where people want to grow jobs.”

There was much joking among the five politicians who served in what Chris Coleman called the best job any of them have ever had. Latimer made reference to the city’s proclivity to elect Irish-Americans — since the Great Depression, 13 of the 16 mayors were Irish or Catholic or both. Cohen and Norm Coleman, however, are Jewish.

“He got elected with the name Cohen,” said Latimer while pronouncing it “Cohan.” “People in the city thought he was Irish. It never could have happened otherwise.” Later, Norm Coleman said: “Unlike Mayor Cohen, I never denied my Irish heritage.”

And Scheibel found something that united the five. “If you look back at all of our state of the city speeches, we all said the city was in good shape. So we have that in common.”

You can also learn about all our free newsletter options.

Comments (3)

  1. Submitted by Hiram Foster on 05/08/2015 - 09:30 am.

    Randy Kelly

    I wonder why Randy Kelly refused an invitation.

    For me, one of the great minor mysteries of Minnesota politics is the question of why Randy Kelly, the DFL mayor of a heavily DFL city, endorsed quite possibly the worst president in American history who also happened to be a Republican. Why would a politician purposely destroy his own political career?

  2. Submitted by Hiram Foster on 05/08/2015 - 01:23 pm.

    Principles

    But then why was he a member of the DFL? Where were his principles when he ran for office?

Leave a Reply