An image from the Ward 1 candidate forum. Elliott Payne secured 78 percent of the delegate vote over current Council Member Kevin Reich.
An image from the Ward 1 candidate forum. Elliott Payne secured 78 percent of the delegate vote over current Council Member Kevin Reich. Credit: Screen shot

Due to the coronavirus, the Minneapolis DFL had to conduct its 2021 endorsement process entirely online. That included the ward conventions, which were held last weekend, though the results weren’t available until earlier this week. The process saw more 4,800 ward delegates vote for council endorsements, a turnout that was more than double that of 2017, when the last city election was held. Here, five takeaways from the party’s endorsements process and what it could mean for the November elections: 

It’s still (mostly) good to be an incumbent

In order to win an endorsement from the city’s dominant party, candidates needed at least 60 percent of the vote in the final round of ranked choice voting. If no one clears that threshold, no one is endorsed in the race.

Council Member Phillipe Cunningham
[image_caption]Council Member Phillipe Cunningham[/image_caption]
Five of the seven DFL endorsements announced this week went to incumbents currently on council: Phillipe Cunningham tallied 63 percent in the Ward 4 endorsement contest; Lisa Goodman — the longest tenured current Minneapolis City Council member — managed to get 61.6 percent of the vote for the Ward 7 endorsement; Council Vice President Andrea Jenkins got 76.3 percent in the Ward 8 fight; Andrew Johnson won the Ward 12 endorsement with 80.6 percent of the vote; and Linea Palmisano won the endorsement in Ward 13 with 67.7 percent of the delegates. 

In only one race did a challenger get the DFL endorsement over an incumbent. In Ward 1, representing much of northeast Minneapolis, Elliott Payne secured 78 percent of the delegate vote in Ward 1 over current Council Member Kevin Reich. 

Jason Chavez, who is running for the open seat being vacated by Alondra Cano in Ward 9, was the only other non-incumbent to nab an endorsement, getting the nod against several other candidates with 69 percent of the vote. 

Also popular: no endorsement

The races in Wards 2, 3, 5, 6, 10 and 11 resulted in no endorsements, meaning no candidate in any of those contests got 60 percent of the delegate vote. But that doesn’t mean some candidates didn’t come close. 

In Ward 5, which is currently represented by Council Member Jeremiah Ellison, challenger Victor Martinez just barely missed out on the endorsement, picking up 58 percent of the vote over Ellison’s 39 percent in the final round. 

Another challenger to a council incumbent, this one in Ward 11, also came close to securing the endorsement. Emily Koski finished the night with 54 percent of the vote over Council Member Jeremy Schroeder, who got 45 percent of the vote.

Council Member Steve Fletcher
[image_caption]Council Member Steve Fletcher[/image_caption]
In Ward 3, incumbent Council Member Fletcher won 55 percent of the final round, holding off Michael Rainville, who picked up 43 percent of the vote. Another incumbent, Council Member Jamal Osman, got 54 percent of the vote in the Ward 6 endorsement fight over Abdirizak Bihi, who got 42 percent of delegate support. 

In Ward 2, which is currently represented by the only non-DFLer on council, Green Party member Cam Gordon, two challengers faced off for the DFL endorsement. And though she didn’t get the required 60 percent, Yasura Arab came close, securing 57.4 percent of the vote over Tom Anderson, who garnered 18.2 percent. 

In Ward 10, candidate Aisha Chughtai received 49.6 percent of the delegate vote over runner-up Alicia Gibson, who received 38.8 percent, and Chughtai immediately used the results proclaim herself the favorite in the November election: “This campaign is the clear frontrunner in this race,” she said in a statement. 

Everybody showed

Minneapolis is essentially a one-party town, and the DFL is that party. In the fall of 2020, the city’s voters went for Joe Biden over Donald Trump by 75 points in the presidential election. That doesn’t mean that every Democratic candidate loves the DFL’s  endorsement process, though, and previous elections have seen candidates choose to skip the whole thing. That wasn’t the case this year. Every single DFL incumbent — Reich, Fletcher, Cunningham, Ellison, Osman, Goodman, Jenkins, Schroeder, Johnson and Palminsano — participated in the process, including the candidate forums.

Endorsements sent mixed signals on policing

Almost every candidate running for council this year is advocating some degree of reform for the Minneapolis Police Department. But the idea of “defunding” or ending MPD (in favor of a department of public safety) has become something of a line of demarcation among candidates, even if the endorsement results offer a mixed message on how popular those ideas are with voters. 

Council Vice President Andrea Jenkins
[image_caption]Council Vice President Andrea Jenkins[/image_caption]
While several incumbents who signed on to a pledge last summer to “dismantle” the police department — including Cunningham and Jenkins — won endorsements, others did not. Fletcher, Schroeder and Ellison, all of whom also took the pledge, not only failed to win endorsements, but Ellison and Schroeder saw challengers get more votes than they did. 

At the same time, one of the three incumbents to not sign the “dismantle” pledge, Ward 1’s Kevin Reich, lost his endorsement bid to Payne by a large margin. 

The process was smooth. And long. 

By virtue of being virtual, the often raucous and sometimes chaos nature of previous conventions was lost. Without delegates, candidates and supporters in one location, the action boiled down to the candidate forums, during which prospective Council members gave speeches to make their case. 

