Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.

UCare generously supports MinnPost’s Second Opinion coverage; learn why.

Overcontrolling parenting of toddlers may lead to emotional and behavioral problems later

Photo by Wang Xi on Unsplash
Children need to learn how to self-regulate their emotions and behaviors — and it’s also essential that they learn that lesson early, before they start school.

The young children of “helicopter parents” — parents who hover over their toddlers, swooping in constantly to guide the child’s play and interactions with others — are less likely to be able to regulate their emotions and behavior when they get older, according to a study published Monday in the journal Developmental Psychology

Those children are also more likely to experience emotional, social and academic problems in school.

“Our findings were not surprising given the critical role parents play in helping their children learn how to manage their arousal and behavior independently,” said Nicole Perry, the study’s lead author and a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Minnesota’s Institute of Child Development, in an e-mail interview with MinnPost.

“A greater desire for independence often puts toddlers in situations of increasing emotional challenge and complexity,” she explained. “If parents try to exert too much control over these situations and step in before children try to handle the challenge on their own, or physically keep children from challenging contexts all together, they may, unintentionally, hinder the development of children’s independent self-regulatory abilities.” 

“For example, if an overcontrolling parent removes a young child from a situation where, for a successful peer interaction, she needs to control her emotions/behavior and share a toy, she may not develop the skills to navigate that situation in socially appropriate ways when a parent is not present.”

How the study was done

For the study, Perry and her colleagues analyzed data collected on 422 mother-child pairs who were participating in the University of North Carolina’s RIGHT Track research project, which is studying children’s emotional regulation and development over time. Two-thirds of the children were white and slightly more than a fourth were African-American. The families came from economically diverse backgrounds, and at the start of the study 80 percent of the mothers were married.  

When the children were 2 years old, they were videotaped as they undertook a play activity and a cleanup task.  Their mothers were told to play with their child as they normally would at home and then to work with the child to clean up the toys in a way that had been introduced to them earlier. Researchers later coded the level of the mothers’ overcontrol (instances when she was too strict or demanding, considering the child’s behavior) on a scale of 1 (low) to 4 (high).  Mothers were scored as being high on the scale if, for example, they constantly guided the child or frequently repeated commands.

The children were videotaped again when they were 5 to see how they would respond to a situation in which there was an unfair sharing of candy and to a task that required them to identify various shapes as fast as possible. The researchers used these videotapes to score the children’s ability to regulate their emotional and behavioral responses to stressful situations. 

Other data for the study came from teacher reports of the children’s social and academic skills at age 5 and 10 and from the children’s own self-reports of their attitudes about school at age 10.

The analysis of all that data revealed a clear pattern.  

“We found that overcontrolling parenting at age 2 was associated with poorer emotional and behavior regulation at age 5, which, in turn, were associated with more child-reported emotional and school problems, fewer teacher-reported social skills, and less teacher-reported academic productivity at age 10,” said Perry.

“Thus, overcontrolling parenting in toddlerhood was associated with adjustment in preadolescence through its association with the development of children’s self-regulatory abilities,” she added.

A necessary lesson

Children need to learn how to self-regulate their emotions and behaviors — and it’s also essential that they learn that lesson early, before they start school.  

Nicole Perry
Nicole Perry

“Greater behavioral and emotional control may decrease the likelihood that children will act out and behave destructively or internalize negative emotions that could lead to increased anxiety or depression,” said Perry.  

Children who can keep their emotions and behavior in check are also more likely to develop better friendships with other children — and to be more liked by their classmates, she added.

By contrast, children who are unable to develop effective ways of self-regulating their emotions and behavior may find school frustrating. 

“This, in turn, could lead to decreased social and academic competence and greater psychological difficulties,” said Perry. 

How to ‘un-helicopter’

The study has some important limitations. Most notably, the mother’s interactions with their children were recorded only a single time (and for just six minutes) and, therefore, may not have been indicative of their day-in-day-out parenting style. 

Still, as Perry and her colleagues point out in their paper, other research has also found a link between overcontrolling parenting and emotional and behavioral problems in children.

What is Perry’s advice to parents who recognize “helicoptering” tendencies in themselves?

