Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.


In this corner (of Minnesota): a wild, crowded and unpredictable campaign for the state House

Copyright Minnesota House of Representatives
Rep. David Dill conferring with Rep. Jeanne Poppe during the final days of the 2015 legislative session.

Things you’ll need if you’re running for Minnesota House District 3A: A detailed map, a car with good gas mileage (a small aircraft might be even better), a robust cell phone plan and a lot of good friends across the community who will vouch for you. 

Less important, apparently, is what political party you side with. 

The seat representing the northeastern-most district in the state House, the largest in Minnesota — it’s roughly the size of Maryland — is on the ballot this year after former DFL Rep. David Dill died unexpectedly this summer of cancer. A December special election has attracted six candidates of all political stripes. Among them: a former Republican candidate in the district who is now running as a Democrat; a former Democratic mayor who is running as a Republican; and don’t forget the lobbyist who is running as a true independent — as in: not aligned with Independence Party. 

Party loyalties are a nebulous concept in a place like 3A, a wild and sparsely populated district that includes the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness, a national forest and the shores of Lake Superior. More important is where the candidates stand on issues important to the sprawling district: Hunting and fishing, bonding projects for its many parks and trails, money for broadband service and a proposed copper-nickel mining project that could bring jobs to the area  — but that would also sit near pristine wilderness areas that draw tourists from across the country.

“This district has a history of electing moderates or contrarians to their party,” said northern Minnesota political blogger Aaron Brown. “That might be unusual in other parts of the state, but that’s not unusual here.”

Four Democrats on primary ballot

The special general election is set for Dec. 8, but up first is the Sept. 29 primary election. That’s creeping up quickly for the four DFL candidates vying for a spot on the general ballot to replace Dill.

Heidi Omerza
Heidi Omerza

There’s a healthy mix of personalities from different parts of the district. Heidi Omerza is a former teacher and current city council member in Ely; Rob Ecklund is a Koochiching County Commissioner and former union president; Eric Johnson is a businessman and outdoors outfitter from International Falls who previously challenged Dill as a Republican; Bill Hansen has been a DFL activist basically since infancy and was recently named Tofte Citizen of the Year.

Few would argue that, in terms of political parties, voters in the district have a tendency to favor DFLers. Dill was a Democrat who served for more than 10 years, and the district has overwhelmingly favored statewide candidates like DFL Gov. Mark Dayton, DFL U.S. Sen. Al Franken and Democratic President Barack Obama. But in 2012, a majority of voters in the socially conservative district supported a constitutional amendment that would have banned gay marriage. Even Dill was initially labeled as a Republican before he ran for the Legislature, and during more than a decade in St. Paul, he often bucked his party on social and environmental issues. He also closely aligned himself with Republicans on gun regulations, and easily won re-election in the district.

Rob Ecklund
Rob Ecklund

All the DFL candidates in the race promise to espouse the same independent style that Dill displayed in the Legislature, but none as strongly as his former Republican opponent, Johnson. “[Dill] truly was a bipartisan legislator,” said Johnson, who owns an outfitting shop in International Falls and lost to Dill by 30 points in the 2014 election. “He really knew how to work with his colleagues down in St. Paul to pass legislation that really benefited a lot of northern Minnesota and rural Minnesotans.”

“I’ve never really been a party guy one way or another,” he added. “I just want to serve and give back to the area. Showing that I’m willing to run under either party shows that I am going to carry on that legacy.”

Ecklund, on the other hand, has the most traditional background of a Democratic candidate from northeastern Minnesota. He’s been a on the Koochiching County board for the last four years and works at the Boise Paper plant in International Falls, one of the larger population centers in the district. He is also a member and past president of the United Steelworkers Union Local 159 (not surprisingly, they are backing his campaign).

Eric Johnson
Eric Johnson

“I think my union background will play well,” Ecklund said. “You get down into the certain parts of the district and labor is still a large amount of population.”

Omerza hails from Ely, one of the other population centers in the district. She’s serving her third term on the city council there and serves on the board of the Coalition of Greater Minnesota Cities. In that role she railed on the House Republican majority after the legislative session ended, criticizing them for abandoning campaign promises to focus on rural Minnesota needs in 2015.

“I’ve seen how the tourism, the technology, the taconite and timber all play into our way of life day in and day out,” Omerza said. “I know it and I live it.” 

Hansen is the only candidate to stand apart from Dill in a major way — he doesn’t support the proposed copper-nickel mining projects in the area. There’s no mining in the district yet, but two companies want to open the state’s first-ever sulfide mines in the area. One project, proposed by PolyMet Mining, would be located in Hoyt Lakes just outside the district, the other, Twin Metals, would be situated near Ely, just a few miles from the edge of the boundary waters.

