UCare generously supports MinnPost’s Second Opinion coverage; learn why.

Few health problems can be linked to vaccines, government report says

Many childhood diseases that vaccines had once almost eradicated in the United States have made comebacks in recent years as an increasing number of parents reject the vaccines for their children, mostly due to fears of autism.
Creative Commons/ZaldyImg
Many childhood diseases that vaccines had once almost eradicated in the United States have made comebacks in recent years as an increasing number of parents reject the vaccines for their children, mostly due to fears of autism.

An analysis by the Institute of Medicine (IOM) of more than 1,000 scientific articles has found that common vaccines cause few health problems.

Furthermore, most of the side effects that were found to be associated with the vaccines tended to be rare.

“We have a lot of evidence that vaccines save lives and avert a lot of suffering,” said Dr. Ellen Wright Clayton, chair of the 16-member IOM committee that wrote the report, in a phone-in press briefing on Thursday. “The side effects we’re talking about here are relatively rare because it’s hard to find them when you look at a general population. The majority of the ones we found are either short-term or readily treated.”

The vaccines analyzed by the IOM committee are common childhood ones used to prevent measles, mumps, rubella, chicken pox, pertussis, flu, polio, tetanus, diphtheria, meningitis, hepatitis and human papilloma virus, which can cause cancer.

The IOM committee found no evidence that the MMR (measles, mumps and rubella) vaccine causes autism. It also found no evidence of a link between either the MMR vaccine or the DTaP (tetanus) vaccine and diabetes type 1.

Nor did it find evidence that the flu vaccine causes Bell’s palsy or exacerbates asthma symptoms.

The committee did find convincing evidence of the following, however:

  • The MMR vaccine is linked to febrile seizures, a type of fever-associated seizure that occurs in infants and young children, typically within two weeks after vaccination. These seizures are usually benign and have no long-term consequences. They do not predispose a child to epilepsy.
  • The MMR vaccine is associated with an increased risk of a disease called measles inclusion body encephalitis in people with compromised immune systems. Such cases are rare.
  • Six vaccines — those used to prevent MMR, flu, chickenpox, hepatitis B, meningitis and tetanus — can cause anaphylaxis, an allergic reaction that occurs shortly after receiving the vaccination.
  • The varicella zoster (chickenpox) vaccine, which is a live vaccine, was linked to pneumonia, hepatitis, meningitis, brain inflammation, shingles and even chickenpox, although mostly in people with compromised immune systems.

An exhaustive review
The 647-page report is the most thorough review of vaccine-related scientific literature in almost 20 years. It was commissioned in 2009 by the Department of Health and Human Services to help it administer the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP), which provides compensation to people injured by vaccines.

Clayton, a professor of pediatrics at Vanderbilt University in Nashville, Tenn., said she hoped the report would also help to allay any fears that parents may have about vaccinating their children.

Although the report wasn’t specifically written for parents,  “we had parents in mind every single step of the way,” she said.

Won’t convince everyone
Dr. Gregory Poland, director of the Vaccine Research Group at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minn., welcomes the report, which he said contained no surprises. “It was a rigorous process, and I think it should be very reassuring to the public,” he said in a phone interview Thursday.

Still, he added, it’s unlikely that this report, as exhaustive as it is, will convince vaccine skeptics that the benefits of vaccines far outweigh the risks.

Indeed, the first question asked during Thursday’s press conference was whether Clayton and the other IOM committee members thought parents who believe their children’s autism was caused by a vaccine were “dishonest or stupid.”

It was asked by a media representative from the Age of Autism, an advocacy group that believes that the government and the medical community are ignoring or covering up the link between vaccines and autism.

(No, Clayton told the questioner, “I am not about to say that people are dishonest or stupid.”)

“The anti-vaccine people in particular will not understand or accept the methods used in this study,” said Poland. “So they will misinterpret the findings.

“They have formed a belief, and there are no data that will legitimately challenge that belief,” he added. “They would have accepted hands down, no questions asked, a report that substantiated their beliefs, but they are unwilling to accept a report that repudiates their beliefs.”

Deadly diseases are making a comeback
That unwillingness to accept the data has “directly and in a quantitative manner harmed children and has led to the deaths and disability of children,” Poland said.

Many childhood diseases that vaccines had once almost eradicated in the United States have made comebacks in recent years as an increasing number of parents reject the vaccines for their children, mostly due to fears of autism. Minnesota, for example, experienced a measles epidemic earlier this year that hospitalized several children.

Before the measles vaccine was developed, some 450 children died each year in the United States and another 1,000 suffered deafness or permanent brain damage from measles complications, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

“People forget what these diseases are like,” said Clayton during Thursday’s press conference. “When I was a resident, I had a child in the hospital with tetanus. You don’t want that to happen.”

“One of the things that needs to be said to put this in perspective is that a lot of the diseases that these particular vaccines prevent are really bad,” she added. “…Vaccines are a victim of their own success in this regard.”

You can read the full IOM report or a six-page summary at the institute’s website.

Comments (3)

  1. Submitted by Dan Hintz on 08/26/2011 - 12:16 pm.

    I don’t think the parents who believe are dishonest or stupid, but its more than just being unwilling to accept contrary information. You have to look at why they are willing to do so, and its because they are desperate for answers and have been victimized by con men like Andrew Wakefield and others actively pushing the fraudulent vaccine-autism link.

  2. Submitted by Wayne Rohde on 08/26/2011 - 10:52 pm.

    Dan Hintz. No con men like Wakefield. So says you. But your really do not know the whole story.

    The real con is being played on many people just like you. A very nice coordinated media effort this past week to promote a corrupt vaccine program.

    And the reporter of this story has an agenda as well.

    Here are some facts for you to think about and also for the writer to think about.

    The IOM report took two years to produce, mostly behind closed doors, and was paid for by the Department of Health and Human Services, the government agency which is also a defendant against the vaccine-injured in the government’s vaccine court.

    Due to a narrow set of objectives defined for the IOM by the government, the report only looked at a small set of published research studies linking just two vaccines to developmental disorders such as autism.

    Only four epidemiological studies were considered of sufficient quality to evaluate the MMR vaccine in relation to autism and no studies were deemed of sufficient quality for the DtaP vaccine and autism analysis.

    The committee did not attempt to evaluate six other vaccines for autism causation, the safety of the cumulative vaccine schedule and health outcomes like autism, or the safety of vaccine ingredients like mercury and aluminum in the context of chemical exposures from other sources like air pollution or consumer products.

  3. Submitted by Dan Hintz on 08/27/2011 - 03:17 pm.

    Not just so says me. So says facts and science and the truth.
    Wayne, the nonsense you are babbling would be funny if it wasnt so sad. Its sad because you think that pretending that autism is caused by vaccines does any good. At best every minute and every dollar spent pursuing that has been a waste of time, and actually has hurt the families of autistic kids.

Leave a Reply