WASHINGTON — By all accounts, the Bug-O-Nay-Ge-Shig School needs help.
The school serves nearly 200 students on the Leech Lake Indian Reservation in Northern Minnesota. Part of it is housed in a former barn, converted into what was supposed to be a temporary school building in 1984. Thirty years later, it’s still occupied, it fails to meet fire and health standards, it’s riddled with mold and fungus and rodents and lacks such basic security measures that police have taken to dubbing it “Killer Hall.”
Students are in dire need of a new building — in 2011, an Indian Affairs secretary said, “preliminary evaluations indicate that the building should be replaced.”
The Bug School’s problems are emblematic of the country’s 183 Bureau of Indian Education schools, one-third of which are in desperate need of repairs or replacement.
But funding has been in short supply. For the last two years, the Obama administration hasn’t requested any money to replace a small handful of schools that have needed new facilities since at least 2004. His request for next year covers construction for only one school.
The lack of funding is especially galling for Indian education advocates given the way the federal government funds the second education system it runs, for the Department of Defense. In 2010, the DOD established a list of 134 schools that need replacing or modernizing, at a cost of $3.7 billion, and they hope to finish the project by 2018.
Indian education advocates say BIE needs its own, updated list of replaceable schools, and administration officials said one could come out as soon as this year. Minnesota Rep. Betty McCollum said the government is bretraying its “trust and treaty obligations” with Indian tribes the longer their schools sit in disrepair.
This year, the House plans to appropriate $65 million to build a single new 275-student DOD school in Guantánamo Bay. The House has yet to release its Indian Education budget for next year, but its 2014 total was paltry: just $954,000 to begin planning a replacement school in Maine, and $55 million for construction and repairs across the whole system.
“When we needed to build [the Guantánamo] school and get it right for those children, we came up with the money to do that,” McCollum said. “We can do that for the other American children in this country, too. It shouldn’t be an either-or. All children are deserving.”
McCollum: More funding for tribal schools
Funding for Indian schools falls under a couple of McCollum’s legislative purviews.
She’s Minnesota’s only member of the budget-writing Appropriations Committee and the future top Democrat on the committee’s Interior panel, which handles Indian Affairs funding. She’s also the co-chair of the House Native American Caucus, and she said improving tribes’ schools would help everything from Native American graduation and literacy rates to reducing suicide among tribal teenagers.
To be sure, McCollum also supports the DOD’s rebuild effort. But she said lawmakers aren’t paying enough attention to Indian schools and their 48,000 students. In April, when the Guantanamo funding was announced, she said it amounted to “inequality.”
After McCollum joined Congress in 2001, “people were coming in, lobbying for more impact aid, both the DOD and the Bureau of Indian school parents were coming in together, to get that number up for dollars for resources for their children,” she said.
At one point, she said, military parents came in to talk about personal fundraisers designed to raise money for air conditioners in schools.
“That kind of got everyone’s attention because people were paying attention to what was going on on the military bases because of the Iraq War and the Afghan War, so people kind of tuned in to service members and their family’s lives,” she said.
McCollum also started touring schools on Indian reservations around the country. In New Mexico, she saw a school so badly ravaged by an earthquake that there were open cracks in the walls. In South Dakota, the roadways leading to Indian schools were so bad “school buses literally deteriorate on the road’s they’re traveling on.”
White Earth school replaced
The Bureau of Indian Education gave Congress a list of schools it wanted to replace in 2004. Congress pumped tens of millions of dollars into the program for a few years, funding 38 replacement schools or facilities between 2002 and 2011, according to a 2011 report on BIE construction.
In 2005, a BIE school on Minnesota’s White Earth reservation began receiving funding for a new $16 million building. The reservation’s old facility had leaky walls and roofing, education director Joan LaVoy said. In the 2004 report, it was ranked sixth on the list of most needed replacement schools.
An outside agency “basically said we shouldn’t even be in that facility,” McVoy said. “We were in a very, very poor facility.”
Their new building, the Circle of Life School, opened two years ago — thanks to both federal and tribal funds — and “it’s beautiful,” McVoy said, with a new football field, large gymnasium and state-of-the-art technology in it’s classrooms.
New replacement list needed
Repair and rebuilding efforts received more than $244 million in the 2009 stimulus act, but Obama administration funding requests for new schools have slowed since then. While the Department of Defense asked for $2.7 billion for new school construction in 2013, Indian Affairs hadn’t requested replacement funding since the 2011 fiscal year. The Bureau is asking for $3.2 million for construction funds in 2015, and there are still three major projects left over from its 2004 list, at a cost of $58.6 million.
Congress hasn’t exactly helped, either: An early draft budget for 2014 included enough funding to nearly zero-out that list, but it didn’t make it into the year’s final funding package. McCollum said she thinks lawmakers would move quickly on school construction if they had a thorough overview of what school buildings need replacing, like the DOD’s.
“We need to get a list of what we can do in repair and maintenance and what needs to be fully replaced,” she said. “Because I haven’t seen that list, I don’t want to just pull a pie in the sky number and be stuck with it.”
A Bureau of Indian Affairs spokeswoman said the department is crafting a new replacement list and a funding plan to upgrade BIE facilities within six years. The list could come out this year, and the three schools left over from the 2004 version — two in Arizona and one in Maine — will be included.
In the meantime, Indian education advocates have asked for a big boost in repair and replacement funding. Using a government formula, about a third of BIE schools are rated as “poor,” and getting them up to satisfactory levels could cost as much as $1.3 billion.
The National Indian Education Association suggested more than $263 million annually in 2013, and Bug School superintendent Crystal Redgrave told the House Appropriations Committee in April that it should budget $200 million a year until the construction backlog is reduced.