With 13 wards, that meant seven hours of screen-time for speeches on Saturday and another six on Sunday. Still, one upside is that the candidate forums were recorded and uploaded to YouTube, meaning voters will be able to reference the speeches if they didn’t catch them live.

Join the Conversation

5 Comments

  1. David B. Wheeler ran for Ward 10’s City Council position. I am saddened to see that he did not garner support. He has experience governing in Duluth, Minnesota’s City Council, and is rational and no nonsense. He has been a pastor, and serves on the Minneapolis Board of Estimates and Taxation. As a Democrat, he is also good with making decisions with money; and with his age and temperament, he will make an excellent member of the Minneapolis City Council.

    As a gay man who does not wear his sexuality on his sleeve, but speaks of his husband in a noble and admiring manner, he would have brought credibility and maturity to our Council, and serve as a great example for young members of the LGBTQA+ community who focus on their differences from heterosexuals and, often (as are possibly true of my cousins), some members of their families who are not accepting of them as valuable people and who are judgmental toward them and their health.

    As a delegate from Ward 6, I was torn between my friend, Abdirizak Bihi, and my Council Member Jamal Osman. Osman has indicated policy approaches with which I agree, and he has written me a couple of letters which indicate his interest in my thoughts, despite his staff not being the best at getting back to me on needs associated with my city-related business involving commerce and licensing. That said, when I have finally spoken to his staff, they were amiable, though not timely. I encourage making more use of college seniors and graduate students as volunteers and interns whose interest in civics and government would possibly excuse the low or no payments for their services. This would do much to speed up service in the City and ward off concerns for the reputation and competence of both Council Members and their staffs. As a lifelong volunteer in non-profits and civic-related activities from an affluent family, though in poverty, I encourage people to volunteer and assist toward development of both a better community and a better commercial society.

    Abdirizak Bihi and I have a history, and I appreciate his intelligence, good humor, and long devotion to the Ward 6 community. I have enjoyed many conversations with him, and see his maturity and skills as an executive and radio personality at KFAI Radio’s Somali Talk Radio Program. Minnesota State Representative Mohamud Noor and I appeared together on Somali Talk on May 14, 2018 to discuss mental health and autism, which are two very important issues not only in the Somali community, but more broadly throughout our community and nationwide. the National Institute of Health published a report in 2019 which indicates that 20.6% of Americans experience one or more of the 300 medical conditions in the fields of psychology and psychiatry. I believe the number would be higher were people to be more rational and not stigmatize this area of health. I have been a patient for forty-one years due to depression, anxiety, and PTSD resulting both from natural realities of my biochemistry and also due to severe physical, sexual and other abuse from age 8 and onward. Bihi’s consideration for this topic is important, along with his work in the community, outside of his role as a radio talk show host, to bring in a variety of cultural and vocational programs, instituting them as anchors in our society on behalf of the mostly East African community, but welcoming people from other ethnic and racial cohorts, as well. He is logical, communicates at a very high level, and has worked with people from a very economically diverse community as well as people from the labor, professional, and business communities.

    The Mayor’s race was not covered in this article. Possibly, this was due to editorial concerns for focus and space. As a delegate, Jacob Frey, with whom I also have a history and broad awareness, is my first ranked choice to continue on as Mayor. Frey is an attorney and has served as both a member of the old Senate District 59 DFL Executive Committee, and has successfully served as Council Member for Ward 3. He brings with him an understanding of law, business, and social concerns. While many people have castigated him about his response to the May 2020 looting and riots, I see that as a momentary issue involving both the Governor’s responsibility to call on the National Guard. Frey is in favor of controls over bad police officers.

    Many members of our community do not understand that neither the Mayor ,nor the Chief of Police, have the ability to control the recklessness of the current Minneapolis Police Officers’ Federation in terms of their willingness to vigorously support officers who bring down the reputation of the entire profession. State laws currently interfere with an executive’s ability to easily and effectively disarm and dispose of officers who are a problem to the community, and to the reputation of great officers and the departments on which they serve. Jacob Frey’s intelligence, stability, authenticity, and vigor are highlights of my reasons for supporting and endorsing him. His work to find an alternative to the base nature of some newer and longer term officers is a sign of good reasoning and thoughtfulness. I say this as the eldest nephew of a retired police officer, and as one who has known of and respected the work of one of my dad’s friend who was a U.S. Marshal at the highest level of service to the U.S. and international communities; and as one with a very warm and respectful regard for a retired FBI Special Agent and former MN BCA Superintendent and Minnesota Commissioner of Public Safety, Paul Tschida, who has long since retired and lives in Saint Paul, Minnesota.

  2. What happens in November with so many races which have no endorsement? Does that mean all the candidates running will still be on the ballot? Also for Ward 7 I want to vote for Teqen instead of Lisa Goodman in the general election. She has been in there too long and I want a person who is true progressive in there. Lisa has only a 12% progressive rating. Teqen says he is still running. Does that mean I will have to write him in on the ballot? I think having some few delegates choose who is on the ballot is very undemocratic. I think Ranked Choice is okay for primary or general election, but not for endorsements.

    1. The endorsement has no impact on who gets on the ballot. Any candidate that qualifies for the ballot can run regardless of whether they were endorsed.

      1. And hopefully some of them do run without the endorsement. Some don’t have computers or internet and the endorsement process tends to bring out the activists in both parties and candidates who were able to push their supporters to get out tend to win.
        With ranked choice voting it will be an interesting general election.

Leave a comment