Walking with a cane
Credit: david Griffiths on Unsplash

When my body won’t hold me anymore

And it finally lets me free

Will I be ready? – Avett Brothers, “No Hard Feelings”

As I move deeper into my sixth decade, my spirit remains willing; spry even on occasion. But my flesh? Not so much. With increasing urgency, my body seems to be sucking wind, reminding me after most any exertion that I am not, well, quite as young as I was.

I hurt more and, as I think about it, something hurts most all the time. My right knee badgers me incessantly. The message, communicated largely through dialects of soreness and stiffness, seems to be, “Yo, dude, after five decades of pounding, how about giving it a rest?”

Other vital joints are joining in the chorus as well. I’ve learned far more about rotator-cuff anatomy than I’ve ever wanted, to understand how the simple act of throwing – something I have taken entirely for granted for longer than memory itself – has become so fraught. I suspect too that I am a likely candidate for hip-replacement surgery before too long. Can’t say I know that anatomical neighborhood very well, but it seems I may be on the cusp of moving there.

So, although I understand, in an existential sense, the truism that things fall apart, I haven’t, until recently, fully appreciated its more parochial implications: That my things – my knees, my hips, and my shoulders – will fall apart. Are falling apart.

And let’s face it, it is discouraging when your body begins to let you down. The carefree running and jumping of my youth now require extraordinary caution. Even walking resembles a sort of hobbling. And skipping? Forget about it; can’t recall the last time I skipped. So, all in all, it’s just harder to embrace the circle of life when completing the jog around that circle has become so labored.

I want to shout sometimes at the injustice. How can it be that I should have but one body for a lifetime, but it doesn’t seem up to going the distance?

And yet, although my body has begun its inexorable decline, I don’t feel in the grasp of despair. In fact, I most often feel grateful, thankful for just how far this bag of bones has carried me, for how resilient it remains despite all the punishment it has taken over the decades.

For my first 20 years or so, that punishment was considerable. I put my body through a meat-grinder of sport and game. Although slight in build (scrawny really) I was inexplicably drawn to sports with the highest rates of collision and played them for far too many seasons.

What was I thinking?

As the toll of organized sport receded in my third and fourth decades, I took to unorganized sport, pick-up games, which produced their own, albeit lower, dose of deterioration.  I took to running and can’t begin to count the miles that I have demanded – more recently, coaxed – from these weary legs. This was also my era of exploration, traveling, hiking, and camping. Fewer collisions, for sure, but wear and tear nonetheless, born of going into the wild to be with creatures, but without creature comforts.  While hard hiking or paddling, followed by a night’s sleep on hard ground, can work magic on the spirit, it can also be torture on the back.

And the results of this decades-long punishment, all the activity, pounding and collisions? About what might be expected: things concussed, broken, cracked, torn, twisted, arthritic, and sore. Things, as foretold, falling apart.

What’s more, I have been too cavalier over many years about the trauma visited upon my carcass from the inside out, by all that I have thoughtlessly ingested. Let’s just say that my eating habits for the last half-century or so could hardly be described as plant-based. And the closest I’ve come to a Mediterranean diet? Probably, I am sheepish to report, my wine consumption. My only hope, then, is that with the advance of science, we come to learn that salty snacks, after all, are really good for you.

I wonder too – don’t we all – what I have unwittingly ingested. What toll have toxic substances, in the air we breathe and water we drink, taken on our bodies? And now, beyond even the assault of pollution and plastic, it seems our species will be tested by heretofore unknown viruses.

I am acutely aware as well that health is often determined by those most elusive variables, genes and luck. I know this from my paternal grandfather, Red O’Brien. As a 19-year-old soldier, he flew very rickety planes in Europe during WWI, including during the Argonne Forest Offensive. He survived the crash of his de Havilland bomber (he called it his “bus”) but with permanent damage to his hip. When stricken by the Spanish flu in the great 1918 pandemic, he found himself in a field hospital where many around him died or were dying. As we tell the story in our family, he stole a bottle of brandy and went AWOL. He was taken in and cared for by a local French family long enough to regain his health before rejoining his troop. A bit of luck and guile served him well in the last pandemic.

Genes, however, may have been his undoing. Although he survived WWI and the Spanish Flu, at the age of 62 he suffered a paralyzing stroke. At roughly my age, his body was broken and bent; it remained that way until his death a decade or so later.

In the shadow of my grandfather’s story, then, I can only be humble that, at this precious moment, I am upright and alive. Despite all the punishment I have visited on my declining body, I can still run a bit, chase a tennis ball, ski and skate with my kids.  Instead of despair, I feel only gratitude that despite all my creaky joints, my aged carcass remains dutiful, holding me up, moving me forward and even allowing for a bit of frolic.

Bill O’Brien lives, works (and frolics occasionally) in Minneapolis.

