Nonprofit, nonpartisan journalism. Supported by readers.

Donate

Rep. Phyllis Kahn faces critical test at reconvened caucus

Phyllis KahnRep. Phyllis Kahn

Minneapolis School Board Member Mohamud Noor will likely get a bump in support Wednesday evening in a competitive state House race against incumbent Rep. Phyllis Kahn as both campaigns vie to send their supporters to the district’s DFL endorsing convention in April.  

Democratic activists will gather at the University of Minnesota to complete work that was halted when a precinct caucus meeting in the predominantly Somali Cedar-Riverside neighborhood broke out in violence two weeks ago. Noor had overwhelming support at that initial caucus, and picked up nearly every delegate at a separate caucus in another Somali neighborhood that night.

Both caucuses on Feb. 4 broke out in violence. While activists in the Seward neighborhood were able to finish their work, the caucus at the Brian Coyle Community Center in the Cedar-Riverside neighborhood ended abruptly after a brawl broke out and police shut down the event. One activist was later sent to the hospital and was treated for a concussion.

The reconvened caucus will be critical in the contentious race for a Minneapolis state House seat. Tighter restrictions will be in place at the reconvened caucus, after allegations of threats and bullying plagued the initial caucus event.

“The people of this precinct deserve to have their voices heard in a process free of intimidation, threats, and physical violence,” Kahn and Noor said in a joint statement shortly after the caucus dispute. “While we may disagree on who is best fit to serve this district in the Legislature, one thing we do agree upon is that these acts of violence have no place in our party.”

Candidates make their case

Each candidate has been making their pitch to potential delegates as to why they would be the best representative for the House district, which includes parts of the Cedar-Riverside, Seward and Prospect Park neighborhoods and the University of Minnesota campus.

Kahn says she’s done a good job representing the Somali community in the House, pointing to her work to push the reconditioning of the Brian Coyle Community Center and support for the Human Rights Commission, inner-city parks and urban gardening for the immigrant community.

Mohamud Noor
Noor for State Senate Facebook pageMohamud Noor

She also noted her 42-year seniority in the lower chamber and work on statewide issues. Kahn currently chairs the House Legacy Committee, which works to divvy up dedicated sales tax dollars to arts and conservation projects. “I would do a better job for my community, for my district and for the state,” Kahn said.

Kahn criticized Noor for leaving the Minneapolis School Board to run against her shortly after being appointed by the board. Noor joined the board after the death of Hussein Samatar, winning that position over Ubah Jama, Samatar’s widow. Kahn said if Noor’s main issue is education, he could have much more influence on the board than as a freshman member of the Legislature.

Noor said the school board was aware he would be competing in the legislative race. “My focus has always been going to the Legislature so that I can serve this district,” Noor said. “They knew about it a long time ago. It wasn’t something that was created yesterday.”

He said the demographics and character of the district have changed a lot since Kahn was first elected in 1972. In the Legislature, Noor said, he would work to tackle the “opportunity” and education gaps, as well as promote graduate-school grants and take on the issue of rising tuition costs.

He said he would also address growing safety concerns for both students and residents in the district. “I think there’s an opportunity here to discuss what are the priorities of the district,” Noor said. “I think I can bring that leadership.”

A fight for delegates

At the heart of the event is who will get the lion’s share of 43 remaining delegates and alternates that will be sent to the DFL endorsing convention this spring. The other precinct caucuses in the House race were able to complete their work.

Turnout was low in several precincts near the university that tend to break strongly in Kahn’s favor, she noted, while the two precincts in Somali neighborhoods saw more attendees than could become delegates.

It’s almost certain that neither campaign has reached the 60-percent delegate support required to lock the endorsement, but both camps could likely block the nod if the battle draws out.

“I think that we’re confident that we’re over the 40 percent threshold and are closer to 50 percent,” Noor spokesman Ben Fribley said in an interview. Kahn also said she felt confident she has enough support going into the convention. She plans to abide by the DFL endorsement.

“I’ve always said that I would abide by the endorsement, and I always have abided by the endorsement,” Kahn said.

Noor wouldn’t commit to abiding by the endorsement, should one occur. “It’s too early for me to say that,” Noor said. “One step at a time.”

