Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.


UCare generously supports MinnPost’s Second Opinion coverage; learn why.

Andrew Wakefield, Dr. Oz, others given ‘awards’ for promoting medical nonsense

Andrew Wakefield, Dr. Oz, others given 'awards' for promoting medical nonsense
REUTERS/David Gray

Each April Fool’s Day, the James Randi Educational Foundation (an organization dedicated to exposing pseudoscientific claims) “honors” what it calls “the five worst offenders who are intentionally or unintentionally pulling the wool over the public’s eyes.”

Winners receive a Pigasus Award, named for both the Greek mythical flying horse Pegasus and for the popular cliché (and, apparently, centuries-old Scottish proverb) that states that such-and-such will be true “when pigs fly” (meaning, of course, never).

This year’s Pigasus honorees were announced last Friday, and three are in the health field. Regular Second Opinion readers will be familiar with one name: Andrew Wakefield, the discredited British researcher (and former doctor — he lost his medical license last year) who continues to stir up scientifically unfounded fears about childhood vaccines, including here in Minnesota.

Wakefield was given the “Refusal to Face Reality Award” by the Randi Foundation.

Another familiar name — cardiac surgeon and Oprah protégé Dr. Mehmet Oz — received, for the second year in a row, the “Media Pigasus Award.” Oz was chosen for his promotion on his syndicated TV show of such medical nonsense as faith healing, Ayruvedic tongue diagnosing, and so-called energy medicine.

“This year, he really went off the deep end,” the Randi Foundation notes in its press release about the awards. “In March 2011, Dr. Oz endorsed ‘psychic’ huckster and past Pigasus winner John Edward, who pretends to talk to dead people. Oz even suggested that bereaved families should visit psychic mediums to receive (faked) messages from their dead relatives as a form of grief counseling.”

Oz had also promoted homeopathy on his show, and proudly proclaims that his wife gives the scientifically debunked medicines to their children. Homeopathy features in a third Pigasus award this year. The Randi Foundation bestowed the “Funder Pigasus Award” to CVS/pharmacy for its  “work to support the manufacturers of scam ‘homeopathic’ medications who sell up to $870 million a year in quack remedies to U.S. consumers.”

“CVS/pharmacy sells these quack products in thousands of stores across the U.S.,” states the foundation’s press release, “right alongside real medicine, with no warning to consumers. Instead of giving their customers the facts about homeopathy, CVS/pharmacy executives are cashing in themselves by offering their own store-brand of the popular homeopathic product oscillococcinum. Oscillococcinum is made by grinding up the liver of a duck, putting none of it onto tiny sugar pills — that’s right, none of it — and then advertising the plain sugar pills as an effective treatment for flu symptoms.”

This year’s other two Pigasus awards went to the following:

  • NASA engineer Richard Hoover, who claimed yet again (for the third time in 14 years) that he had found evidence of alien microscopic life in meteorites — a claim that NASA has distanced itself from and that has been disproven by other scientists.
  • Televangelist Peter Popoff, who, despite being shown in the 1980s to be fraudulently claiming he could heal the sick and receive information about people directly from God, is now offering “supernatural debt relief” — a business that is earning him and his family more than $1 million a year.

Will there ever come a time when the public is significantly scientifically literate to not fall for such nonsense?

Let’s hope so. But don’t expect to see winged porcine creatures any day soon.

Comments (2)

  1. Submitted by Nancy Hokkanen on 04/04/2011 - 03:39 pm.

    Pseudoskeptics posing as skeptics. What a tangled web.

    When trillions of dollars are at stake, corporations and government will say anything to protect themselves. All they need are media mouthpieces who are repeaters rather than reporters. But not all are susceptible to such pressure, believing that no child should be written off as collateral damage in the war on disease — and are worthy of study to prevent further injuries.

    Vaccine Court: Autism Debate Continues
    Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and David Kirby
    Posted February 24, 2009
    “…Special Master Richard Abell ruled that the Banks had successfully demonstrated that ‘the MMR vaccine at issue actually caused the conditions from which Bailey suffered and continues to suffer. …
    “In his conclusion, Special Master Abell ruled that Petitioners had proven that the MMR had directly caused a brain inflammation illness called acute disseminated encephalomyelitis (ADEM) which, in turn, had caused the autism spectrum disorder PDD-NOS in the child…
    “The Bailey decision is not an isolated ruling. We now know of at least two other successful ADEM cases argued in Vaccine Court.”

  2. Submitted by Dan Hintz on 04/04/2011 - 07:00 pm.

    Nancy, if people who are skeptical of a doctor who was stripped of his medical license for faking his data and abusing children are “pseudoskeptics” what exactly does that make someone who ignores all other evidence and believes in that doctor?

Leave a Reply