Join the Conversation

25 Comments

  1. Sorry pal, I am a few years older and I marvel at how well things have held up. Speaks to the wonders of a sedentary lifestyle: enjoyed fishing when I was 20 and still today, with no diminishment in performance. Peak moments in Horseshoes still occur. Do have a few moments of cautionary reflection at the top of a 30′ ladder.

    1. I read the orig post…then started running thru a litany in my head of many symptoms I’ve had to deal w the past almost 25 yrs w a very debilitating disease…then read your post…and just LAUGHED. I mean really, what else can we do at this point? Thanks for the tongue in cheek levity. I needed that.

  2. Mr. O’Brien, with all due respect, I ain’t buyin’ it. Your essay is another example of an attitude far too prevalent: There’s nothing I can do. The challenge ahead is acceptance.

    No. The challenge ahead is to get lean, eat vegan, live right and exercise. There’s no such thing as your “wear and tear”. Our bodies can and will respond to healthy living.

    1. I was lean & very fit & healthy for years. Never even got normal childhood maladies. Then a virus brought me to my knees and absolutely nothing since has helped bring that back, even briefly. So I know longer believe nutrition & exercise are the key. Yes, they are still important. But they are not a deterrent to certain illnesses; in my case a viral attack that systematically affected EVERYTHING. And still does despite numerous & ongoing efforts to overcome the damage.

      1. Try cutting out meat, dairy, and bread. See what happens. It’s a big deal at first. But the one thing you don’t have to do is diet. You eat as much as you want, the weight falls off, and you never know. It might be the cure you’re looking for. Also see https://nutriciously.com/vegan-doctors/

        1. ???? I’m not looking to lose weight & I know all about nutrition, healthy eating, the importance of exercise, etc. A specific type of virus caused significant & lasting systemic damage throughout my entire body! Nothing, out of many things tried, has made any difference over the years, nor is there a cure. Indeed some things tried made things worse:( So a total jock type has had to admit defeat, accept the loss of a previous way of life, and adjust/adapt to a much smaller & limited way of life. I still dont fully accept it. I understand that folks who haven’t experienced physical losses like this–plus financial!–might struggle to understand the enormity. But they need to try. Everyone else who has suddenly had their body betray them for whatever reason(s) and who is now severely debilitated will fully understand.

          1. My heart goes out and I’m on your side. What I’m saying is people have made remarkable turnarounds through vegan eating. When you say you don’t fully accept your condition that’s a good thing. Keep punching.

    2. While I agree that most Americans should drastically reduce their meat consumption, I’m very skeptical of veganism. While an admittedly small sample size, my mother, on the cusp of octogenaraianism, is scrawny to the point that her doctor recommends she add weight – which she hasn’t been able to do on a vegan diet. She can’t tolerate cold either; which in her climate is the 50s. Her energy levels are markedly lower. On the other hand, the ovo-pesca-poultrytarians seem to have more energy & fewer complications. Though, again, a very small sample size.

      I dare say, based on my observations, diet is not as significant as staying active & mentally stimulated. The 3rd set of Octos I can cite have poor diet & limited activity. And they’re struggling.

  3. Bill, a well written article. Love the title.
    Having a career in health care, your genes are indeed the largest determinant of your lifespan.

    At times reading comments like this it reminds me of standing in front of “The Fates gathering in the Stars” painting (1887 by Elihu Vedder) at the Art Institute of Chicago. One fate spinning the strands of our life, another determining the length of life and the third cutting the strands at our time of death.

    Ian, being the same age as you, I admire your self-determination at staying fit. My running days are in the past. Like the author, I did sports, ran cross country, played soccer well into my thirties. I recall breaking through the running barrier to where I could run cross country several miles on county park trails and then halt, not being out of breath or even breathing deeply. I was arrogant in that same time frame about skiing triple diamond slopes and as we said then, shredding them to pieces. I do now feel it.

    A good walk is still most welcome to clear mental cobwebs.

    Vegan lifestyle? If that works for you Ms. Wicklow, God bless. Really. However, most of the doctors I worked under said that we humans have been carnivores for many tens of thousands of years and… our genetics have since taken that into account.

    Bill, drink your wine unashamedly. I had a primary doctor who at one of my physicals had earrings of grape clusters. When asked about this, she said they were a gift from her granddaughter “because grandma seems to always have wine handy”. We laughed and proceeded on with the physical.

    1. This country is fat and sick, and getting fatter and sicker. We’re eating the wrong food, and it’s not carrots. My cat is a carnivore, with a short GI tract. I am a herbivore, with a GI tract your doctors would find indistinguishable from any great ape. You don’t need meat, or bread, or dairy, or added salt. These are bad for you, like the New York Times. I threw that last one in, but you know what I mean.

      1. “I am a herbivore, with a GI tract your doctors would find indistinguishable from any great ape.”

