Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.

MinnPost's education reporting is made possible by a grant from the Bush Foundation.

The new Mill City High will be unlike any other school in Minneapolis

Courtesy of John Miller
John Miller teaching a sample class at an information event.

John Miller had been teaching pretty happily for a quarter of a century when it occurred to him that he was in a position to fix the sundry small discontents of his professional life by dreaming up and opening his own school.

This fall, after nearly four years of planning, scheming, grant-writing and the completion of enough paperwork to obliterate a lesser vision, Mill City High School will open in downtown Minneapolis. It will be completely unlike any other school hereabouts, and if the reality lives up to the idea, it will rock.

It will also be one of five charter schools authorized by the Minnesota Guild of Charter Schools, an offshoot of the Minneapolis Federation of Teachers (MFT). The MFT is the first teachers union in the country to begin authorizing charter schools. Accordingly, the new programs are teacher-led.

Located in the shadow of the new Vikings stadium in First Covenant Church, Mill City will offer a novel, four-pronged approach with Global Classical Studies as a lynchpin. Up to 150 students, spread across ninth-, 10th-, and 11th-grades, are expected this year, with the school eventually serving grades 9-12.

Global Classical Studies might most easily be explained by returning to the topic of Miller’s desire to change things up mid-career. In 2011 when the MFT received state permission to enter chartering, Miller was teaching at Eagle Ridge Academy.

A K-12 school located in Eden Prairie, Eagle Ridge is one of a number of Twin Cities charter schools, most of them located in affluent suburbs, to offer classical education. The classics being, of course, the works of Western thinkers ranging from the ancient Greeks to the U.S. Founding Fathers.

The approach is rigorous academically, and the schools are among the state’s top performers. Though they have been located primarily in affluent areas to date, student bodies have diversified in recent years.

(Classical education has also been popular in households which, for reasons religious or political, are not crazy about the multiculturalism they believe is invading public schools. One of Eagle Ridge’s missions, for example, is to foster “an appreciation for the United States of America and her unique role in the world.”)

Miller loved Eagle Ridge’s “blend of rigor and friendliness.” Yet when it became clear the school was going to undergo some transitions, he mulled until it became clear that what he’d really like was to design his own program.

Consider one of his frustrations: Over the previous four years he had taught 16 periods of high school humanities, 15 of which dealt with the Western world.

“The one period that deals with the rest of the world was called ‘Eastern Thought,’ ” he recalls. “They crammed everything in there — including Islam, just to have it somewhere.”

Classical approach, but opened up

Miller wanted to move away from the Eurocentric curriculum but keep the approach, which he believes is fabulously suited to driving students to ever-richer levels of understanding and to teaching critical inquiry.

Students proceed from a grammar stage, which consists of direct instruction in basic knowledge and skills, to a Socratic dialectic in which they attempt to think their way to a logical conclusion. That is followed by seminar discussion.

John Miller
Courtesy of John Miller
John Miller

Why not keep the structure, but open the field of inquiry up to the classics of other traditions and civilizations?

“Have a conversation amongst students where you give them open-ended questions,” Miller explains, “but instead of Plato vs. Aristotle it’s Lao Tze vs. Buddha.”

Why not start with cultures that are 2,000 years old, and include indigenous and African traditions and — as students age and the global classics become more contemporary — Latin American and African-American experiences?

“We’ll teach the civil-rights movement, but also the gay civil-rights movement so kids from all kinds of modes of diversity will see themselves,” says Miller.

Big vision notwithstanding, opening a charter school — much less a high school — is a tough undertaking in the Twin Cities right now. One of the biggest hurdles is finding space. Schools require universal access, gyms, commercial kitchens and other expensive renovations. Most landlords don’t want to invest for a startup.

First Covenant

As it happened, First Covenant was in search of people who might like to use its four floors of mostly vacant space for activities that jibe with its social justice mission. Built in 1885, the church’s sanctuary was for a time the tallest building in the city.

A second building once housed Sunday school for 1,000 students. Mill City will max out at 300.

It didn’t hurt that a former student of Miller’s was the son of the pastor, who is a member of a downtown Multi-Faith Network that includes priests and imams and other clergy committed to working together.

“You can’t beat the location,” says Miller. “All roads lead downtown. Light rail leads downtown. Buses all go downtown.”

Mill City High School promotional video

Because Mill City’s students are likely to be at different achievement levels on enrollment, the school has a number of plans for helping some kids accelerate while others catch up.

The first 12 weeks of the 17-week semesters and the first three days of each week, “everybody gets what the state says they need to get” — instruction on academic standards — “but with differentiation.”

Students who pass at those junctures will go on to enriched electives and, if they pass there, to courses where they can apply their learning. Those who haven’t mastered a topic will get intensive coaching.

‘A culture of mastery’

Because teachers have no control over students’ home circumstances, there will be no homework. Basics will be done in school, and a B must be earned to pass a subject.

“We want to emphasize the intrinsic motivation,” says Miller. “It’s really about establishing a culture of mastery.”