“These parents are often very well-intentioned and really want to support their children’s development,” said Perry. “However, it’s important to recognize overcontrol can impede their ability to do so.” 

She recommends that parents take active steps — but in noncontrolling ways — to help their young children learn to control their emotion and behaviors.

First, talk with your child about what behaviors might be triggered by certain emotions, she said. Then discuss how those behaviors may be hurting their ability to calm themselves in response to the emotions. 

Next, help your child develop positive coping strategies for gaining control over negative emotions and behaviors — techniques that will help distract the child from the source of the stress. These strategies can include deep breathing, coloring, listening to music or retreating to a quiet space — whatever works best for the child and is appropriate for a particular situation.

It’s also important, Perry stressed, that parents allow their children to experience a wide variety of emotional situations to help them develop their self-regulating skills.

“Overcontrolling the situation, removing children from emotionally challenging situations, or immediately managing children’s emotions for them without discussion or allowing them the opportunity to try on their own, is unlikely to facilitate these important skills,” she explained.  “Emotionally-charged situations are prime opportunities for parents to praise children if they can effectively use a coping strategy. If parents jump right in they won’t be able to see whether their children had developed the ability to handle the situation.”

“Ideally,” she added, “if the parent is able to help guide and support during those times, children will internalize those strategies into ones that can be used independently.”

Perry also offered this final bit of advice for parents: Set a good example. Use appropriate coping strategies to manage your own emotions and behaviors when upset. 

FMI:  The study can be read in full online.

Comments (3)

  1. Submitted by al stolz on 06/19/2018 - 11:30 am.

    The new “refrigerator mothers”

    In 1943, researcher Leo Kanner wrote a paper claiming that autism was caused by “refrigerator mothers” who interacted with their children too “coldly.” Years later Kanner came to realize that autism was a neurological condition, and that mothers hadn’t caused the condition but rather were adapting their parenting techniques out of necessity. He retracted his claims, but the damage was already done–mothers continued to be blamed for autism well into the 21st century. As a side note, Kanner HAD noticed the same parenting adaptations in both mothers and fathers, but chose to blame only the mothers.

    In 2018, the University of Minnesota’s Nicole Perry writes a paper claiming that behavioral problems in school age children are caused by mothers who interacted with their preschool children in an “overcontrolling” manner. The full study mentions that these mothers already were reporting that their children had difficult behavior, but Perry doesn’t consider the idea that the mothers were adapting their parenting techniques out of necessity. I would argue that having to redirect a child multiple times during a task is not a sign of being “overcontrolling”; it’s a sign of a mother who is making needed adaptations for a child who will later be diagnosed with conditions such as ADHD or ODD. And yes, Perry’s blame falls on “helicopter mothers” not parents in general. She studied over 400 mothers-child interactions, but not a single father-child interaction!

    It’s 2018, but Nicole Perry is making the same damaging (and sexist) mistakes that Leo Kanner made 75 years earlier. What a shame.

  2. Submitted by Joel Stegner on 06/19/2018 - 11:44 am.

    Too hot, too cold, just right

    The real issue is the proper amount of control. Here is a theory. Highly educated parents with one child tend to over control children. That is first born syndrome – we first born get intensive parenting and more than our fair share of mistakes. When you have an only child, all your eggs are in one basket and if you are lax, and your child had big problems as a result, you have no chance to redeem yourself – or at least that is your fear. And believe me, parents rank themselves based on how their children are doing.

    We first borns have seen our parents go soft as the second, third or fourth baby comes along. A lot of the close supervision goes away. Parents simply cannot keep it up. The issue becomes too little control. Your kid can get in serious trouble and you will never know it. Look in your owm family and you wll see the consequences.

    So, this study should have looked at both extremes as simply stopping being a helicopter is a step in the process and not the end all. Our job is to prepare children to be adults when they are ready in careful steps. Giving them more freedom and seeing how it works. Kids naturally rebel against authority – some won’t take much direction, others will. You have to treat child equally, but differently.. The goal a mature adult.

    • Submitted by al stolz on 06/19/2018 - 12:26 pm.

      Birth order is a myth

      The belief that birth order influences personality or behavior has been repeatedly debunked.

Leave a Reply