Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.

Donate

UCare generously supports MinnPost’s Second Opinion coverage; learn why.

Another warning: Sitting is not good for your health

Sitting around all day is bad for our health.

Yet another study suggests that sitting around all day is bad for our health — whether or not we get up to do our obligatory half an hour or so of vigorous exercise.

This latest research, published Monday in the Archives of Internal Medicine, involved just under three years of data collected from 222,497 Australian adults aged 45 and up, who are part of a large, ongoing aging study. During those three years, 5,405 of the participants died.

After analyzing the data, researchers found an association between prolonged sitting and risk of early death from all causes. Specifically, they found that those participants who said at the start of the study that they sat for more than 11 hours daily were 40 percent more likely to have died during the next three years than those who said they sat for four hours or less daily.

People who reported sitting for eight to 11 hours daily had a 15 percent higher risk of dying than those who sat less than four hours a day.

And, yes, the results took into account the participants’ physical activity.

“Prolonged sitting is a risk factor for all-cause mortality, independent of physical activity,” the researchers concluded. They also found that the findings were consistent across all age groups and in both men and women — and even after adjusting for such factors as weight and pre-existing health conditions, including heart disease and diabetes.

“To put this in perspective,” wrote two Australian epidemiologists in a commentary that accompanied the study, “30 minutes of physical activity is as protective an exposure as 10 hours of sitting is a harmful one.”

Accumulating evidence

This study is just the latest in a slew of similar research that has pointed out an adverse association between early death and different types of prolonged sedentary behavior, including TV viewing, video-game playing, driving in a car, and working at a job that requires sitting.

Some of the research isn’t all that new. As the commentary authors point out, a 1966 study “reported that workers in occupations requiring much sitting (London bus drivers and mail sorters) had higher incidences of cardiovascular disease than did workers who were required to stand and ambulate (bus conductors and postal workers).”

Indeed, the Italian physician Bernardino Ramazzini noted something similar back in the 17th century.

Correlation, not causation

Still, the current study is not designed to prove cause and effect. As an observational study, it comes with all sorts of caveats. To begin with, the participants’ initial health and lifestyle data were collected through questionnaires, an unreliable source of information no matter how standardized they are. In addition, certain as-yet unidentified factors may be behind the study’s results. For example, the people who reported sitting for long periods of time may have had undiagnosed illnesses at the study’s start.

The authors of this study acknowledge these limitations, of course. In fact, they note that sedentary behavior research “is still in its infancy and that more high-quality prospective studies are needed.”

But they’re also calling for public health program to “focus not just on increasing population physical activity levels but also on reducing sitting time, especially in individuals who do not meet the physical activity recommendation.”

In other words, we may need to add “reduce daily sitting time” to our to-do list for a healthier lifestyle.

It wouldn’t hurt any of us, of course, to stand up and move around more often. As the study’s background information points out, the average adult spends more than 90 percent of his or her leisure time sitting (or lying) down.

So don’t just sit there. Get up from your computer and, well…move.

You can also learn about all our free newsletter options.

Comments (2)

  1. Submitted by Lance Groth on 03/27/2012 - 03:21 pm.

    And?

    I don’t doubt the information, but the fact is there isn’t much office workers can do about it. Our jobs require us to sit, usually staring at monitors, for most of the day. Your first sentence seems to say that the negative effects of sitting are evident regardless of whether we exercise for half an hour too. If this is so, then this would seem to be information that is depressing but about which not much can be done. Gee, thanks.

  2. Submitted by Lynda Anderson on 03/28/2012 - 09:40 am.

    not a surprise

    Guess it’s time to rig up a standing desk for work.

Leave a Reply