UCare generously supports MinnPost’s Second Opinion coverage; learn why.

Mood and food: A look at diet choice and psychological well-being

The good news: Despite how challenging, annoying and frustrating (hey, we’ve all been there) a weight-loss diet can seem at the beginning, if you stick with it, you’re likely to feel happier within a few weeks.

The bad news: If you’ve chosen a low-carb weight-loss plan (like the Atkins diet), that improved mood may fade away. After a year, you’re likely to feel the same as before you began to shed pounds.

Your mood won’t be any worse, but it won’t be any better, either.

That’s the central finding from an Australian study published this week in the Archives of Internal Medicine. The researchers enlisted 106 overweight and obese volunteers, who were randomized to either a low-carb, high-fat diet (like Atkins) or a high-carb, low-fat diet (like the “Mediterranean” diet).

At the end of a year, both groups had lost about the same amount of weight (on average, about 30 pounds each), and both also scored about the same on tests that measured their short-term memory and speed-of-processing thinking skills. (The memory skills, by the way, improved for both groups.)

But, the people on the low-fat diet were more likely to enjoy a sustained boost in mood. Specifically, at the end of the year they scored better on tests that measured anger-hostility, confusion-bewilderment and depression-dejection.

Harder to follow?
Why would a low-fat diet be better at enhancing mood over the long run?

The researchers aren’t sure, but they speculate that it might be tougher to adopt a low-carb diet in our Western culture, which tends to favor carbohydrates like bread, pasta, rice and fruit. Or low-carb diets may just be harder for individuals to follow. Both factors could dampen a low-carb adherent’s mood.

Or, it may be that low-carb diets produce less serotonin, the brain chemical associated with feelings of happiness and well-being.

It’s important to note, however, that the mood states of both groups fell well within the normal range for healthy adults throughout the study. So we’re not talking about any major emotional problems here.

Nor is this study the final word on this topic.

Still, it would be nice to feel somewhat happier after losing 30 pounds, wouldn’t it?

You can also learn about all our free newsletter options.

Comments (3)

  1. Submitted by David Dempsey on 11/12/2009 - 09:34 am.

    Thanks for an interesting post. Besides the serotonin possibility, are there any other chemical explanations for the potential association of mood and these diets? Is there a scientific literature on the link generally?

  2. Submitted by Susan Perry on 11/12/2009 - 01:07 pm.

    David:

    The study itself, of course, cites some other, previous research, some of it conflicting. You also could go to Pubmed and type in “diet” and “mood” or similar tags and see what else comes up.

    Unfortunately, there’s a lot of unscientific nonsense floating around on the Internet about food and mood. Hucksters are everywhere.

    Susan

  3. Submitted by Bernice Vetsch on 11/12/2009 - 04:33 pm.

    Doctor Atkins once wrote that no-one should be on his high protein/high saturated fat diet for more than a couple of weeks because they’d be missing some essential nutriments.

    This may be a personal idiosyncracy, but my mood remains generally good by eating a diet without red meat but with lots of fruits and veggies, good breads, good fats and ….. chocolate.

Leave a Reply