So where does one assemble a faculty well versed in global classics? Miller laughs. Lack of an existing curriculum notwithstanding, lots of teachers have expressed interest. And there is no shortage of elders and others who have agreed to serve as resources.

A couple of notes about the teachers and their employer: Mill City is one of five schools authorized by the Guild. One, an arts and science elementary program, opened last year in Cambridge. The other three, all slated to open this fall, include a school in Rochester that will serve students with executive function challenges and two other Minneapolis programs.

Mill City’s teachers will be at-will employees on contracts at the start of the year. Miller says he expects they will quickly ask Education Minnesota, the state’s largest teacher union, to meet with them to discuss organizing. That the faculty will unionize is likely but not a foregone conclusion, nor one of the impetuses for starting the school.

“It’s part of empowering teachers,” says Miller. “It goes back to the origins of charter schools in the whole country. It’s one way of empowering teachers; teachers know the most about what is going on in the classroom.”

Mill City will have a teacher-majority board, and a great deal of thought has gone into organizing the day and week so teachers have time to work in teams.

So what, nine months after quitting a good job and four years after starting this quest, does this feel like to Miller?

“After being in education for 25 years, I got to design my own school,” he says, grinning. “The perfect school where I’d like to work.”

Comments (8)

  1. Submitted by Lynnell Mickelsen on 06/12/2015 - 09:16 am.

    I hope this school thrives…..

    …..and I wish it all the best because we need lots of different education models out there and this one sounds really interesting. And you’re right, if it works, it will be amazing.

    It’s not easy to start a new school. There will be bumps and problems. But I applaud for everyone involved for trying something new.

    I’d also like to see Education Minnesota come up with a 21st century, model contract that pays teachers well, contributes to a great work environment, and is flexible and performance-focused.

    This could be a win-win for everyone involved.

    Beth—what are the names of the other three schools that the Guild is opening his fall and can you tell us more about the other two in Minneapolis? Are they K-5? Middle schools? High Schools? What locations.

    • Submitted by Beth Hawkins on 06/12/2015 - 09:23 pm.

      Precious little, Lynnell

      I made some calls about the other Guild schools and turned up… almost nothing. Which is curious. Both of the other Minneapolis programs are secondary schools. One is Learning ReImagined and the other is Metropolitan Education for Future Employment. The former lists its location as Northeast Minneapolis. The latter lists former city council member Tony Scallon as a contact.

  2. Submitted by Rachel Kahler on 06/12/2015 - 10:42 am.

    Hope it works

    It sounds great. I hope it works.

  3. Submitted by John Egekrout on 06/12/2015 - 02:14 pm.

    hardly new idea

    The idea of a teacher-led school has been practiced by the Edvisions charter schools for years. Nothing new there. I do think that a unionized charter is the way to go if you are going to have a charter school. These teachers deserve comparable pay, benefits and protections as other public school teachers.

  4. Submitted by Ray Schoch on 06/12/2015 - 06:15 pm.

    Sounds great

    I very much like the dual philosophical stances of a more-than-just-western-europe approach to what constitutes civilization and civilized life, and a teacher-led school. If it works – and that remains to be seen – it’ll be a great model for a charter school to do what charter schools are supposed to do, which is to serve as laboratories for public schools, and to pass on to those public schools ideas and innovations that work, so that all students, everywhere, can get a very similar experience at their own school, whether it’s a charter or not. Perhaps the hardest part of this experiment will be finding out if the Mill City High model, assuming it works as its founder(s) hopes, is freely shared and readily available to other, more traditional schools in the Minneapolis system.

  5. Submitted by Valerie Olsen-Rittler on 06/12/2015 - 08:04 pm.

    Not MFT

    The rank and file of the Minneapolis Federation of Teachers NEVER voted on becoming a charter authorizer. MPS teachers have no interest in opening charter schools and weakening the Minneapolis Public Schools. Louise Sundin (former MFT president) and Lynn Nordgren (current MFT president) are the two who started the Guild—by questionable methods–in the name of MFT. The money for the startup of The Guild came from an “innovation” grant from the Gates Foundation. Really, the Guild should never be referred to as an offshoot of the union. This is confusing to parents and the public. In my opinion, The Guild is a distraction and disgrace.

    • Submitted by Harris Goldstein on 06/13/2015 - 02:57 pm.

      Distraction and Disgrace?

      Strong words. Can you back them up (especially “disgrace”?

      I don’t have any knowledge of the Guild, but I do know – first hand – that different students will thrive in different environments. My oldest son did well at Wayzata HS. But my other son did not – yet did well at the Perpich Arts HS.

      Does the Mpls School Distract provide a range of educational models? I’m aware of the Wellstone Int’l HS, but no other programs that are not traditional. If so, I stand corrected.

      I agree that some charter schools might be more focused on a point of view instead of education, but not all. If the school district can’t or won’t provide alternative models that provide a quality education, I say more power to a teacher-led model.

  6. Submitted by Joe Musich on 06/12/2015 - 10:47 pm.

    Under the umbrella of mft59 …

    And the teachers are not unionized. Reprehensible!

Leave a Reply