Minnesota’s BIE schools
Bug-O-Nay-Ge-Shig School
Bena, MN
Facility condition (2011): Poor
Circle of Life School
White Earth, MN
Facility condition (2011): Good
Fond du Lac Ojibwe School
Cloquet, MN
Facility condition (2011): Good
Nay-Ah-Shing School
Onamia, MN
Facility condition (2011): Good
Minnesota has four BIE schools, but the Bug School is the only one rated in “poor” condition. It would cost more than $23 million to get it up to acceptable levels. McCollum called it “the poster child for many schools all over the country which are inadequate physical structures for our schools to be in.”
Tribes to get more control over schools
Still, Native American education advocates say things are looking up.
Before Obama’s visit to a North Dakota reservation last week, the Department of Indian Affairs released a new set of guidelines meant to give tribes themselves more control over their BIE-funded schools. The administration still needs to fill in the funding details, but NIEA executive director Ahniwake Rose said she expects to see a bump up in replacement and repair funding for old school buildings.
She said the schools badly need it. Some tribal schools are still using chalk boards, or struggling to offer broadband Internet, while students elsewhere have a massive technological leg up — Baltimore City Public Schools, for example, plans to arm every student with tablet or laptop.
“The way your school looks is a direct reflection of the way students feel about their learning environment,” Rose said. “If you know you’re not valued, you’re not going to want to go to school.”
Devin Henry can be reached at dhenry@minnpost.com. Follow him on Twitter: @dhenry
Why fund?
Was there some 1850-or-so treaty that mandated that the state or federal government subsidize Native American schooling? We all know of the treaties that they routinely publicize that give them rights to their own land, but are there any that require permanent federal assistance?
Why not mandate the rich tribes support the poor? Shouldn’t the uber-rich Shakopee Mdewakanton Sioux Community assist such tribes in building new schools? I know they send token amounts to remote tribes, but not enough to fund a new school presently.
I’d rather the federal government fund schools for citizens that pay taxes to the federal government. It makes for a better fiscal policy and such schools are open to everyone rather than a very small ethnic group.
Yes. Treaty with the Sioux, 1868
Article 7.
In order to insure the civilization of the Indians entering into this treaty, the necessity of education is admitted, especially of such of them as are or may be settled on said agricultural reservations, and they therefore pledge themselves to compel their children, male and female, between the ages of six and sixteen years, to attend school; and it is hereby made the duty of the agent for said Indians to see that this stipulation is strictly complied with; and the United States agrees that for every thirty children between said ages who can be induced or compelled to attend school, a house shall be provided and a teacher competent to teach the elementary branches of an English education shall be furnished, who will reside among said Indians, and faithfully discharge his or her duties as a teacher. The provisions of this article to continue for not less than twenty years.
FYI
Native Americans pay taxes to the federal government. They also are citizens.
Are these schools responsible for the
achievement gap between native students and other students?
New facilities may be warranted but what takes place in the building is more important than the building itself.
What takes place outside the building
There are a number of factors that could contribute to this gap.
Twenty-eight percent of the Native Americans living on all reservations are under the poverty line. The rate for all Americans is 15%. The alcohol dependency rate for Native Americans is the highest of all ethnic groups, and over twice the national average. Natives on reservations have a high school graduation rate that is less than half the rate of all Native Americans.
Over 1/3 (35%) of reservation residents are out of the labor force (not working, including those not actively seeking employment). Ironically, the largest employers historically have been reservation schools. On reservations with casinos, the average unemployment rate is 13%. The median income on all reservations (casino and non-casino alike) is around $29,000; the median income for the entire US is around $41,000.
Native American Schools
There are no American Indians attending……just Native American children.
Wild rice, not curried rice.
Try to keep up with the world.
Respectfully
Either term is one of many that is chosen by, and used by, indigenous people to this country to describe their people. These comments are disrespectful and uncalled for.
Where’s the democrats’ incentive?
The tribal elders at Standing Rock greeted Barack Obama with open arms last week, thanking him for all his help and pledging their unflinching support despite their 72% unemployment rate.
What has Betty done? The article says she visited reservations in New Mexico and South Dakota, but has she ever been to the school in Leech Lake?
Where’s her spending request that she submitted for addition to the congressional budget? Did she ever submit one?
Why should she? She doesn’t need those votes.
Treaties and obligations
Perhaps Mr. Riddel you want to review the constitution and brush up on your understanding of history before you vote again.
1. Treaties are made between nations. The fact that the US chose to make treaties means that it recognized tribal governments. Article 6 of the constitution makes them the supreme law of the land. Tribal treaties are generally about property rights, what rights the tribes retain “hunt fish and gather in the ceded territories” and which they give up – exclusive occupancy in exchange for some compensation. Education was often one of the types of compensation. .
2. Tribal members (and most carry a citizen or membership card from their tribe) all pay federal taxes just like everyone else. They also pay state income and property taxes just like you or I if they don’t live on land in trust held for them by the federal government land and/or outside the boundaries of reservation. That is pretty much most of the country.
3. It is irrational to suggest that wealthy tribes be made to share their income involuntarily with other tribes. That would like suggesting that since Sweden has a higher per capita income they share the surplus with Romania. The assumption that all tribes are alike is like saying every one white is related. That kind of stereotypical thinking about categories of people based on superficial characteristics like ethnic group, gender or skin color died in educated people in about the 90’s. There are words that end in ism that are used for people who still express them.
DOD schools
The DOD schools are being studied for closure per budget cuts. Only about 15% of military children attend DOD schools. All children deserve an education and the opportunity to improve their future.