Bill Hansen
Bill Hansen

There are strong feelings in the district both for and against the project. Hansen is quick to note that he supports the state’s current iron-mining industry, but he says in general mining is not a sustainable industry. He says it’s not a worthwhile strategy to bring short-term jobs to the district while risking possible toxin leaks into nearby waters. 

“I’m getting a good response everywhere I go,” Hansen said. “I feel like the mining issue especially is starting to turn statewide.”

Hansen, who runs a canoe outfitting business in Tofte, is something of a darling among DFL activists, and was favored to win the party’s endorsement (he challenged Dill for the endorsement twice before and won before losing in the primary). But candidates were told this week there would be no endorsing contest in the race. That means all four candidates will head to the primary election.

Brown, who blogs at Minnesota Brown and has been active in DFL politics for more than a decade, said there’s fear among some pro-mining interests that Hansen would win the endorsement and then the primary election. Without the party’s backing on the ballot, the primary is more of an open game. “It feels to me there is an air of panic among some that the next representative could be a guy that does not openly support mining,” Brown added.

“Bill Hansen is outraged at this circumvention of the DFL party process,” Hansen’s campaign manager, Nancy Powers, wrote in an email. “In this strongly DFL district, the primary election often determines who wins the seat in the general election. The endorsing convention helps the electorate understand who, among the candidates running as Democrats in the primary, truly represents DFL priorities.” Paul Fish, who chairs the Senate District 3 Democrats, could not be reached for comment.

Minnesota House District 3A
Minnesota House District 3A

A complicated general election

Whoever survives the primary will have to face off in a Dec. 8 general election against Roger Skraba, the former mayor of Ely, and Kelsey Johnson, a lobbyist and resident in the district.

Roger Skraba
Cravaack for Congress
Roger Skraba

Skraba, who could not be reached for comment, is perhaps the most inscrutable candidate of the bunch. Despite recently serving as a Democratic mayor, he has run for the House seat in the past as an Independence Party candidate. This time he registered as a Republican. He has supported both Republican and Democratic candidates in the past. 

Skraba is a Quetico Provincial Park guide and is both popular and well-known in and around Ely. He’s an outspoken supporter of copper-nickel mining and once pled guilty to breaking rules and riding a snowmobile through the Boundary Waters (an act of defiance that probably only made him more popular with some voters).

Johnson’s candidacy also throws a wrench in everyone’s political calculations. She had to collect more than 500 valid signatures in just four days to run as an independent candidate, an impressive number, Brown notes. She’s a well-connected lobbyist in St. Paul and has campaigned for candidates in both parties.

She said her experience lobbying in St. Paul will make her an effective legislator for the area, and notes the next session is shorter than usual, with a focus on a bonding bill. Johnson said she would push to bring major capital investment dollars back to the district for local projects.

Kelsey Johnson
Kelsey Johnson

“I’ve been getting so frustrated lately with so much emphasis on party politics. I’ve seen people strong-arm members to get them to vote for things that are not favorable to their districts,” Johnson said. “I want to make sure the community is represented and I’m running as an independent so I’m sure that I’m not serving any party affiliations over my district.” 

The realities of running a general election campaign in the massive House District 3A are painfully obvious to Johnson, who will have no help from either of the major parties in her general election campaign. She has been crisscrossing the district in her car for weeks to hit community centers, events and whatever she can before December. 

“I’ve helped with campaigns across the metro area and it’s a much different game. You can easily hit a number of doors there, but here, it’s so sparse. It has to be very deliberate,” she said. “If you have someone who will stand behind you in these communities that always helps. In these communities, it’s more about supporting the people we know and trust. That’s the way we are up here. We like the the people we know.” 

Comments (7)

  1. Submitted by Terry Nagle on 09/10/2015 - 12:12 pm.

    NE Minn. District House Election

    Balanced, thoughtful, articulate and principled are great, yet rare qualities in political candidates. Bill Hansen is the embodiment of each of these attributes. Although we no longer live in Cook County it’s hard to imagine there being a better representative for NE Minnesota.

  2. Submitted by Carol Orban on 09/10/2015 - 01:31 pm.

    3A endorsing convention cancelled

    Paul Fish, my DFL Senate District Chair, cancelling our endorsing convention is another example of a few Iron Range officials thinking they can run the party. How can they think they can go against our own party rules? Because they are used to getting their way, by any means necessary.

  3. Submitted by Alan Muller on 09/10/2015 - 01:50 pm.

    An interesting election for sure

    Dill, as chair of the House environment committee, did a lot of damage to the state. Using terms like “moderate” tends to obscure the role he played as a promoter of pollution and destruction of natural resources.

    I am sure a lot of people are rooting for Bill Hansen.

