Twins take five steps back as momentum and Morneau break down

Justin Morneau has complained of neck pain since spring training and got cortisone shots in an unsuccessful effort to play through the injury.
REUTERS/Adam Hunger
Justin Morneau has complained of neck pain since spring training and got cortisone shots in an unsuccessful effort to play through the injury.

So much for momentum, huh?

Digging out of the massive early season hole seemed possible and then some when the Twins chased Giants starter Madison Bumgarner from Tuesday’s game with an eight-run first inning. They’d won eight in a row as part of a 15-2 stretch that improved the Twins from an MLB-worst 17-37 to 32-39, miraculously bringing .500 into reach just two weeks after the season looked all but lost and putting them 6.5 games out of first place in a division there for the taking.

Not only have they lost all five games since then, the Twins have scored a grand total of nine runs in 53 innings since that eight-run opening inning, plummeting past the Royals to reclaim the league’s worst record. Anything short of ending the first half on a 13-game winning streak would make clawing back to .500 at the All-Star break mathematically impossible and the Twins are now nine games behind the division-leading Tigers with just 86 games to play.

Momentum left as suddenly as it arrived, but the injury bug unfortunately stuck around. Just as they were finally getting healthy with Joe Mauer, Jim Thome, Glen Perkins, Joe Nathan and Tsuyoshi Nishioka returning from the disabled list, Justin Morneau unexpectedly will undergo neck surgery that may end his season, Delmon Young was carted off the field and placed on the DL with an ankle injury, and Jason Kubel‘s return timetable has been delayed again.

Because they play 21 of the next 25 games at home and the rest of the division is so mediocre, even this buzz-killing setback doesn’t totally wipe away their great run, but ultimately we’re a week from the season’s midway point and the Twins have the AL’s worst record while being further out of first place than all but the Orioles. Detroit sits atop the division despite being on pace for just 87 wins, but in order for the Twins to win 87 games they’d have to finish 55-31.

Possible? Sure, but before and after the 15-2 stretch they’ve gone 17-42.

They’ll be playing at least half of those remaining games without Morneau, who was on the DL for his wrist, rather than his neck, but has complained of neck pain since spring training and got cortisone shots in an unsuccessful effort to play through the injury. Morneau also missed the final 20 games of 2009 because of a back injury and the final 78 games of 2010 with a concussion, meaning by the time he returns, he’ll likely have missed at least 165 of the past 300 games.

It turns out Mauer was the durable one, and an interesting side effect of Morneau’s third major injury in three years is that it gives the Twins a convenient excuse to use Mauer somewhere other than catcher. Every indication is that both Mauer and the Twins have no plans to move him permanently — and rightfully so, because he deserves one more chance to get healthy and stay healthy before a career-altering change — but an occasional start at first base makes sense.

As ugly as the first 76 games of this season have been, the Twins’ outlook in the second half and beyond won’t be a whole lot prettier unless they can get Mauer and Morneau healthy and productive again. They’re making a combined $37 million this year, with the same salaries due in 2012 and 2013, and right now the long-term question marks attached to both former MVPs threaten to overshadow the Twins’ current struggles in a franchise-defining way.

You can also learn about all our free newsletter options.

Comments (3)

  1. Submitted by Ray Schoch on 06/27/2011 - 10:40 am.

    Like CEOs, athletes in most major professional sports are vastly overpaid to begin with, but Mauer’s situation in particular provides a nice illustration of why long-term contracts are usually – not in every single case, but the vast majority of the time – a mistake. Athletic performance is completely dependent upon a superbly-functioning physique. Even minor injuries can be just enough to make a professional athlete not significantly better than the guy playing beer-league softball or weekend hockey or basketball, though the professional’s paydays will, in most cases, continue to be orders of magnitude larger than those of an amateur player.

    Any sort of major medical condition that significantly degrades athletic performance turns the franchise star into an ugly financial albatross, whether s/he’s a “home town” player or not. Morneau and Mauer in the Twin Cities, Albert Pujols in St. Louis, Todd Helton in Colorado are all examples of very good baseball players whose performance has been significantly affected by injuries. We’re all soft-skinned bipeds, and while merely-adequate functioning doesn’t always place severe demands on us physically, the level of performance we’ve come to associate with “professional” athletics is frequently very stressful, indeed. The human body has sometimes amazing recuperative powers, but it truly does not take very much in terms of degradation of ability to turn professional athletes into former professional athletes, many of whom have to get real jobs when that knee or elbow or concussion-injured brain simply refuse to provide the level of ability that was formerly the case.

    55-31 isn’t impossible – plenty of teams have played half a season at .630 winning percentage or so – but given the strength of Twins’ pitching and the lack of offense recently demonstrated, it’s pretty unlikely.

  2. Submitted by Bill Schletzer on 06/27/2011 - 10:44 am.

    Mauer is way overpaid. Just like Garnett was and A Rod when he played in Texas. A smaller market team can’t win when it has to pay one player a disproportionate amount of money. It’s a team sport and Mauer wasn’t thinking of the team when he forced that deal. The Twins would probably be better off trading Mauer to a team in our division and getting a couple of good pitchers or everyday players. Let his salary drag some other team down. We could get a couple all stars for 23 million that would produce more for the team than Mauer can even when he is playing well.

  3. Submitted by Jackson Cage on 06/27/2011 - 02:05 pm.

    Mauer is only more durable than Morneau if you actually believe they were both injured.

Leave a Reply