Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.


Twins’ Joe Mauer is making the case for MVP honors with a truly historic year

Joe Mauer
REUTERS/Eric Miller
Joe Mauer

There’s been lots of talk lately about Joe Mauer‘s chances of winning the American League’s Most Valuable Player award, but rather than focus on how 28 newspaper writers might cast their ballots in six weeks, let’s concentrate on the historically awesome season that the Twins’ catcher is having.

After collecting six hits and three homers in the first three games of the Texas series, he’s 33-for-66 (.500) with seven homers, six doubles, and 19 RBIs in 16 games since his batting average fell to a season-low .353 on Aug. 1. Yes, a season-low .353.

He leads baseball with a .380 batting average and tops the AL in on-base percentage (.448), slugging percentage (.648), OPS (1.095), Runs Above Replacement (65.0) and percentage of runners driven in. Despite spending all of April on the disabled list, he’s up to 25 homers, 77 RBIs and 237 total bases, each of which ranks among the AL’s top 10. Oh, and he’s also the league’s reigning Gold Glove catcher and has thrown out 30 percent of steal attempts this year while making great plays behind the plate.

Mauer has been the AL’s best, most valuable player whether or not the 28 people with an actual vote on the award recognize it, but beyond that, he’s having a truly historic year. What makes his performance so amazing is that throughout baseball history, catcher has been home to the worst hitters. This year is no different, as MLB backstops have managed a measly .256/.321/.398 line and .719 OPS that rank as the worst from any position. In fact, shortstop is the only other spot with an OPS below .750.

Not only is Mauer the best hitter in the league but he’s the best hitter in the league while being a good defender at the least-offensive position on the diamond. Catchers just don’t hit like this, which is why Mauer is on track for his third batting title in five seasons after no catcher in the history of the league ever managed even one before he came around. He’s also at or near the top of almost every all-time leaderboard for catchers, including batting average, on-base percentage, slugging percentage and OPS:

JOE MAUER 2009 .380 Mickey Cochrane 1933 .459
Babe Phelps 1936 .367 Mickey Cochrane 1935 .452
Mike Piazza 1997 .362 JOE MAUER 2009 .448
Bill Dickey 1936 .362 Johnny Bassler 1924 .441
Mickey Cochrane 1930 .357 Chief Meyers 1912 .441
JOE MAUER 2009 .648 JOE MAUER 2009 1.095
Mike Piazza 1997 .638 Mike Piazza 1997 1.069
Gabby Hartnett 1930 .630 Bill Dickey 1936 1.045
Bill Dickey 1936 .617 Gabby Hartnett 1930 1.034
Mike Piazza 2000 .614 Mike Piazza 2000 1.012

Mauer currently has the highest batting average, slugging percentage and OPS in baseball history for a catcher, ranks third all time in on-base percentage, and Mike Piazza is the only guy from the past 70 years to even appear on those lists. Mauer is on track for one of the single greatest catcher seasons in baseball history and has easily been the AL’s best player. He has a 1.100 OPS when no one else is at even 1.000 and, as an aside, his batting average is higher than Mark Teixeira‘s on-base percentage.

Mauer has clearly contributed more runs to his team than anyone else in the league, he’s having one of the greatest seasons of all time for a catcher, and the only other players in baseball history to have a .380 batting average with at least 25 homers this late in the season are Babe Ruth, Ted Williams, Lou Gehrig and Joe DiMaggio. If in six weeks the 28 newspaper writers with an MVP ballot don’t recognize just how amazing he’s been, then perhaps we should stop caring so much about what they think.

You can also learn about all our free newsletter options.

Comments (4)

  1. Submitted by David Koski on 08/20/2009 - 10:33 am.

    I agree. Too bad the season has been so .500.
    To make the ultimate dream a reality, Joe hits for .400 this year and the Twins win their division.

  2. Submitted by John Reinan on 08/20/2009 - 12:20 pm.

    Great analysis, Aaron — thanks for taking up the cause. I’ve seen that list of .380/25 HR hitters elsewhere and I think Rogers Hornsby should be on it.

    He had seasons of .401/42, .403/39 and .380/39, so he probably was at .380/25 at this point in at least one of those years, if not all.

  3. Submitted by Steve Aschburner on 08/20/2009 - 12:30 pm.

    Funny how Johnny Bench doesn’t show up in any of the above categories, yet his 1970 season is one that Joe Mauer might die for. Bench hit 45 home runs, drove in 148 runs, scored 97 runs, went to the plate 671 times, amassed 355 total bases and had 177 hits. Mauer has had that many hits and runs just once so far in his career, never has gone to bat that often and, in his most productive season now, is barely halfway to Bench’s RBI total.

    Oh, and the Big Red Machine’s catcher threw out 30 of 62 would-be base stealers that season. Won the NL MVP award at age 22 and helped the Reds to the first of four World Series, and two titles, with him as their backstop.

  4. Submitted by Peter Nickitas on 08/20/2009 - 08:20 pm.

    The author knows his statistics. His conclusions are low and outside for a ball.

    Mike Texeira will win the AL MVP this year with his home run, RBI, and clutch hit statistics for the first place New York Yankees. Texeira has the numbers and the subjective impact that has put the Yankees at the top of baseball up to now.

    We have an Hispanic Yankee fan on the Supreme Court this year.

    We will have an Hispanic Yankee MVP this year.

    Forget about the Fat Lady. This season will not end until Old Blue Eyes sings — twice.

Leave a Reply