        Follow the diet that works best for you, but if your doctor can’t tell the difference between a human and a simian GI tract, it may be time to look for a new doctor.

          1. However I did catch the humor. You could have said something about which party is more apelike. Maybe we don’t wanna go there : )

            1. “You could have said something about which party is more apelike. Maybe we don’t wanna go there : )”

              No, I don’t think we do. Let us leave it here.

          2. No, they aren’t, but maybe I should start asking my doctor what grade they got in gross anatomy.

          3. They are very different. That’s not to say that you can’t be vegetarian/vegan, if you so choose. But it is entirely a choice. Our bodies were designed to be omnivorous, and our gut is pretty uniquely designed to handle nearly anything we throw at it. There are lots of diets that are “healthy,” but yours is not uniquely so. Nor does it convey upon you any particular medical authority (clearly) or moral superiority, especially if your only reason for choosing it is internally focused.

            For what it’s worth, the author was not complaining about the natural process his body is going through. He was simply sharing his experience, which only he is the expert on, whether you “buy it” or not.

  4. Some of your words remind me of the ancient writer, Solomon (Ecclesiastes 12).

    He may have come to a different collusion than you, but some concepts are the same.

  5. Ya know it’s funny. Someone writes a simple and elegant essay about the simple fact that as we get older… we age, and people think they can “argue” about it. It is simply a biological fact that we are all dying, and there is no predictable, or reliable method or strategy that can be deployed to prevent death. I know death frightens people, but no amount of denial, exercise, or diet, can prevent it. So whatever, everyone get’s to face their mortality their own way but this not “debatable”. So you play pickleball or run five miles a day until you blow out your hip, or knee, and spend the rest of your days in pain. And you think you’re better than those of us who never blow out a joint or tear a muscle or tendon… Whatever.

    We know that bodies age, joints and muscles are NOT the same at the age of 60 as they are at 20 or 30, and we know that diet and exercise don’t delay the aging process, although it’s always better to be in the best shape you can be at your age… than not be. But something will eventually kill you, and whatever that is will happen regardless. So if you feel great now, good for you… but don’t expect it to last indefinitely. Life expectancy in the US is actually declining. I’m old enough to have seen several people die, and they are frequently in good to great shape… until they’re not. Regardless of diet, exercise, Yoga, whatever… the subscription seems to run out around 80-85 for most people these days. So if you’re in your 60s and you think your going to make it to 100 because you play pickleball well… you do you.

    1. Right? Our time on this planet is finite. It is far healthier to appreciate what you have than to give a rip about whether someone tells you you’re doing it wrong. Even vegans have a shelf life.

    2. Yep. I think there are a lot of benefits to being active, but practice yoga, run, or play pickleball (looks like fun) because you enjoy the activity or the socializing associated with it, not because you think it’ll help you live until you’re 103.

      1. I don’t disagree, but would suggest finding something – anything – active to do regularly is hugely significant; and good call on the social component too.

        One of my joys as a parent has been that my kids are able to see their active grandparents living quality lives. I hope I’m lucky enough to do the same.

    3. Paul wrote: I’m old enough to have seen several people die, and they are frequently in good to great shape… until they’re not. Of the latter part of Paul’s comment, be thankful if that is what people say about you at your wake. That was the story of my father, about 97 years, 3 months, and two weeks of good health, and several days not so good. I chalk that up as a win.
      Of the first part of Paul’s statement: My dad outlasted all of his siblings. Someone asked him how it felt to outlive them all, and dad paused and said – There is no joy in watching all the people you love pass away before your eyes.
      Might I amend your timeframe on death, the subscription runs out more accurately at about 75. Some live longer however ask yourself about how often you read of people pass in their early to mid-60s. (I see this especially for some reason with jazz musicians.) However, you are spot-on about life expectancy declining.

      One of my earlier and sadder experiences was a patient who (coming in from a nursing home with pneumonia) asked, “Why don’t they let me die? I’ve outlived everyone I know, my children are gone, my husband is gone, and again and again, they get me well and send me back to the nursing home. Where I go back to watch others die around me.”

      Rachel: “Even vegans have a shelf life.” Thank you for that laugh Rachel! Thank you.

      1. Yeah, I wasn’t speaking statistically, just personally, I’ve known some younger some older who died. But most recent people I’ve lost, parents, mother in law, other seniors, were all in their mid to lower 80s.

        Saw a video on Facebook a couple days ago, retired guy who’s idea of aging gracefully is taking naps with cats at neighborhood rescue shelter. I can get behind that.

  6. When my father remarried, his new mother-in-law shared her wisdom & humor until she passed at 96. Best line:

    “Getting old ain’t for sissies!”

  7. Well, you CAN the young stuff… but they frequently don’t listen. What’s the old saying again? Youth is wasted on the young?

Leave a comment