Turns out, killing off CTIB kinda screwed over the city of Minneapolis

MinnPost photo by Corey Anderson
The city of Minneapolis will collect between $1.6 million and $1.8 million less each year in lodging taxes as a result of CTIB’s dissolution.

Remember that dissolution of the regional transit funding board known as CTIB, the Counties Transit Improvement Board?

Getting rid of it was considered something of a win-win, at least for regional transit. It would double the money available for mass transit projects in Hennepin and Ramsey counties. And it would allow the three other counties that had made up CTIB — Dakota, Washington and Anoka — to keep paying the same tax rate but keep the money locally for future rail and bus rapid transit projects rather than share it regionally. 

As it turns out, though, there was a loser (beyond, of course, those who might not support additional mass transit lines but will still pay higher taxes). The city of Minneapolis will collect between $1.6 million and $1.8 million less each year in lodging taxes as a result of CTIB’s dissolution.

“The net result is not that the county receives more money from our sales tax but that hotels are being subject to a lower overall tax,” Mark Ruff, the city’s chief financial officer, told the Minneapolis City Council’s Ways and Means Committee Tuesday.

Here’s what happened, according to Ruff. The quarter-cent sales tax that the five counties in CTIB were allowed to impose and spend collectively on projects such as the Green Line was exempt from a long-ago cap on the amount of hotel taxes that could be collected in Minneapolis. So even though the lodging tax — which is an accumulation of various state, local and special assessments on hotel charges — was higher than the state-imposed cap of 13 percent, the old transit tax didn’t count against it.

But with CTIB’s dissolution, the new tax that Hennepin and Ramsey counties opted into was not exempt from the lodging tax cap. And when that new tax kicked in, on Oct. 1, the cap was reached and crossed, and Minneapolis had to reduce the size of its lodging tax to make it all fit.

So that’s what it did. The city reduced its lodging tax from 2.625 percent to 2.125 percent — a rate that was in place during the Super Bowl.

The cap, which dates to 1986 as part of the convention center funding authorization, only applies to Minneapolis. St. Paul, Rochester, Duluth and Bloomington all have cumulative lodging taxes that exceed 13 percent.

All totaled, Minneapolis collects more than $80 million in various sales taxes; there’s a local sales tax, a downtown liquor tax, a downtown restaurant tax and an entertainment tax in addition to the lodging tax, which accounts for about $8 million.

Ruff said the city made CTIB leaders aware of the impact before the dissolution, but was told the process was too far down the road to respond.

Last October, former Minneapolis City Council President Barbara Johnson wrote her counterpart on the Hennepin County Commission, Jan Callison, asking for help getting a solution at the Legislature.

Ruff described it as a “technical fix.”

But other political battles are likely to reappear along with any request at the Legislature coming from the city of Minneapolis. The first problem is the general lack of fondness that legislative Republicans have for the state’s largest city. The second is the issues Republican transportation leaders have with light rail in general and the dissolution of CTIB specifically. Last spring, attempts by the GOP to intervene in and even block the dissolution were thwarted by Democratic Gov. Mark Dayton.

You can also learn about all our free newsletter options.

Comments (2)

  1. Submitted by Henk Tobias on 02/09/2018 - 02:03 pm.

    So those of us in the Minneapolis

    the economic engine of the entire state, once again get screwed. Supporting the seasonal lifestyles of the folks in out state Minnesota isn’t enough, we have to subsidize folks who could afford to spend 10 grand on super bowl tickets as well. Ridiculous.

  2. Submitted by Richard Adair on 02/11/2018 - 01:55 pm.

    Actually a good deal for Minneapolis

    So, if I understand this correctly, the city of Minneapolis collects about 1.7 million less in lodging tax yearly, out of about $80 million in sales tax revenue.

    In exchange, Hennepin and Ramsey Counties spend more money than they did under CTIB to provide Minneapolis with bus and light rail service that brings people downtown every day to work and shop, and to reinforce its status as the vibrant center of our metro area. And Minneapolis residents can get a quick ride to good-paying jobs in the suburbs and St. Paul. Sounds like a good deal to me.

    Cities that don’t invest in transit hollow out and die. Trust me, I’ve lived in one.

Leave a Reply