  4. Submitted by Chris McGreevy on 09/10/2015 - 03:31 pm.

    Disappointing to see Fish and Bakk cancel the endorsing convention. Bill Hansen would be a great representative and they are clearly worried. You have to wonder what phone calls went out from Polymet and Twin Metals HQs.

  5. Submitted by Patti Taylor on 09/11/2015 - 06:06 pm.

    03A endorsing convention

    The untimely passing of our 03A Rep. David Dill has saddended many of us in his District. Many of us understand why there is not going to be an endorsing convention, just think of the logistics. Each of our county units would have to have their own delegate convention. Many of our county unit members live up to 100 miles from a probable meeting place. We have several county unit directors who don’t get to meetings just for that reason. Just take a look at the map. Our District is HUGE! We had very little time between the filing deadline & the primary, barely time to get ballots available for people to file absentee and many other reasons. I trust Ms Bierschbach was speaking of non-ferrous mining when she stated ” There is no mining in the District yet”.

    • Submitted by Bill Willy on 09/12/2015 - 01:29 am.

      Just think of the logistics

      No offense intended Patti, but from what I can gather, the last time this kind of thing came up (in about 2011?), Tony Serditch had just “retired from” his legislative seat (whatever exactly it was) to become the Head of the Iron Range Resources and Rehabilitaion Board (the IRRRB), and a near-replica situation existed. But SOMEhow, way back then, “the party” and the far flung but hard working people (the “party organizers” and the county employee folks that, if need be, are ready, willing and able to get voting materials and systems ready to go) you (almost, but don’t quite) mention were somehow able to slap together a “convention” at which the “DFL endorsement” went to Carly Melin who, thank goodness — she’s been an aMAZing rookie legislature up until this Polymet/”Range Delegation/IRRRB Thing” vote on getting rid of the Citizens’ Board and the environmentally-friendly-or-not free pass for the mining industry she helped pass into law last sessions — won the election.

      I’m not sure if you were involved in that last DFL nominating process or covention, but if you were, my (hopefully non-offensive) question is, what happened to your (and your 3A neighbor’s) “Can Do!” spirit and doing all you can to help satisfy the Truely Democratic American’s Hunger and Thirst for the Best Possible Candidate Winning?

  6. Submitted by Bill Willy on 09/13/2015 - 07:12 pm.

    The question to ask the candidates

    I don’t live in or have a say in the 3A election process, but if I did, the thing I’d want to know from every candidate running is where they stand on the copper-nickel mining issue. It is, by far, the most important issue facing the state at this point in time, District 3A and all points south.

    According to the article, only two of the candidates made themselves clear on it: Roger Skraba is all for it; Bill Hansen doesn’t think it’s a good idea.

    “I’m getting a good response everywhere I go,” Hansen said. “I feel like the mining issue especially is starting to turn statewide.”

    That was interesting to read. Interesting from the point of view that Mr. Hansen seems to be hearing from Northeastern MN people firsthand what the results of an April poll had to say about that, as reported by the Duluth News Tribune:

    “”61 percent of Northeastern Minnesota respondents opposed sulfide copper mining near the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness with just 25 percent support.

    “In other poll questions, a majority said they suspect problems would occur, that mining companies would take shortcuts to save money and that copper mining companies couldn’t be trusted to protect against problems.”

    And, along those same lines, there was a pretty good article on the StarTribune web site on September 2nd with the headline that reads:

    “PolyMet mine water could flow northward, toward BWCA”

    As interesting as the article is, what was even more interesting to me was the (200+) reader comments. I say that because the majority of this particular batch of comments seemed to reflect the broadest opposition to the project I’ve seen so far… Broad in the sense that there appear to be a broad cross section (politically, or ideologically) of people that are strongly and articulately opposed.

    When I’ve read mining related articles and comments there over the past year or so it’s seemed a lot more contentious and two-sided, with the standard “lefty, greenie, pinko, anti-mining, fear-mongering activists” type commenters going back and forth with those having a hard time believing anyone would be dumb enough to be in favor of letting the “carpetbagging, always lying, forever ruining, profiting and disappearing goon profiteers from the global mining industry pull and buy the wool over your eyes with Big Rock Candy Mountain promises of jobs that will never materialize,” etc..

    And while there’s plenty of that, to be sure, where it has seemed closer to a 50/50 or 60/40 split in the past, the comments on this one leaned way more toward the “Not a good idea at all” side.

    I mention those things because of what Bill Hansen had to say, and because I think he may be onto something real that others in the race MAY want to pay attention to when it comes to supporting what it is the majority of your (potential) constituents may be in favor of, regardless of what other NE MN politicians, office holders/IRRRB members and, of course, the people at Polymet are saying or trying to do.

    If you live in district 3A you might want to take a look at those articles and comments and see what YOU think and maybe find out where the candidates stand on the issue… It COULD be important to you and your family’s and neighbor’s future.

Leave a Reply