Tighter rules

The DFL Party, with agreement from both campaigns, opted to move the caucus to the university’s Coffman Memorial Union to handle what’s anticipated to be a large crowd. About 300 people attended the initial caucus at the Brian Coyle Community Center. Bus transport will be provided for people wishing to attend from the center, and Noor has arranged some transportation for his supporters.

DFL officials will also enforce rules that require people attending precinct caucuses to prove their residency by providing a government-issued identification or a utility bill. Vouching will not be allowed.

Usually enforcing the rules isn’t needed at a community meeting like precinct caucuses, but there was at least one challenge of a caucus-goer’s residency at the first event. There will be no unauthorized access to the caucus floor, and neither side can carry signs or hand out campaign flyers.

The caucus will also be chaired by four people from outside of the district, including DFL Party Chairman Ken Martin, former Minneapolis Mayor R.T. Rybak and former St. Paul City Councilman Melvin Carter. One of the central arguments in the previous caucus was over who would chair the caucus.

“Any attempts to influence this process with threats, intimidation coercion or physical violence is prohibited,” the official rules for the event say, and anyone who breaks those rules could be “banned from official DFL Party activities” or face criminal prosecution.

You can also learn about all our free newsletter options.

Comments (5)

  1. Submitted by beryl john-knudson on 02/19/2014 - 12:21 pm.

    Dog fights legal now?

    Is this the same Kahn who stole lit drops and lawn signs from her opponent during one past campaign?

    Seems like Minnesota from both sides now, have grubby issues rising with the ”other’ party setting up a paper-doll cut-out candidate sans policy to challenge Franken?

    It’s not the parties we once knew or what? Minnesota Nice…think twice.

    • Submitted by Steve Titterud on 02/19/2014 - 01:28 pm.

      Yup, it’s the same Phyllis Kahn.

      http://www.fraterslibertas.com/2004_09_01_archive.html#109598081262646998

      I would also like to know who was behind hiring people to show up and disrupt that DFL meeting, and who provided the funds. http://www.minnpost.com/politics-policy/2014/02/allegations-threats-bullying-follow-cedar-riverside-caucus-brawl

      Disturbing also: Ms. Kahn’s comment on the injury to a person at that event, “Kahn dismissed Omar’s injuries, acknowledging that she didn’t know whether Omar had been sent to the hospital and had the forms to prove a concussion. “I participated in the process when it was much more unfriendly to women than that,” Kahn said, describing a time she said she got the equivalent of a death threat. “Once that has happened, what’s a punch?”

      A “…what’s a punch?” attitude is completely unacceptable, no matter Ms. Kahn’s previous experience.

      Phyllis Kahn has had an important and valuable voice for many long years. We appreciate her service. We should thank her.

      Then, she should step aside, bow out, and enjoy her retirement.

  2. Submitted by Bill Gleason on 02/19/2014 - 01:38 pm.

    Just for the record …

    “In 2004, Kahn was charged with theft for removal of Republican campaign literature from doorsteps of several houses. The charges were dropped when she agreed to pay a $200 fine.”

    link: http://ow.ly/tNjx7

    She also immediately apologized to her opponent. I have not heard of any further instances of this kind of behavior.

    I listened to Ms. Kahn spar with three right wingers – males of course – on a radio show yesterday morning. She more than held her own. She is still a very sharp cookie and certainly deserves re-election.

  3. Submitted by David Fehlan on 02/19/2014 - 03:54 pm.

    Kahn

    I don’t know what the ‘equivalent of a death threat’ is, but her dismissive comment about a punch (which apparently caused a concussion) seems to be part of a pattern of doing or saying just about anything she pleases, and if she’s caught, she apologizes and everything is supposed to be OK.

    In addition to the conviction for stealing campaign literature several years ago, she also said someone at City Hall “should be executed” for long lines at a polling place (election 2012).

    It’s time for her to go.

  4. Submitted by craig furguson on 02/20/2014 - 04:55 am.

    Kahn!

    OK, excuse the Star Trek reference.

    42 years is enough for her turn at the chair, that is longer than most careers. Thank her service and it’s time for some new ideas and new blood reflective of the community.

Leave a Reply